2 ms·
> DACA is an exception for people who were already in violation of the law, no? Are you really going to try to tell me that a 2-year-old who was brought to the
by kelnos 3y ago
> DACA is an exception for people who were already in violation of the law, no?
Are you really going to try to tell me that a 2-year-old who was brought to the US by their parents and then stayed here into adulthood was "in violation of the law"?
While I agree that DACA isn't representative of common situations US immigrants (legal and illegal) end up in, I think it's a fine illustration of how our immigration system is broken. If we can't even find a pathway to permanent residency and citizenship for people in that situation (not to mention the constant threat of DACA being scrapped entirely if political winds change), who have only ever known the US as a home... well, it's pretty easy to question the rest of the system then.
> Refugee status is meant to be a last resort for people who flee in fear for their lives
I think you underestimate the quantity of political persecution outside the US. Remember that this isn't just prominent public figures who have tried to stand up against an oppressive regime and failed. Any average citizen in a situation like that could end up in a precarious situation like that. And political persecution is just one reason someone might fear for their lives to the point where they believe they need to leave their country.
But really, we don't need to limit ourselves to DACA or refugees to find serious issues with the US immigration system. The H1-B visa is broken; it's gamed by "consulting" companies to mint modern-day indentured servants. The green card process is ridiculous; imagine applying for permanent residency and being told that the wait time meant you'd get it after you were dead, just because you were born in a particular country, not because of anything else about you that actually matters.
- jksflkjl3jk3 3y ago> Are you really going to try to tell me that a 2-year-old who was brought to the US by their parents and then stayed here into adulthood was "in violation of the law"? Yes? Why would you argue otherwise?
- lmm 3y ago> Are you really going to try to tell me that a 2-year-old who was brought to the US by their parents and then stayed here into adulthood was "in violation of the law"? Yes. You can blame their parents for giving them an upbringing unsuited to their citizenship, but that doesn't make their position any more legitimate. It's no different from a child raised in a mafia family, who was brought up to break the law before they even knew they were doing so, for whom criminality is the only way they know to live - we don't hold them responsible for their crimes from back when they were too young to know what they were doing, but we do expect them to stop. > I think you underestimate the quantity of political persecution outside the US. Remember that this isn't just prominent public figures who have tried to stand up against an oppressive regime and failed. Any average citizen in a situation like that could end up in a precarious situation like that. And political persecution is just one reason someone might fear for their lives to the point where they believe they need to leave their country. I don't see how any of that changes what I wrote? Yes, there may be any number of reasons someone might end up in legitimate fear for their lives. But either they are genuinely fleeing for their lives (for whatever reason) or they are not refugees.