5 ms·
[sigh/] Obviously, labeling things "Recyclable" satisfies an intense emotional need for many people. Regardless of where the stuff they dump into their "Recyc
by bell-cot 3y ago
[sigh/]
Obviously, labeling things "Recyclable" satisfies an intense emotional need for many people. Regardless of where the stuff they dump into their "Recycling" bins actually ends up.
But at what point would it actually be better - for both the environment and human health - to invent a clean (~no toxic outputs) and efficient-ish way to burn mixed plastic waste as fuel, and to just use that?
- UncleOxidant 3y agoThere used to be a startup near me that was turning plastic into crude oil. Looks like they're still around: https://www.agilyx.com/ https://www.agilyx.com/
- PaulHoule 3y agoPolystyrene is relatively easy to depolymerize with enzymes, catalysts and moderate amounts of heat, see https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acssuschemeng.1c08400 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acssuschemeng.1c08400 The pyrolysis route they are using can be problematic because it produces carcinogenic aromatic compounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benzopyrene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benzopyrene which has a metabolite which is almost a cancer-causing drug. In principle you could pyrolyze plastics all the way down to carbon monoxide + hydrogen syngas and then build that up to molecules you want with C1 chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C1_chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C1_chemistry but most of the people who are trying chemical recycling by pyrolysis are trying to cook the molecules partially so the output fuel is a witches brew rich in hazardous aromatics. There is a lot of research into cleaner processes for chemical recycling such as https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-83659-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-83659-2 and that one at the top but every large scale plant I've seen is a pyrolysis plant that's had to fight with environmentalists to start operations. From the viewpoint of a chemical engineer making fuel is for the birds because gasoline costs 50 cents a pound and (almost) any other chemical costs a lot more than that.
- versteegen 3y ago> Polystyrene is relatively easy to depolymerize with enzymes, catalysts and moderate amounts of heat Wow. The paper from 2022 so surely noone is using this process yet, but are there any plans to? Any idea if it's practical? For expanded polystyrene?
- PaulHoule 3y agoThat paper is not too remarkable, it's (1) the first one I found and (2) it uses extraordinarily mild conditions. The gap between the bench and a commercial factory is immense and there are many areas where people write papers like this for decades but nothing really gets built. I think the usual excuse is that the factory is large enough that it needs to gather waste over a huge area and that transportation of EPS is prohibitively expensive. It doesn't help that styrene monomer is worth only 50 cents a pound, about the same as gasoline.
- jacobolus 3y agoIt would be better to only allow a small list of approved plastics for uses like packaging with much more obvious labeling to distinguish them (e.g. require a particular color or very clear markings), more carefully regulate mixed/composite materials, charge manufacturers an extra cleanup tax for whatever materials they use, and try to carefully regulate many types of single-use plastics out of existence in favor of biodegradable or environmentally neutral alternatives (as a trivial example, there's no good excuse for candy wrappers to involve plastic), and force every municipal trash collector to also collect "compost" including food waste, soiled cardboard, and biodegradable plastics. It should be possible for relatively incompetent consumers to tell at a glance precisely which plastic something is made of and figure out how to sort all of their recyclable plastic waste into 2 or 3 categories. * * * Or at a higher level, there should be some people with significant systems thinking training doing full society-wide audits of the sources and treatment of materials including plastics, and then regulators should be making targeted policy to fix harms (whether environmental, human health, economic, ...), starting with the most significant ones and working their way down from there.
- maxerickson 3y agoIt should be possible for relatively incompetent consumers to tell at a glance precisely which plastic something is made of and figure out how to sort all of their recyclable plastic waste into 2 or 3 categories. Do you honestly think that would be sufficient? I expect you'd get significant amounts of the wrong material in all the bins.
- shados 3y agoPeople can't even properly sort cardboard vs plastic...
- jacobolus 3y agoThis is why we should get rid of as many of the distinct types and uses of plastic as possible, with the remaining ones as non toxic as possible, and some kind of explicit tax on manufacturers to pay whatever is necessary to handle all of the costs of cleanup. If there were 2 types of plastic packaging and they were very obviously visually distinct, it would be much easier for anyone involved in the process to sort them (whether at home or at a recycling plant) compared to the current system with hundreds of distinct types of often visually indistinguishable mixed-material packaging much of which we can't do anything with except chuck it in a landfill.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoGiven that your input stream of plastic waste contains a very large number of toxic inputs, burning it without releasing toxic outputs seems pretty much impossible. It seems a similar level of problem: burning it without releasing toxins and recycling it without incorporating toxins.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoChemistry-ignoramous question: Is there a burn-temperature above which everything dangerous is basically rendered inert? I.e., you make stuff so hot that whatever survives is perma-bonded to oxygen, carbon, chlorine, fluorine, etc., and has almost zero chance of reacting with living creatures? (Ignoring radioactive stuff, I mean.)
- PaulHoule 3y agoNot really. Even with a plasma torch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification you need to clean up the syngas to get rid of dioxins with a charcoal filter or something like that. The plasma torch is supposed to convert the organic materials in municipal waste (e.g. food waste, plastic, wood) to syngas and then vitrify the remainder as glass particles that trap toxic heavy metals (you could use it as a material for roads and buildings.) Allegedly you can burn the syngas to make enough electricity to run the torch and still sell some to the grid. I guess you'd want to try to capture mercury before it goes up the stack. They built a few small (like 5 MW) plants to test the idea but attempts to scale up to 50 MW. For a long time the technology belonged to one of Westinghouse's ghosts (like the one that owns the AP1000) but they are still ordering AP1000s but nobody is ordering plasma torches for municipal waste.
- rapjr9 3y agoI asked my local waste disposal company why they don't buy a plasma gasification system and they told me that the plants require so much trash as fuel that to keep them fed they'd have to haul trash from three states. It wasn't affordable to buy one just for local operation. Here's the history of attempts and current projects: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification_commercialization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_gasification_commercial... These are definitely large scale, large area systems and there have been some engineering problems. A few seem to be operating successfully. Even if the net energy production is zero that's better than it being negative. Financing has been a problem also. It still produces CO2 also, so there is that to consider. It greatly reduces hazards in the waste stream though, so it seems better than a landfill. I'm not sure it would be a good idea to turn the glass plus heavy metals that is produced into building or road materials.
- nox101 3y agoLet's call it "recycling theater" like we do for security. Maybe there were good intentions at one point but so much of it seems like marketing now. Most cities only have a few collection spots. It would make way more sense to try to separate the trash at the trash location than asking millions of individual people to try to do it correctly, 30% of which can't do it correctly, 30% of which don't care. I'm not sure I've ever seen a single trash can that has 100% of the correct trash in it, even at a FAANMG company that claims to hire the best and brightest. Then you get ambiguous things like plastic coated paper, marked with a recycle symbol. Or cardboard milk cartons with a plastic cap and plastic infused cardboard (or is it wax?) Sure, maybe you're supposed to cut the cap part out but lots of people don't know, can't be bothered, won't do it. If you want this to actually be effective you really need to do it in as few places as possible, the trash collection companies, where a few inspectors can make sure it's being done correctly and a few reporters can check
- throwway120385 3y agoMaybe we could try reducing or reusing in addition to recycling?
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoRecycling is much more meaningful if it's done by the designers of the recycled thing and not by some third party. I'd like to see a world where if you're not sure, it should go in a pile that gets shipped back to the manufacturer... On their dime if labeling standards weren't met, on your dime if they were. This would give manufacturers a reason to build things in a way where they want the discarded thing back (like how they do with toner cartridges).
- dylan604 3y agoMy recent favorite is Amazon's "recyclable" packaging, but only if you bring it to one of their locations. I've seen other examples of the same thing, but this was the most recent. When you try to claim your packaging is recyclable but make the person jump through those kinds of hoops is not very conducive to having things recycled. It's one of the most obvious BS PR maneuvers