4 ms·
PDF is an annoying specification, but there exists absolutely no replacement for it. I have never seen any kind of technical documentation published in any oth
by adrian_b 3y ago
PDF is an annoying specification, but there exists absolutely no replacement for it.
I have never seen any kind of technical documentation published in any other format than PDF that is comfortable for reading and searching, even when that is done on a mobile phone.
I do not want a document that changes appearance depending on the device used for reading or depending on its temporary state, like window size. I want a document whose layout has been well conceived by its author and which is fixed, regardless of what I happen to use for reading it.
When I happen to read it on a smaller screen or window, except for trivial text-only documents, I do not want changes in layout, but I only want a smart reader, with comfortable means for fast zoom and pan, and which does not have stupid behaviors (like some Android readers), for instance where scrolling vertically (including Page Up/Page Down) also moves the document horizontally (preventing the easy reading of a column of text).
The traditional recommendations for the maximum width of a text column are good enough, if observed, to ensure comfortable reading even on a mobile phone. Only when the author breaks the traditional typographic rules by making extra-wide columns, the reading on a mobile phone becomes inconvenient.
- broscillator 3y agoI find reading PDFs on my phone and even on my kindle really uncomfortable. On my phone I have to either zoom in or turn on landscape mode (which usually means turn it on globally, I can't do it just for the reader app). On kindle, a full page has too small font due to so much margin, and fitting the width shows me 80% of the page, and then I have to scroll down for the last 20% and my eyes have to find where exactly I was reading.
- baq 3y agoI'm keeping my not-sure-how-old iPad 5 around specifically because it's the device form factor to read pdfs.
- broscillator 3y agoThat kind of highlights how non-versatile PDF is despite some comments. However it does sound handy, I kinda want a dedicated tablet for sheet music.
- baq 3y agoYou're absolutely right PDFs are super rigid, but that's kinda their point - so with the proper device, like a sheet of paper or a 10+ inch tablet screen it makes sense. Would I prefer more content to be reflowable etc.? Yes - but with a tablet it isn't strictly necessary, just nice to have.
- rchaud 3y agoIt's plenty versatile. Not everything needs to be phone-friendly. Phone screens weren't designed for reading PDF-size documents. Even so, options exist to reflow the text, view in landscape or pan and zoom.
- broscillator 3y agoThere is one device which fits PDFs well, an ipad. It can be fairly awkward on laptops and deskptops as well. > view in landscape or pan and zoom. This is awkward, that's the issue I mentioned above, how annoying is to have to do that if you're reading for a 30-60 minute session.
- pseingatl 3y agoOr the Kindle DX, RIP.
- IIsi50MHz 3y agoFor Android, I use FaME IT's "Rotate" to set both per-app and global rotations: forced-auto (overrides most lawful-evil apps that try to force an orientation for not good reason) auto-portrait (allows only the two portrait orientations, auto-landscape (similar, good for some games & video apps) lock-current (for chaotic-evil apps that lose state or rebuild the whole UI in response to rotation events).
- crabmusket 3y ago> I have never seen any kind of technical documentation published in any other format than PDF that is comfortable for reading and searching, even when that is done on a mobile phone. Can you provide an example of what you mean? My experience is completely the polar opposite.
- adrian_b 3y agoI refer to something like a 3000 page manual of some microcontroller, or the datasheets of some integrated circuits or the specifications of some Arm architecture variant, or the standards for some programming language, e.g. C++ or System Verilog. These are concrete examples of documents that I might have read during some flights or when waiting for some flight, on a smartphone. When reading something like a fiction novel, reflowing the text based on the window width may be acceptable. On the other hand, the navigation through a huge document half of which are tables, figures, diagrams, schematics and graphics is extremely painful when it is in HTML format so the layout changes based on the device and window used and there are no means to jump quickly e.g. to page 1436, then to page 2117. When zoom, pan and scroll are correctly implemented, which unfortunately happens seldom, they are much less distracting than the random changes in page layout caused by rendering as done by a browser. I strongly dislike whenever a company provides only a Web documentation that is hard to navigate, instead of also providing a PDF manual. Web documentation may be acceptable for very small documents, but not for most of the current technical documentation, where many thousands of pages for a manual are common. Perhaps an EPUB format extended with everything necessary to completely describe a fixed page layout might become competitive with PDF, but I will have to see an example to believe it. For now, whenever I see a book or any other document both in PDF and in EPUB formats, I always choose the PDF variant, because without exception it provides a better quality of the rendered pages.
- crabmusket 3y agoI accept your points and agree that the kind of documentation you're thinking about sounds like a poor use case for HTML/EPUB. I do not regularly encounter this sort of documentation. I've been boosting the idea in the OP, but more for things like "your local council's meeting minutes" or "your English class assignment" or "a research paper". Though I do want to point out that even moderately complex specs, when designed for the web, can work well. For example, the HTML spec doesn't reference page numbers, but has extensive internal hyperlinking: https://html.spec.whatwg.org/ https://html.spec.whatwg.org/ > Perhaps an EPUB format extended with everything necessary to completely describe a fixed page layout might become competitive with PDF I highly doubt this will ever happen, for use cases which require fixed layout. But there are plenty of use cases where fixed layout is unnecessary and inferior.
- niutech 3y ago> PDF is an annoying specification, but there exists absolutely no replacement for it. There are: OpenXPS (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_XML_Paper_Specification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_XML_Paper_Specification) or DjVu (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DjVu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DjVu).