2 ms·
> What do you mean the game keeps on going? One side has to move but has no legal moves. As said elsewhere, I would suggest removing rules against putting your
by eru 3y ago
> What do you mean the game keeps on going? One side has to move but has no legal moves.
As said elsewhere, I would suggest removing rules against putting yourself in check.
> The stalemate rule adds something that the attacking player has to keep in mind and gives the defending player something to shoot for - lots of creative and tricky play arises from this, with IM Eric Rosen being the most famous exponent[1] so much so that he now has a particular type of stalemate trap named after him.[2]
That's why I was careful in saying that the proposed change would make the rules more elegant, less clunky. I did not say anything about this making chess a better game. Sometimes adding weird corner cases to your rules can make the game better.
Just look at all the weird rules that you can find in Skat or Doppelkopf. (Though Mü is an example of a game with much cleaner rules that captures a similar spirit.)
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoBut who cares if the rules themselves are more elegant if the game they describe is different and worse because of it? It's like you introduced a bug in refactoring and are insisting on the change because the code looks nicer now.
- eru 3y agoYes, you are right that this is only an intellectual exercise. (Btw, it's quite popular in the Go world to reformulate the ancient clunky rules of Go into a more modern, mathematical version that might or might not have small differences in gameplay.) However, I don't actually think that removing check rules make chess worse. But that's subject to experiment. See https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.04374.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2009.04374.pdf for exactly such experiments.