3 ms·
Another possibility is `.zz`, which technically can be a ccTLD but it's a user-assigned ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code, and its last position makes extremely impossibl
by lifthrasiir 3y ago
Another possibility is `.zz`, which technically can be a ccTLD but it's a user-assigned ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code, and its last position makes extremely impossible for it to be repurposed as a valid code even in that setting. In comparison, some user-assigned codes like `XZ` are often used for temporary country codes so `.xz` would be less appropriate.
It seems that ICANN did consider this choice among others, but reject for the lack of meaningfulness:
> The qualitative assessment on the latter properties was performed in the six United Nations languages (Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish). [...] Many candidate strings were deemed unsuitable due to their lack of meaningfulness. [...] In this evaluation, only two candidates emerged as broadly meeting the assessment criteria across the assessed languages. These were “INTERNAL” and “PRIVATE”. Some weaknesses were identified for both of these candidates. [...]
I wonder if this means that they only scored the highest among others and all candidate strings were indeed unsuitable, but that they had to pick one anyway. I'm not even sure that laypersons can relate `.internal` with the stuff for "internal" uses.
- unclet 3y agoI opposite to use the `.zz`. Instead, I think this should be assigned as new TLD domain for all people live in any country, because it is a reserved ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code, and will not be assigned to any country. It's the best convenient TLD for human on the earth.
- matrss 3y agoI consider .xyz to be a good TLD for that purpose already, but .zz would be nice too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lifthrasiir 3y agoThere is not much to gain from having a new two-letter gTLD instead of existing all-purpose three-letter TLDs (say, `.com`, `.ooo` or `.xyz`). Especially given that every TLD needs a registry, and `.zz` would be a particularly extra-special gTLD that needs a special procedure to select the registry. Better to make it a reserved TLD if it is ever going to be used.