3 ms·
> If it's policy, it's legal. I don't disagree that it's legal and mentioned that in my comment. What I'm claiming is that the way in which the legal system ha
by lxgr 3y ago
> If it's policy, it's legal.
I don't disagree that it's legal and mentioned that in my comment. What I'm claiming is that the way in which the legal system has evolved has incentivized problematic behaviors.
> there's going to be who-knows-how-much embarrassing personal gossip in there, too and that just makes folks look bad
That's what I was referring to by "making discovery more expensive during any hypothetical future lawsuit". Part of that cost is due to legal fees for discovery, but the other part is reputational harm:
The problem here again isn't courts and parties to the lawsuit having access to that data, but rather that it's being explicitly published for the entire world to see and share.
Personal gossip has absolutely no reason to be published as part of a lawsuit, in my view. If it's relevant to the case, make it available to its parties, read it out during the (usually public but non-broadcast) trial etc., but don't put it on an online case filing platform. Get rid of that, and the incentive to delete literally anything that's not legally required to be archived goes away too.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Get rid of that, and the incentive to delete literally anything that's not legally required to be archived goes away too. Not exactly. One of the reasons companies do this is that random employees don't know how laws and courts work. They'll say things without knowing that the words they're using are a term of art with a different meaning in the law than it has the way they're using it, and then write something which would be damning if it was what they actually meant, but it wasn't what they actually meant. Or that sounds damning if taken out of context. Also, sometimes they really are breaking the law without knowing it and not having the evidence of that sitting around isn't really to the company's advantage either. The only real way to prevent companies from wanting to delete it would be to make it so it couldn't be used against them if they kept it.
- lalaithion 3y ago> They'll say things without knowing that the words they're using are a term of art with a different meaning in the law than it has the way they're using And this is what we need to change. We need a presumption that when a non-lawyer says “we should form a cartel with our competitors” that they aren’t implying anything illegal, even though cartels are illegal.
- pixl97 3y agoThis is what the purpose of a trial is, hence the evidence gathering, and rebuttal in court. The best evidence against you is no evidence. Lets jump from civil to criminal law, where you do have the presumption of innocence. Let's say you send a message that says "I'm going to kill Jon with kindness" to someone else on your team . Then the next day Jon ends up violently murdered. Even though the content of your message is one that does not condone any particular violent act, you should 100% expect to be a target of the investigation. This is reasonable. In civil trials where it's not beyond a reasonable doubt, but a preponderance of evidence, these little things could tip the balance out of your favor.
- nullc 3y agoThe issue is that sure you can fight that out in court-- at great cost and expense and risk of being unsuccessful for reasons of pure chance. Or you could just not retain the record and instantly avoid what is potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars in cost for review and argument and millions of dollars of "loss in the expectation". A 1% chance of failing the win in your argument and taking a $100m loss as a result is a million dollar loss in the expectation, and even a darn good legal position will still often have a more than 1% chance of being lost. > these little things could tip the balance out of your favor. Yes, and out of the direction of justice... and certainly at a disproportional cost.
- salawat 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 3y ago> Personal gossip has absolutely no reason to be published as part of a lawsuit, in my view. If it's relevant to the case, make it available to its parties, read it out during the (usually public but non-broadcast) trial etc., but don't put it on an online case filing platform. Get rid of that, and the incentive to delete literally anything that's not legally required to be archived goes away too. The sentence "This seems like a really shitty way to treat our customers," is going to both look bad and be relevant to lots of lawsuits. On the other hand, if a company doesn't have a communications channel in which people can freely say this, they're going to end up treating their customers in shitty ways a lot more.