4 ms·
U.S. will soon stop Chinese companies from using American clouds for AI training
- wg0 3y agoSlower chips elsewhere will take longer to train a model but not exponentially longer.
- credit_guy 3y agoNot initially. In time there might be a compounding effect. During the Cold War there was a time in the 50's when the Soviet Union was running neck and neck with the US. Famously they were the first to launch a satellite. A few decades later and the technological gap was so large that the US seemed to be from an alien world compared to the Soviet Union.
- kkzz99 3y agoWhich is very ironic, when you compare 1st tier chinese cities with 1st tier US cities, you could probably say the same thing.
- hulitu 3y ago> A few decades later and the technological gap was so large that the US seemed to be from an alien world compared to the Soviet Union. You shouldn't believe everything you read.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>A few decades later and the technological gap was so large that the US seemed to be from an alien world compared to the Soviet Union. Only for consumer tech, not military. Also, as the war in Ukraine proves, you don't need cutting edge chips to inflict worlds of pain on another country, but 100+ year old tech of mortar cannons and shells are more than enough. Plus, high tech Russian weapons use commercial off the shelf chips from the west that you can't stop them buying off the free market anyway. An Arduino or Raspberry Pi could very easily guide a bomb. You don't need an Nvidia A100 for that.
- hker 3y ago> Also, as the war in Ukraine proves, you don't need cutting edge chips to inflict worlds of pain on another country, but 100+ year old tech of mortar cannons and shells are more than enough. Worth noting the difference in scale between Russia (1.3m active personnel) and Ukraine (0.2m active personnel), the West are not directly participating in the battlefields (due to nuclear threats), and that Russia is connected to Ukraine by land. For the Chinese case, the US has been very clear about sending armies to defend Taiwan, which is separated from China by sea. So a technological gap can be a sufficient deterrent for the Chinese case, while less so for the Russian case.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- navigate8310 3y agoWhy do you believe that nuclear concerns wouldn't arise if China were facing significant setbacks in attempting a conquest of Taiwan?
- adriancr 3y agoIt's hard to see China (or anyone else) using nuclear weapons without similar response or worse. So they would go from attempting to conquer a new piece of land via conventional war that they can withdraw from at any point if losing to facing destruction. They've lost wars like vietnam and withdrawn after declaring victory, so it's not like they are suicidal if they dont get their way.
- hker 3y agoChina has a No First Use policy on nuclear weapons. Russia threatens to use nuclear, even without being hit with nuclear.
- baybal2 3y ago[dead]
- frozenport 3y ago
- rdtsc 3y agoIndeed. By the 1970s they started to abandon their native computing technologies and just started blatantly copying western ones.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoThis is a great way of inducing increased technological competence in countries outside the US.
- halJordan 3y agoSure; ofc. That's not the point. Your suggestion is just as likely to fail and stumble as any other suggestion. This has been the rallying cry of the Chamber of Commerce and big businesses since the dawn of time to argue against national security concerns in favor of big profits, so forgive me if trite regurgitation is unconvincing.
- odyssey7 3y agoIf the US is hoping to promote free-market policies, then increasing demand for technological innovation within China is a likely objective of this policy. For an example of the theoretical framework being discussed by experts, here is an article from Stanford in which the West's recent competitive advantage in technological innovation is attributed to free markets. The implication is that a country would need to operate a free market in order to become a global leader in technological innovation. https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/how-innovation-drives-economic-growth https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/how-innovation-drives-...
- Baguette5242 3y agoThe 30,000th wake-up call for EU. Spoiler alert: it will still not wake up.
- kkzz99 3y agoCorrect, the US is not a reliable partner and should be viewed very warily.
- Baguette5242 3y agoAbsolutely. Hold my beer while I buy another round of F35.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoThe EU didn't wake up to the massively critical gas dependency on Russia, what makes you think it will wake up to core tech dependency to the US. That ship has sailed for the EU. We just accepted that all the cool SW comes from the US and we just buy it from them instead of making our own. Who cares about SW jobs in the EU anyway?
- Baguette5242 3y agoCompletely agree.
- wg0 3y agoHow the EU will wake up is the basic question. Capital allocation won't happen until there's some value in it. At the moment, capital, skilled labour all is available to at least start building chips that if not rival but are sufficiently advanced for day to day usage such as desktops and laptops to begin with. But they won't be cost effective, might be around the same price as an Intel/AMD/ARM chip. Being new, the adoption would be slow as well. Only way to change that would be for the EU to ban imported chips so that there's no way for the consumers but to buy local which amounts to trade war. Therefore, I don't think so there are much (rational) choices as of now.
- 3y ago
- CompYOUT 3y agoIt should have ALWAYS been this way. Now do this for our Farmland and our Homes. Said EVERYONE.
- bdcravens 3y agoI'd first like to see restrictions related to corporate ownership of those resources. Food quality has gone down, and housing prices have gone up, due to the interests at odds with smaller ownership.
- Log_out_ 3y agoWhatever happens, limiting food exports to any country is non discuss able. That is the old ugly world of pre ww1 were empires starved out there enemies unpunished. That road has given birth to a monstrous century.
- kelipso 3y agoWhat do you imagine sanctions to be exactly?
- interactivecode 3y agoAnd the moment china stops US companies from buying silicon, the US will throw a fit.
- Our_Benefactors 3y ago> And the moment china stops US companies from buying silicon, the US will throw a fit. Citation needed. Taiwan != China, and domestic Chinese chip production does not produce anything unique or strategically important.
- unstatusthequo 3y agoWhy bother? They’ll just wait for the U.S. to train something then attack until they exfiltrate it. IP means nothing to them.
- nubinetwork 3y agoThat's fine, they can just pull a bytespider and move their equipment to Singaporean IP addresses. (Or any country for that matter)
- hustwindmaple1 3y agoIt's so easy to just create a foreign entity and get access to American Clouds these days ....
- costco 3y agoThe Commerce Department is asking for mandatory KYC for cloud services. This is weird and the kind of thing that authoritarian countries do. Why must all actions be tied to a registered identity?