6 ms·
Schools are using surveillance tech to catch students vaping
- nickthegreek 3y agoSmoking Detectors were the original surveillance tech for the last version of this vice. I’m a pretty big privacy advocate but I fail to see the issue here. It sounds like the real issue here is the insane punishment for a single infraction.
- cnst 3y agoPunishment should be proportional with the difficulty of finding the violators and enforcing the statutes. There's far too many instances where people simply get away with smoking, so, for those instances where solid proof is available that the person did smoke, they should, indeed, be punished for violating other people's right to pollution-free air on their first offence. Otherwise, these people will simply learn to simply avoid the spots where they could be caught and reprimanded, whilst continuing to create a nuisance elsewhere, entirely defeating the effectiveness of enforcement.
- dfee 3y agoAgree completely. We shouldn’t invest much effort in finding violators or enforcing statutes that prevent no real harm. So rather than introducing the equivalent of chewing gum bans like Singapore did, let’s move on.
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt's fun to pair this up with the article from a day ago about the air pollution over Alberta's oil sands[1]. I wonder what consequence those oil companies will face for violating our "right to pollution-free air". I would be surprised if it's even a (relative small) fine. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39137430 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39137430
- shusfuejdn 3y ago[dead]
- LordDragonfang 3y agoI can't help but feel like the constant comparisons between US high schools and prisons are apt here. Monitoring students' bathroom use and threatening the kids' whole future, including criminal charges for students who are, by their own admission, legal adults - all for using a totally legal mild stimulant that has no secondhand effects on anyone else.
- latency-guy2 3y agoMaybe you can phrase your hyperbole a bit better when it comes to smoking around children. I do not think it is an insurmountable task for a legal adult take their recreational drugs at home. Maybe legal adults can take responsibility of their future, rather than risking it on breaking rules that are pretty explicit, so much so that in any other workplace or public area that prohibits smoking incurs fines at the least, and jail time for repeat offenders.
- donatj 3y agoDid you attend a modern American school, with metal detectors, transparent backpacks and zero tolerance policies? It's really not hyperbole. It's an apt comparison.
- latency-guy2 3y ago> Did you attend a modern American school, with metal detectors, transparent backpacks and zero tolerance policies? Not all those qualities, but we did have metal detectors. > It's really not hyperbole. It's an apt comparison. I guess my standards are lower compared to you, I associate prison with complete lack of freedom where you cannot leave at the end of the day, most other things are representations of that. School was generally fine, and even quite fun some days for myself.
- handoflixue 3y agoI think it's perfectly reasonable to complain about unequal enforcement. My workplace has a "smoking area" dedicated to drug use, and allows "smoke breaks" for the sole purpose of consuming said drugs. We have places called "bars" that exist for the sole purpose of taking drugs in public. Are we actually giving these students equal opportunities to consume it legally, or are we saying "you're a prisoner for 8 hours, and we're going to abuse that authority to deny you any access to your perfectly legal recreational activities during that period"? If we're going to crack down and say kids should go 8 hours without drugs, shouldn't we be OK enforcing that on the adults in the workplace, too? Why are we holding these students to a higher standard? Why are we spending thousands of dollars on enforcing the rules for students, and nothing on the rest of society?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThis just harms kids and ruins their public record for nothing and awards lucrative contracts to these companies. Eventually kids will just switch to zyn or some other smokeless spitless product. Then what is the school going to do, full cavity search and fishhook your mouth?
- shusfuejdn 3y ago[dead]
- ethanbond 3y agoWell the enforcement could happen at a different, more effective level of our society. It’s nontrivial to produce and mass-market nicotine products, for example.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoThere is no enforcement that can stop it because a kid can just pay cash for a product from someone older who bought it legally.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoI've said it before and I will continue to say it. America's "justice" system serves only to effect vengeance against those the rulemakers deem punishment-worthy.
- mustacheemperor 3y ago>Schools nationwide have invested millions of dollars in the monitoring technology, including federal COVID-19 emergency relief money meant to help schools through the pandemic and aid students’ academic recovery. Marketing materials have noted the sensors, at a cost of over $1,000 each, could help fight the virus by checking air quality. >Students found vaping also can receive a misdemeanor citation and be fined up to $100. Students found with vapes containing THC, the chemical that makes marijuana users feel high, can be arrested on felony charges. At least 90 students in Tyler have faced misdemeanor or felony charges. Imagine getting a felony as a high school senior for getting caught vaping weed by a sensor bought for a thousand bucks in COVID-19 emergency relief funds.
- ethanbond 3y agoThis is why the only viable solution to avoid tyranny is aggressive safeguarding of democratic institutions and the gradual (and continuous) alignment of laws with our actual desires as a society. The technology for authoritarianism will continue to get cheaper and continue to proliferate. There’s no way to prevent that.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoI'm pretty sure we proletariat lost on all fronts. I advocate we give up on change via text official routes (which tends to absorb as much energy as anyone can throw at the project while producing epsilon results, barring the odd tournament-market victor [Britney Spears, Neil deGrasse Tyson for examples]), and teach our children and each other the importance of undermining and subverting the dominant control structures at every turn.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoThey thought of that. But with the current tech, the solution is a matter of implementing a social credit (or similar) system. Western nations will have this eventually, its inevitable. With it in place, you can achieve fine grain continuous compliance of any behavior. Scary from the populace pov, but an absolute miracle from the pov of the powerful.
- TheFreim 3y agoGetting caught breaking the rules, and possibly the law, and instead of taking responsibility she blames surveillance that amounts to little more than a smoke detector paired with camera systems that are already in place in many (most?) schools. I'm sympathetic with arguments against a lot of the surveillance we see in schools, but it does a great disservice to the anti-surveillance position when you try to use an example where it correctly identifies genuine misconduct. The girl in the article says that this sort of thing doesn't work, yet in the next sentence she admits that it actually did work, "I’m never going to do something like that again, because the repercussions I faced were horrible." The system correctly identified her and as a result she decided to not partake in such behavior in the future. This reads like a young kid who doesn't think her actions should have consequences.
- robobro 3y ago[flagged]
- dfee 3y agoWhether it finds what’s defined as misconduct (or not) is irrelevant. It’s dragnet surveillance: there are inevitably false positives ex picked up. But also, isn’t this a sort of victimless crime? Or is she, herself, the victim? It’s unclear.
- TheFreim 3y ago> It’s dragnet surveillance: there are inevitably false positives ex picked up. False positives would only be a problem depending on how exactly the evidence is used. In the first example in the article Iglesias says she learned about the sensors in her own school when an admin came to the restroom after it was triggered. Despite it being triggered by actual vaping, she notes that the admin "ultimately let all the students go" which seems to indicate that, at that school, it wasn't being used blindly to convict students. Could this system be abused or over relied upon? Definitely, but it doesn't seem that false positives are an issue if the school administration has appropriate standards of evidence.
- shusfuejdn 3y ago
- dhosek 3y agoWhen I was in high school in the 80s, there was a designated outside area that was the student smoking zone. The school newspaper office was over it and we would occasionally fire paperclips at them with rubber band slingshots. We talked about but never actually did throw water balloons down there, mostly because it seemed likely to result in violent retribution (the paper clips rarely hit their marks or garnered any reaction if they did). One of my teachers smoked in his classroom during the lunch break and when we came into the room (we had him right after lunch), the room positively reeked of cigarette smoke. Young folks today have no idea just how wild the twentieth century was.
- belltaco 3y agoSmoking wasn't banned on planes till 1985. You had smoking and non-smoking sections, but they were only separated by a curtain, same with restaurants. Edit, it was even worse: > In 1988, airlines based in the United States banned smoking on domestic flights of less than two hours, which was extended to domestic flights of less than six hours in February 1990, and to all domestic and international flights in 2000
- EA-3167 3y ago> Smoking wasn't banned on planes till 1985. You had smoking and non-smoking sections, but they were only separated by a curtain, same with restaurants. Can confirm, I still remember playing with the in-seat ashtrays and my mother telling me to stop, and then the whole rigamarole with the "smoking" and "non-smoking" sections and lights. Hell I remember my father buying Marlboro reds from an old vending machine that was entirely mechanical.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoThere are still a few of these cigarette vending machines around in bars and they were always fun to use back when I was a smoker 5-10 years ago. The ones I got to use had a pull style activation that was quite satisfying as it required a decent yank to dispense the pack.
- teeray 3y agoI wonder how well these will work through the tupperware kids will duct tape around them?
- 15155 3y agoOr the can of hairspray, WD40, or soda they empty directly into them.
- pbj1968 3y agoDear God, we have got to let some of this go. Kids deserve a chance to be a little rascal and grow out of it. The authorities can’t even check to see if the door is actually locked until they’ve been actively murdered one by one for an hour.