2 ms·
Our immigration system is indeed hopelessly broken. While there's a lot here about O-1 being fairly objective and checklist-based (no idea if that's actually t
by kelnos 3y ago
Our immigration system is indeed hopelessly broken. While there's a lot here about O-1 being fairly objective and checklist-based (no idea if that's actually true, just taking some comments here at face value), other visa situations can be arbitrary and opaque. And don't get me started on the ridiculous, arbitrary, capricious green card process.
> There is no obligation for the US, or any country, to turn something as important as determining whether someone is eligible to enter the country
I have the opposite opinion. Borders should be much more open, and people should stop whining so much about immigration. Nearly everyone -- aside from the relatively small number of Native peoples -- in the US is an immigrant, or the descendant of immigrants. We are all here because our ancestors forced their way here, killing and destroying wherever they went.
The idea that we have some natural right to decide who comes and goes is entirely laughable to me. I get that we should have some controls in place for at least logistical and security reasons. But our immigration restrictions go far beyond that. And again, let's not pretend it's some natural right of ours to do. We get to do it because we've had more guns than other people who wanted to be here and "own" the land.
Also remember that this is not the normal or common state of things. The internationally-recognized passport system we take for granted has existed for barely a century[0]. Before that it was a patchwork of various systems (sometimes just the honor system) and much of what we'd call "illegal immigration" today was the status quo. On top of that, the US's restrictive immigration system has existed for an even shorter time; when my great-grandparents immigrated about 115 years ago, all that was required was they enter through an official port of entry and truthfully declare who they were and where they were from. They didn't have to have a visa, or apply for permanent residency. My great-grandfather became a citizen about 15 years later shortly after applying and providing a record of his original arrival in the country.
Meanwhile, today, adults who were brought here by their parents as toddlers ("illegally" -- like a 2 year old has the capacity to do something illegal) can't even get legal residency or citizenship. If that's not hopelessly broken, I don't know what is.
The funny thing is that we're talking about this in the context of someone suggesting that OP "hacked" a broken system to get a visa. But it sounds like the O-1 system is pretty functional and is working as designed. There's a list of criteria, and a lot of explanation as to what is and isn't covered under those criteria. You document, make your case for why you fit the criteria, and apply. USCIS makes a decision (and pretty quickly, at least in this case!), probably based on a checklist, by people who likely don't really understand the nuances of any particular industry or profession or academic discipline to make any sort of value judgment on the application, beyond the checklist and the case being made. That... seems exactly how it should be? A transparent process with well-defined criteria for acceptance? (You may disagree with the criteria, or the list of things that qualify, but that's a different matter.)
[0] (The idea of passports have existed at least for a couple thousand years, of course, but in the earliest days they were more like a hand-written letter asking, "please allow my subject, Bob, to pass safely through your lands, signed, King Larry".)
- TMWNN 3y ago>Borders should be much more open I don't disagree! I think the US ought to have open borders with Canada, for example, with immediate work rights for anyone who has been a citizen for, say, 18 years. In an ideal world we would be able to institute the Wall Street Journal's longtime mantra of "We shall have open borders". But that cannot happen without corresponding changes to domestic welfare policies, among other things. >I have the opposite opinion. Borders should be much more open, and people should stop whining so much about immigration. Nearly everyone -- aside from the relatively small number of Native peoples -- in the US is an immigrant, or the descendant of immigrants. We are all here because our ancestors forced their way here, killing and destroying wherever they went. Sorry, you are going to have to do better than this sort of "We live in a society"-level rhetoric. If Burundi tomorrow invades the US with superior military forces and every Burundian moves here, I may not like it but that's how things have worked for the entirety of human history minus the last few decades. >On top of that, the US's restrictive immigration system has existed for an even shorter time; when my great-grandparents immigrated about 115 years ago, all that was required was they enter through an official port of entry and truthfully declare who they were and where they were from. Those stories always omit the details. Every single person who came through Ellis Island * had passed a medical inspection * had proof of having enough resources to pay for their upkeep in the US, or a US financial sponsor guaranteeing same * was turned away if failing any of the above tests, with no possibility of appeal I, for one, am very much in favor of reinstating such barriers to entering the US. PS - One more thing: Every single person who came through Ellis Island was coming to a country with an enormous demand for unskilled labor. This is no longer true. >Meanwhile, today, adults who were brought here by their parents as toddlers ("illegally" -- like a 2 year old has the capacity to do something illegal) can't even get legal residency or citizenship. If that's not hopelessly broken, I don't know what is. The parents of those toddlers broke the law, for themselves and for children they brought along. That does not mean that the toddlers themselves are criminals. That also does not mean that they are entitled to the legal and financial rewards of US residency, either. Or that a president can with the stroke of a pen but without the concurrence of Congress create an entire legal infrastructure permitting their legal residency, one which the subsequent president somehow cannot dismantle in the same way. I hope that some process can be devised to grant such people legal US residency, but it has to occur through a law duly passed by Congress, and in the context of other changes; especially, but not only, a strengthening of the southern border and crackdowns on visa overstays. >The funny thing is that we're talking about this in the context of someone suggesting that OP "hacked" a broken system to get a visa. But it sounds like the O-1 system is pretty functional and is working as designed. As I said elsewhere, I don't disagree with this either! My disagreement was and is with the reply by hn_throwaway_99 to the original post stating that someone being able to use the O-1 system in this way is proof that the US immigration system is "hopelessly broken", by which of course he means "Requiring such steps is outrageous and unfair". I would love a system in which everyone entering the US had to comply with the O-1 or some equivalent thereof.