3 ms·
If there's a tool that an officer can use that retrieves this information, I'd have a problem with that. If the phone is demanded as evidence with proper warran
by dylan604 3y ago
If there's a tool that an officer can use that retrieves this information, I'd have a problem with that. If the phone is demanded as evidence with proper warrant/subpoena, then sure. However, in the cases of a car wreck, I think confiscating the phone as evidence does seem warranted. And admitting that has me in a weird state. With such little consequences for blatantly being distracted, it will not stop. But looking at history, draconian punishment is not a deterrent in other aspects. Addicts are going to do whatever for their fix. Admitting phone addiction exists is probably something too though.
- hooverd 3y agoPersonally, I don't think calling for expanding the surveillance state helps this cause vs advocating for proper pedestrian infrastructure and road design. We've made it really easy to speed and give no heed to pedestrians and other forms of infrastructure.
- dylan604 3y agoI'm thinking bigger than just pedestrians. Distracted drivers are not only affecting pedestrians. Not many pedestrians on open highways.
- amrocha 3y agoI don't know what world you live in that a license plate on your car is ok in terms of privacy, but a phone that reports whether you were using it while driving is a surveillance state.
- owl57 3y agoYou seem to be insisting that such a feature can be mandated without collateral damage for a lot of phone users, including people who never use a phone while driving or even don't drive at all.
- amrocha 3y agoAnd you seem to be insisting that it can't
- owl57 3y agoWell, and what's your plan for the proposed feature? In particular what does your plan say about: 1) phones that allow installation of a custom free OS; 2) phones that are already in use now.
- amrocha 3y agoSoftware updates on Android and iPhones, and if you're one of the 100 people running a custom OS in your phone then you're fine who cares about you
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- amrocha 3y agoDraconian punishments do work for the vast majority of people. Most of Asia has very strict laws against drug use, even weed. If you look at rate of usage, it's a lot lower than more liberal places. But I'm not even saying put people in jail. Just take away their license. They've clearly proven they're not responsible enough to handle driving.
- dylan604 3y agoYou say that as if people will no longer drive when they don't have a license. I can unequivocally say that this absolutely happens, and I'm not asking for a friend. Thinking someone not willing to commit one crime while being able to commit another seems like very strange logic to me.
- amrocha 3y agoOk, then you arrest them when they do that. Most people won't risk getting arrested, even if some would.
- dylan604 3y agoso you're okay with someone being arrested for driving without a license, but not okay with their phone being seized as evidence after causing an accident. you don't think being arrested for driving without some little ID card is a bit draconian?
- amrocha 3y agoOh you're a libertarian. Driving licenses are a government overreach kinda person. I don't think this discussion is gonna go anywhere.