4 ms·
Men drifted to the right due to a vacuum. I'm reasoning from a European perspective but the pattern is fairly universal. In the 80s-90s, almost all men were pr
by iteratethis 3y ago
Men drifted to the right due to a vacuum. I'm reasoning from a European perspective but the pattern is fairly universal.
In the 80s-90s, almost all men were progressive. The progressive movement was a labor movement fighting for the plight of the lower class which largely consisted of blue collar men. There was ample room to improve the conditions of these men, thus the politics and the demographics align.
Let's pause for a moment here to consider the implication: men are not innately right-wing or conservative.
As of the 90s, the progressive movement dramatically shifted away from working class men to target other groups. Women joined the workforce which rightfully needed attention. Minorities/immigrants. Teachers and other government workers. Pretty much everybody but (white)(blue-collar) men.
Then globalization happened, as well as extensive labor immigration. Both trends have dramatically affected the economic status of these men. Where before non-college educated men had ample access to a tough but honorable job in blue-collar that would earn enough to start a family, now they're in the lower ranks. The underclass.
So not only where these men politically de-emphasized (or even totally abandoned), also economically. And to finish it off, there's the cultural abandonment. A cynical and hostile view of men.
A lot of people fail to acknowledge the above degradation of men's status or even believe it's a good thing. What they fail to realize is that the "patriarchy" concerns the top ranks. Most men are not in the top or in any position of influence at all. Men in the working class, specifically in rural areas, and other sub groups have most definitely taken a huge beating, politically, economically and culturally.
That type of abandonment by progressive politics is what created the vacuum. They feel alienated and not represented, hated even. They may vote conservative out of spite, without even supporting the beliefs. A recent poll of young conservatives showed that the vast majority in fact do not support dialing back abortion rights.
The progressive movement should start caring about men. You can do two things at a time, it's not zero-sum. In fact, it's a no-brainer. Men failing is very bad for women, bettering the plight of men directly benefits women.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI do think mens rights advocates have some valid points, but especially with the blue collar stuff I think most of it is just a classic case of equality feeling like oppression to the privileged. High school grad white men had access to high status jobs because others were excluded, especially foreigners. Now theyre not, so their jobs arent as good. Is the solution really to favor uneducated white men over everyone else again? Or maybe embrace the fact that life generally sucks, and try to improve it for everyone, even if that means some continue to suffer. I agree that the patriarchy does not favor uneducated white men, but it used to, and I think thats a large reason theyre angry.