4 ms·
Well, yes. American discourse has got backed into this corner: - "the government" (broadly defined) is not supposed to be able to spy on people - there is no
by pjc50 3y ago
Well, yes. American discourse has got backed into this corner:
- "the government" (broadly defined) is not supposed to be able to spy on people
- there is no general privacy law, only narrowly defined bits for e.g. video rental records and libraries
- corporations spying on people is completely normalized
- reporting the results of your spying to other people is free speech
> If there is no law against the proprietor bundling up his customer data and selling it, it doesn't seem like there is a strong legal case against police using it.
So long as there's a strong "corporations good, government bad" faction this is going to continue to be a problem.
(Weirdly, the "government bad" faction don't seem to be concerned with police accountability at all, except in very narrow cases where one of their own is arrested for blatent crimes)
- salawat 3y agoTechnically, if we'd consider corporations part of the government (which we arguably should; many acts of regulation that would be impractical to implement directly through the government are farmed out as the responsibility of corporations as a pre-req of doing business), many surveillance capitalism patterns would become fraught by default. The "corporations aren't government entities" defies logic. As without government recognition, they aren't even a thing.
- pjc50 3y ago> if we'd consider corporations part of the government (which we arguably should; I'm not sure that even the Chinese legal system does that. It makes a nonsense of "part of".
- salawat 3y agoIt does not. If you're a legal fiction, at some level your existential DNA is entwined with your political system's existence. It doesn't make a nonsense of "part-of" at all; unless you don't want to inherit government centric probibitions to deal with in calculating your business model.