3 ms·
I think precisely dictating layout is the wrong objective, although some areas (legal documents, academic papers) are still obsessed with that. Arxiv recently
by harshreality 3y ago
I think precisely dictating layout is the wrong objective, although some areas (legal documents, academic papers) are still obsessed with that. Arxiv recently started offering a subset of papers in html, which is a short step from epub.
If quick high-resolution referencing (page x, yth paragraph, zth line) is necessary, I think the way to handle it is to reference a phrase on that line ("the cat ran"...), which the reader can search for. If the search interface is lacking, that's an epub reader failure, not a format failure. Or, if the search option is considered insufficient (it does require typing with a [virtual] keyboard), paragraphs can be numbered—as many ancient works or works in translation already are, because such works have many editions and can't be layout-exact copies of each other.
If paragraph referencing is necessary, visibly styling the paragraphs with numbers helps dramatically. There's no reason it has to be exclusive to high-profile ancient or classical works, like Plato [1].
Classic poetry and plays, where referencing needs to be most exact and fast, already tend to give up any hope of everyone using the same edition, and simply avoid flowed text and then number the lines.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephanus_pagination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephanus_pagination
- foofie 3y ago> Classic poetry and plays, where referencing needs to be most exact and fast (...) I believe that paragraph referencing is, by far and without any contest, used primarily by any text subject to reviews and revisions. This means technical reports and academic papers. All academic papers I subjected to review were forced to use templates that enforced paragraph numbering. Even though each version of those documents were only read by a dozen readers or so, all papers submitted to those journals had to use the template. This means hundreds of documents (see half a dozen revisions per paper submitted per each edition) had that hard requirement, and this took place for each edition of a single journal.