8 ms·
Nancy Pelosi Made $500k from Her Nvidia Bet, Doubling Her Annual Salary
- syspec 3y agoIn this case was there any "insider information", that could have actually helped her decide in late December that Nvidia call options were a good bet? I don't think anything changed in regulation, it was just the rise and boom of AI
- ganoushoreilly 3y agoThere is a large govt program / collaboration announced with MS, Nvidia, and others it is very likely these talks started late last year. That info that it was in the pipe is enough to trade on.
- game_the0ry 3y agoThis is not an anomaly. Pelosi and many others in congress have consistently out performed even the best professional traders over a long period of time. Its not just bc of the AI boom. To think that members of congress do not trade on insider info is naive.
- syspec 3y agoTotally agree with all of this. I just feel that this is a bad example which is likely not related to insider trading so it weakens the case made in the article.
- jessriedel 3y ago"Insider trading" refers to trading on confidential information that was entrusted to employees of a company ("insiders"). Pelosi has access to $10B spy satellite images, which is very different.
- jncfhnb 3y agoCan you cite a source for this claim? Because everything I see suggests otherwise
- godelski 3y agohttps://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-report-2023 https://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-...
- jncfhnb 3y agoI’m not really interested in reading this entire report. This is their first bullet > Congress beat the market, once again. Of 100 trading members, 33% beat SPY with their portfolios. This does not inspire a lot of confidence in their findings. If 33% beat the SPY, then twice as many congress members underperformed. Can you share specific claims that seem relevant?
- godelski 3y ago> Can you share specific claims that seem relevant? I'll admit I'm conflicted here. On one hand, yes, I can and I'd encourage you to just start with looking at the figures since figures say a lot. There's actually not much text and most of the page is figures. But on the other hand, I think there's enough nuance to what's going on that oversimplification can result in a inappropriate dismissal of any claims. Not being a domain expert will only exacerbate any failures to communicate. Certainly the devil is in the details here. FWIW, they do have a tldr. > If 33% beat the SPY, then twice as many congress members underperformed. This being a perfect example. The former does not imply the latter. Nor would the latter imply that there wasn't foul play. First off, there is a third option: matching the SPY. Second, beating the SPY is a proxy metric which is typically used to help identify those that have performed suspiciously well, not those who performed average. It is actually difficult to beat the market, and more so to do it consistently[0]. So I must insist that you use the metric as a guide, not a filter or target. Third: There are many ways to under-perform compared to the market, including not investing. I mention that specific mechanism as one thing the report shows is that there are far fewer filings by Republicans so this is necessary context to properly evaluate some fact like "Democrats beat their Republican colleagues by a massive margin." (Dems ~= 2x Reps in transactions) We must also consider that democrats have fewer members and that >50% of each party's transactions originate from a single member of that party (Ro Khanna (D) and Michael McCaul (R)). There are also multiple vehicles for wealth generation so while stocks should be of interest, it shouldn't be used as the only evidence of manipulation and/or foul play. Fourth: consider what information is marginalized by the metrics. Pareto distribution should be expected, and it is even observed. You must therefore be considerate of aggregates as variance is high (difference between mean and median is large). But I will give you some TLDRs. The report goes into nuance because the claim of insider trading is reliant upon details: - Top 10 returns, in order are: Brian Higgins (D-NY: 239%), Mark Green (R-TN: 122%), Garret Graves (R-LA: 108%), David Rouzer (R-NC: 106%), Seth Moullton (D-MA: 80%), Ron Wyden (D-OR: 79%), John Rutherford (R-FL: 69%), Richard Blumenthal (D-CT: 68%), Nancy Pelosi (D-CA: 66%), Peter Sessions (R-TX: 63%). SPY returns ~=25%. 32 members beat SPY (50/50 split by party) (Note: Higgins holds $100k in NVDA, purchase was from 2021, no sales have been recorded) - 19 congressional members had negative returns, 13 being Republicans. - Kevin Hern (R-OK) stands the most to gain via stocks that correlate with war. 4 of the top 5 most incentivized are Republicans, the other is Pelosi in 4th. Follows power law distribution. - They have a breakdown by transactions that align with members that serve on relevant committees (this is where detail matters and stronger evidence of foul play is drawn from). I would suggest reading or at least giving a quick read rather than relying on me to accurately summarize it for you. Especially if you think there is a bias. I'm sure you can carve out 15-30 minutes if this is actually a topic you care about. If not, I might suggest ensuring your confidence in your existing model appropriately aligns with your domain expertise and time dedicated to becoming informed on the subject. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/14/business/stock-market-2022.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/14/business/stock-market-202...
- bc569a80a344f9c 3y ago> Recent news reports and a Department of Justice investigation highlight the potential for insider informed trading by U.S. Senators and Members of the House of Representatives, an activity which the STOCK Act of 2012 was intended to deter. We use a new and comprehensive data set of these officials’ trades of public equities from January 2012-December 2020. We find no evidence of superior investment performance whether we look in aggregate or at Senators specifically accused of informed trading. Over a six-month horizon, stocks bought by House Members underperform on average by 26 basis points, while stocks sold underperform by 11 basis points. Even at the 95th and 99th percentiles of ex-post stock returns, House and Senator stock returns are consistent with random stock picking. Our methods cannot rule out the existence of some insider trades that are masked by the means, masked by poor ex-post performance or that took place in earlier years. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0047272722000044 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S004727272...
- alphabettsy 3y agoCitation needed.
- godelski 3y agoUnusual Whales is a very famous site that tracks politicians Or do you need a citation that members of congress trading based on knowledge they have is not legally defined as insider trading? Because that's also easy to Google fwiw https://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-report-2023 https://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-...
- alphabettsy 3y agoThe comment I responded to said that members of Congress consistently outperform professional traders. This doesn’t show that.
- godelski 3y agoI think there's a context gap here. They are referring to congress on average. But the median congress member does not beat SPY. The distribution is highly heterogeneous. Even just looking at number of transactions, half of each party's transactions are performed by a single member of that party. So to translate: > Congress consistently outperforms professional traders to > The average performance of members of congress is higher than that of professional traders. This does not mean a specific member outperforms a specific trader. Though there are specific members who consistently have a performance level that is higher than top traders. Which should beg the question of why these people have such high "skill" levels. This also does not mean there aren't congressional members who lost money in the market (there were 19 actually).
- psychlops 3y agoChatGPT was introduced to the world 8 days later after her purchase of calls. Could be coincidence.
- mulmen 3y agoChatGPT was released on November 30, 2022 which was 357 days before this trade. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ChatGPT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ChatGPT
- Jtsummers 3y ago> ChatGPT was introduced to the world 8 days later after her purchase of calls. Could be coincidence. This investment was made on November 22nd 2023. ChatGPT had been around for a while before then, it was not introduced 8 days later.
- fragmede 3y agoSpecifically, it was launched November 30th, 2022.
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoHer husband runs an investment firm so the information here was probably simply detailed analysis, down to the estimated orders per customer and the details of supply chain costs and margins. So not at all unexpected and no need for inside information. That's one thing that people don't seem to get when they look at stocks at a superficial level. Nvidia's rise was entirely expected. A quote among many - "We’re shocked by Nvidia’s pricing power on AI chips that we see driving earnings upside, higher valuation" - Apr 2023 when the price was less than half it is now and that statement was 100% correct yet the thread i'll link has a tone of conspiracy theories that it's a lie. https://old.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/12rbhs8/nvidia_stock_pops_on_hsbc_upgrade_were_shocked_by/ https://old.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/12rbhs8/nvidia_stoc... In fact in superficial analysis land (aka retail investors making trades on past history and PE alone) there were posts on reddit that Nvidia at half the current price was a great shorting opportunity as their PE was high. https://www.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/12c6sbx/nvidia_nvda_is_the_best_riskreward_short_over_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/stocks/comments/12c6sbx/nvidia_nvda... I still can't believe just how bad the retail investor community is. They don't go into any detail on companies. No view of the incoming orders and costs. They don't look at the long standing declines in userbase (there's non stop "Paypal is undervalued" threads on Reddit right now despite the constant user decline), they do superficial analysis and make poor decisions and when they see someone do well on investing through diligence they scream conspiracy. So Nancy Pelosi, and more specifically her investment banker husband did well on this trade? No shit. They probably did some level of homework.
- hanniabu 3y agoShe knew about a government contract they'd be getting
- jessriedel 3y agoAs Speaker of the House and 2nd in line to the presidency, she had access to more classified information than almost anyone on the planet. These sorts of officials should only be invested in blind trusts or diversified index funds, as indeed the president and vice president usually are.
- godelski 3y agoI'm not sure that solves the issue so much as funnels the direction of manipulation. Supposing a bad actor is trying to generate wealth but under such constraints, all they need to do is write policy in favor of the companies that already dominate. Such as favoring Apple, Microsoft, Google, and even Nvidia. Could even be done if one flattens the distribution of funds one would typically find in an index fund. See VOO for example, and play the imaginary game where you are a bad actor who wants to maximize your wealth but all your investments are locked up in VOO. It's important to play this game (run that simulation).
- jessriedel 3y agoIt is dramatically more constrained.
- godelski 3y agoI recognize that (actually made a longer comment in main thread), and I'm not convinced that's strictly in the public's interest. You are essentially placing a filter of "you must be this rich to bribe politicians." This could "counterintuitively" empower the already powerful even further, as you decrease their competition. To perform market capture they must capture a critical mass of politicians (we'll say mass varies by each politician's power). While there's already an implicit filter for those high mass politicians (fat cats ;) -- since you accumulate mass quickly -- the system's robustness is through the distribution of power among politicians. The whole political structure is designed to make it difficult to capture enough mass, and this is identical to the argument against authoritarian systems. So the constraining effectively reduces competition and can actually make mass accumulation cheaper and easier for companies that have the highest potential (and incentives) for abuse. So unless you got a counter argument that can convince me that this is of no concern, then I'm sticking to my original position.
- godelski 3y agoThese types of things always make me think about solutions, as I'm sure many of you do, but I'm not sure I know an adequate one. Common to suggest to just bar trading, which would make political jobs a major disadvantage. So others suggest only allowing for a third party managed fund that would be index focused. This sounds good at surface value, but when you go look at indices like VOO (S&P 500 based) you find, unsurprisingly, that Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Nvidia, Google, Meta, Tesla, B&H, JPMC dominate. Any index fund will tend to be like this, unless we created some very special fund to track the whole economy (I think there could be something to this one fwiw, but construction would need to be done with extreme care). The reason this can be problematic is that they could still grow their wealth by targeting policies at the top companies. All you'd need is to know what the index composition is. I mean should be obvious since Nvidia is in VOO. The other common suggestions are salary based. Some say to move it up to disincentivize them. Can make sense, as most people do not care much when their earnings reach a certain point. I'm sure that includes many here, especially given that the a large part of the idea behind Google/Big Tech perks is because increasing salary is less attractive for people making $150k+ cash (prior to equity). But politics naturally attracts people who are power seeking, and well... we still see Elon giving a shit about how wealthy he is when reality is there's very little his net worth (~$200bn, current #2 richest) gets him that Peter Thiel can't also get (~$6bn, rank #451) (nuance needed about liquidity and other aspects as money doesn't work like it does for normal people in this wealth range, but claim is generally true). I mean Elon could create multiple CERNs that could run indefinitely through returns on investments. So there's good reason to believe that the wealth incentive model that works on the average person doesn't work well on politicians. So there's also the argument to decrease salaries, do disincentivize power seekers from looking to politics as a way to obtain power and wealth. Idea here is to only attract people who are passionate about the job, like teachers (before teachers get burnout). But the nature of the job will always include power and Goodhart's Law is always in effect, so it'll be unsurprising that people can exploit the rulesets (or in this case, they make their own) and can channel money (to combine with their power) through third parties, which sets the stage for market capture. So others suggest term limits. There's also pros and cons to each decision here. Some people also suggest changing the number of politicians: fewer to centralize power, which can streamline many processes but that makes us vulnerable to autocratic takeover as takeover is dependent on the collection of keys to power; others say to increase the number, in an effort to further decentralize the system and make it difficult to capture enough keys, but this can lead to very slow moving and ineffective governments as well as reduce dependence on experts as the point of representative powers is to act as smoothing functions to wisdom of the crowds. Incidentally the highly distributed case doesn't prevent capture, but rather towards Plutocratic settings instead of Autocratic as it is unlikely that a single individual can more or less perform a 51% attack (to put it in less politic, more tech nerd speak). So one can argue that it is easier to replace a few keys when things go wrong, in favor of centralization, or increased robustness, in favor of distribution. There's plenty more suggestions and I still find a lot of them lacking. Most of this is even independent of such things like Capitalism and Socialism that people often conflate as solutions. The matter of the fact is that this is an incredibly complex solution space and I feel pretty confident saying that there is no global optima. And if we're going to get a little math nerdy, we can really think of voter preference as people considering "the optimization problem" (like we're solving a linear program) but each individual places different values for the various constraints (I believe lots of fighting revolves around this, as in any given subject we may be optimizing for different objectives but we assume others have the same conditioning on constraints as us so we think each other dumb). So we have this solution space that almost certainly has more than 100 independent dimensions, if not thousands, with magnitudes more interconnections as the systems are highly coupled, not to mention how the environment is dynamic and there are many outside forces (natural and human driven) that one can not vary. Fuck this is a hard problem and I really wish we could just talk about how it is hard. I'm absolutely tired of hearing about easy solutions. If it was easy, we would have solved it thousands of years ago. Honestly, I think our resistance to even admitting to a little bit of complexity bars us from even making good steps in the direction of optimization. I know it is human nature to desire simplicity and waste energy with complexity, but we're 21st century beings and all the easy problems are already solved. So we need to rely on what makes humans unique, which is in big part about being able to understand multivariate systems and how long-term optimization does not necessarily align with short-term optimization (which these days we seem hyper-focused on short-term). That we can reject rules, momentum, and guides in recognition of the distinction of the alignment between desired outcomes and how we measure outcomes or set guides to achieve them (we are also very good at hacking all this, but machines are good at reward hacking, but not so good at alignment adjusting). (Does anyone know if there have been any serious efforts to place a mathematical description on this optimization problem? Like a giant linear program? Seems like something someone would do, more for fun than utility)
- koolba 3y agoOf course she did, she's a genius investor! I know a number of hedge funds that would hire her in a heartbeat. What other explanation could there be for her consistently beating the market, year after year? Imagine if this clarity of thought was not wasted in Washington: https://youtu.be/fwqWzbk_LeY https://youtu.be/fwqWzbk_LeY
- zooq_ai 3y agoSo did many people. Nvdia is the wrong example to use against Pelosi. Nvdia rise is purely due to the AI moment. No Congress people had any "inside information" about Nvdia that helped to make this bet. In fact, the inside information about banning Nvdia chips to China would have encouraged them to make the opposite bet There are two reasons to oppose congress people trading a) They may have insider information (This is highly over-rated). Congress typically don't have any specific insider information that is not available to sophisticated traders. The laws that they pass are signaled months or weeks ahead. b) Conflict of interest. This is the more serious one and the reason why it should be banned. Congress people obviously won't vote for laws that would hurt their individual stock portfolio
- setgree 3y agoI agree. The whole thing is unseemly, but Nvidia is a poor example. Lots of people made money on Nvidia this year. For what it's worth, I was surprised that the Speaker of the House earn 250k. That seems too low.
- syspec 3y agoIs it though? I mean consider their pension, their health benefits, the fact that they probably spend very little of that salary on their daily needs. Most things for them are paid for, so that's nearly all take home money.
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoIt is honestly low for the role. It's actually a worldwide problem that we don't pay politicians enough and as such we discourage people going into politics for reasons other than pure narcissism. Senior engineers, senior managers and above all make that sort of money but without the horrible lifestyle of politics. Would you trade a Bay Area engineering career for that? I wouldn't. Yet whenever it's even suggested to raise politician wages for the sake of those politicians who aren't already billionaires there's uproar. Let me be blunt. You don't get talent without paying for it. The USA's mix of political backgrounds has become a monoculture of wealthy lawyers and investment bankers. We don't have enough representation from other careers in politics and it'll ruin us if we don't fix it, namely by increasing the salary of a highly stressful career to ensure we encourage the best and brightest to sign up for it.
- laluser 3y agoI really doubt that she's actively involved anymore. Her family's overall portfolio is worth 100s of millions, so she likely has her money parked in some family office managing her money for her. NVDA is one of the hottest stocks over the last few years. No doubt they're going to be making some bets here. Making 500k is nothing. What's scary is the amount she managed to make during her overall career.
- aresant 3y agoPrivate equity groups have been bodyslammed by the SEC into regulations that require "governance" oversights for all personal, active investments to ensure they're not in conflict with their investors So EG - making a private investment or specific stock investment - has to be precleared by a compliance officer for conflicts And these are backed up by SEC "teeth" if compliance officer doesn't enforce that policy rigorously It adds beaurocracy, but it's straightforward enough that it's not a major impediment Like "Oh hey you're on a committee that is going to determine AI policy? Seems like probably that's a conflict." Nancy could still make the trade by investing in a non-controlled investment, or tech-heavy index fund. But probably not just write a check into NVIDIA. While private industry is full of shenanigans I remain perplexed that gov't insiders - who don't just profit from these trades - but can actually influence policy - have virtually no hoops other than "after the fact" reporting (edit - actually I'm not perplexed at all, I'm just depressed about the reality of gov't accountability)
- dannyw 3y agoWhy are you perplexed? Govt insiders make the laws.
- aresant 3y agoHaha - you're right. I updated my comment. I am not perplexed in the least that it occurs. Just dumbfounded at the level of self-dealing that happens in full public view.
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoExactly. I'm confused by why anyone is confused by this. The system is operating exactly as desired by the people making the laws.
- tmaly 3y agoI think regular people would feel better about the system if the law applied equally to lawmakers.
- belltaco 3y agoWasn't Pelosi at the bottom of returns with -20% at some point? https://nypost.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2023/01/unusual-whale.jpeg?quality=75&strip=all https://nypost.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2023/01/unusua...
- mulmen 3y agoIs that an abnormal investment for her? Is it abnormal for her peers? Is the return exceptional? Is there any evidence of wrongdoing?
- mkmk 3y agoPelosi is famous for her trading activity, but I always wonder why there isn't _more_ of this. Is congress constrained by their own sense of propriety, or have they reached the theoretical maximum alpha from their insider knowledge?
- mulmen 3y agoHow much of this is insider knowledge and how much is just that congress tends to attract wealthy people who are already making these kinds of trades?
- mkmk 3y agohttps://twitter.com/unusual_whales/status/1742207287966777673 https://twitter.com/unusual_whales/status/174220728796677767... Judge for yourself – the data is public.
- mulmen 3y agoNot enough information in that Tweet. Is outperforming SPY abnormal among non-congressional peers? Here’s the actual report: https://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-report-2023 https://unusualwhales.com/politics/article/congress-trading-... From the tl;dr: > Congress beat the market, once again. Of 100 trading members, 33% beat SPY with their portfolios. So 2/3 of congressional traders underperform SPY. This also means the image in the tweet only shows top performers. From later in the analysis: > Note that there are a total of 535 Members of Congress, with 100 in the Senate and 435 in the House. If congress has such useful information for trading why is only 1/5th of congress trading? This 20% is roughly on par with the 15% of the American public directly owning stock.
- mkmk 3y agoYeah, so coming back to my initial question – I wonder why there isn't more successful insider trading by congresspeople.
- alisiddiq 3y agoHands down the best hedge fund manager. The next Buffett - I honestly dont know how she consistently beats the market
- outside1234 3y agoShe probably didn't. This is basically what she probably would have earned from NVIDIA if she had invested her portfolio in an S&P 500 fund.
- bklyn11201 3y agoShe's worth maybe $200mm at the beginning of 2023 so invest half in USA equities. $100mm in SP500 and NVDA is 4% of SP500 so purchase $4mm in NVDA stock at beginning of 2023. Price increased 237% in 2023. $9.48mm gain. I don't see how a 500k gain is considered at all noteworthy considering her asset size and considering NVDA's huge gain.
- itsdrewmiller 3y agoDoes she consistently beat the market? The article doesn't allege that.
- TheHypnotist 3y agoDid you bet against it? I don't understand. There's an entire subreddit of people making the same exact move.
- derjames 3y agoNANC is up 26% and KRUZ 11% since their creation.
- jncfhnb 3y agoUseless info unless netted against the sp500
- outside1234 3y agoI mean to be clear, didn't everyone who owns a S&P 500 portfolio basically make the same on a percentage of portfolio terms? (Pelosi has family wealth in the $100M range, so scale accordingly)
- captainpiggies 3y agoDid you even read the article? She specifically traded a million dollar long position on just Nvidia.
- mrinterweb 3y agoHonestly, simply paying attention to what is happening in the AI space should have been all the info needed to see where things are going. This info was generally available when Nancy made her transactions. AI is about to shock the world, is news that anyone paying attention has known for a while. Who sells the hardware all this AI runs on? Invest in the company selling the shovels for the AI gold rush. Just common sense investing.
- 50208 3y agoConsidering that Nvidia stock is up so much, and so many people are making so much on the its growth ... the fact she only made $500k tells me someone wasn't trying doing their job correctly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- captainpiggies 3y agoI can't believe people in this thread seem to be unironically defending / denying that Pelosi and her husband are front running trades based on her insider information. Particularly during the pandemic it was just painfully obvious that she was trading based on information that was not available to the public. Her and particularly her husbands returns are just straight improbable without some explainable edge, and the only logical explanation I have seen is her political position.
- mulmen 3y agoThis article doesn’t seem to contain any evidence of front running trades. Your claims may be true but this article doesn’t support them.
- karaterobot 3y agoI like there being a lot of scrutiny on trades made by Congresspeople. Unless there's some specific reason to call this one into question, I'm not sure how this is news. It didn't require insider information to know that NVIDIA, the maker of the hardware everybody needs for everything in the world right now, would be going up.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- belter 3y ago"The Secrets Behind Nancy Pelosi’s Trading Strategy" - https://www.capitoltrades.com/articles/the-secrets-behind-nancy-pelosi-s-market-beating-trading-strategy# https://www.capitoltrades.com/articles/the-secrets-behind-na...