4 ms·
Site is down. Comparable statement from Scotland.[1] Kids need riskier play, so that the military can get more recruits. Only about 23% of American kids quali
by Animats 3y ago
Site is down.
Comparable statement from Scotland.[1]
Kids need riskier play, so that the military can get more recruits. Only about 23% of American kids qualify for the US military.[2] With a war with either Russia or China coming up, we'll need more fresh meat for the grinder.
[1] https://www.playscotland.org/resources/print/Risky-Play-Leaflet.pdf?plsctml_id=10760 https://www.playscotland.org/resources/print/Risky-Play-Leaf...
[2] https://docs.house.gov/meetings/PW/PW07/20230511/115823/HHRG-118-PW07-Wstate-AschB-20230511.pdf https://docs.house.gov/meetings/PW/PW07/20230511/115823/HHRG...
- n2d4 3y agoArchive is still up: https://web.archive.org/web/20240126065238/https://cps.ca/en/documents/position/outdoor-risky-play https://web.archive.org/web/20240126065238/https://cps.ca/en...
- d1sxeyes 3y agoIt is possible that this is some big conspiracy to increase the number of fit, military age folks in the short term, it seems unlikely. If there were ever to be any kind of “meat grinding” war, it would be escalated to aircraft, drones, and long range missiles pretty quickly I think, with a relatively small number of infantry losses through active combat. There are also a significant number of people who believe that risky play (or the lack of it) is resulting in mental health issues in today’s young adults, who are finding themselves inexperienced in dealing with feelings of fear, unfamiliar with perseverance and delayed gratification, and are also as you have noted, physically out of shape. Just because “teenagers being fitter” would benefit the military does not mean that’s the purpose of encouraging riskier play.
- reverius42 3y agoThe ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine already seems to be a meat grinder, despite the existence of drones and aircraft.
- meheleventyone 3y agoThe vast majority of the killing has always been via indirect fire. Drones and aircraft are just part of that.
- 15155 3y agoOur doctrine was built around aircraft, suppression of enemy air defenses, and then domination through missiles and total air superiority. We flew more combat sorties on Day 1 of Desert Storm than both of these nations have flown in two years of this conflict. Soviet (and by extension both of these nations) doctrine places emphasis on overwhelming manpower, artillery, and air defense. We have an order of magnitude more combat aircraft of all classes than both of these nations combined. We have more AH-64s that are allocated just to training than both of these nations have helicopters in active service combined. Ukraine is already giving Russia's AD systems a run for their money using our hand-me-downs from 30 or more years ago. Their aircraft have no stealth technology, ancient avionics, ancient targeting systems, last-generation anti-radiation missiles. Russian AD systems stand zero chance against modern SEAD doctrine: we can see this in effect every time Ukraine uses decoy-based saturation attacks combined with cruise missiles. They simply do not have enough capable batteries to sustain a meaningful air defense when faced with a financially-superior adversary. We have tens of thousands of AGM-88 HARMs in stock: Russia has less than 2000 estimated S-300/S-400 acquisition radars. Nuclear weapons are Russia's only real military trump card; Russia would cease to exist if confined to conventional munitions in a "peer" conflict. There exists exactly zero chance we end up in a Ukraine style meat grinder, we're deploying nuclear weapons long before that happens. Also: Ukraine isn't engaged in total war and has no ability to wage it. The United States would (and has in past conflicts) engage in strategic bombing campaigns on absolutely every single manufacturing facility, every supply chain, in every complicit nation. In a US-Russia or US-China conflict, Iran doesn't get to sell drones or any other munitions without receiving 40 tons of JDAMs on their manufacturing facilities.
- baybal2 3y ago[dead]
- circlefavshape 3y ago
- mdekkers 3y ago> If there were ever to be any kind of “meat grinding” war Haven't you heard? Ukraine needs 500.000 more units of meat for the grinder. Russia are likewise looking for some huge number.
- coryrc 3y agoAccording to Wikipedia, we have "some 3,700 M1A1, M1A2 SEPv2/v3 in storage". So we have literally thousands of main battle tanks we will never use we could just give them. It's a meat grinder because we're making it so.
- 15155 3y agoHow do MBTs materially change a conflict where every participant has (tens of) millions of landmines ready for deployment? What good do MBTs do in isolation against attack helicopters with 15km-range ATGMs?
- AstralStorm 3y agoIf even that. Think cheaper, like kamikaze (or not) explosive drones. (Substitute armor piercing as needed.) MBTs do not have sufficient AA or ECM capability ever. Either a specialty formation is required or something carrier sized to have a chance. Their existence is the old strategy of demolition and suppression of infantry. (At the last of which they do not quite succeed.)
- coryrc 3y agoWe have enough active military equipment to fight land wars with two superpowers simultaneously. We have enough of all equipment to give to Ukraine. Not lease or sell, just get them to win without losing so many people. Fuck, give them a carrier group. Rain tomahawks down on St Petersburg and Moscow. Destroy every oil terminal and arms factory.
- 15155 3y agoAt what point does Russia just deploy nuclear weapons?
- tazu 3y ago"Meat" is capital in wars, and the more you raise the more respectable you and your war, or special-military-operation, is.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> If there were ever to be any kind of “meat grinding” war, it would be escalated to aircraft, drones, and long range missiles pretty quickly I think That's not an escalation, it's a cooling off.
- master-lincoln 3y agoHow so? Naively it seems to me that aircraft, drones, and long range missiles could do more harm to non military parts of a country compared to a foot army.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoIt's a cooling off in two senses: First, these kinds of remote attacks don't take territory and therefore have sharply limited impact on the conflict. The ceiling on what they can accomplish is very low. Second, they are cheaper and lower-risk for the attacking party, representing a lower level of commitment to the conflict. The potential for loss to the attacker is also very low. Moving from a high-investment, high-risk, high-reward strategy to a low-investment, low-risk, low-reward strategy is hard to describe as an "escalation". > Naively it seems to me that aircraft, drones, and long range missiles could do more harm to non military parts of a country compared to a foot army. You're not alone. I have read that many people in the West were genuinely confused as to how the Tutsi genocide could have been accomplished with machetes. But foot armies are more than capable of inflicting whatever level of destruction you have in mind.
- rich_sasha 3y agoI'd like to read the original analysis. My concern isn't about cannon fodder provision but about all round health. Kids growing up with exercise and a penchant for adventure are IMO better placed to succeed in life (long term health benefits, bravery etc.) but not so if they break their legs all the time falling off of things. It's not obvious to me how to balance these things. The links you provide, as far as I can skim, don't weigh in on the tradeoff.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI think their root problem is insufficient kids, period. Then a certain percentage breaking their legs is tolerable, on a society level.
- 082349872349872 3y agoI grew up in a different century ("no blood no foul"), so for me the english question "Are you OK?" should normally be answered with "yes" unless there are significant quantities of blood or bones are broken. (I guess a more explicit equivalent would be "are you in need of medical assistance?") Is this still the protocol among anglophone children, or has it changed during the intervening decades?
- happymellon 3y ago> Are you OK? Don't worry, all the damage is mental and won't manifest itself until I'm middle aged.
- rich_sasha 3y agoAdmittedly there is a resurgence of understanding the benefits of risk taking, but to demonstrate the status quo, a school outing to a museum requires a risk assessment to be made, weight the benefits of, well, a school trip, against risks of walking on streets etc.
- 082349872349872 3y ago
- photonthug 3y agoI thought you were exaggerating but skimming, it is chilling how that 2nd link just says the quiet part loud: > The powerful effect of incentive plans (independent of quotas) was documented in an older study of Army guidance counselors.22 A key responsibility of guidance counselors is to channel applicants into the Army’s priority occupations. During the period under study, guidance counselors were under an incentive plan that offered counselors additional points for selling a high-priority occupation. The study found that simply offering five more incentive plan points for selling a particular occupation was more than twice as effective as offering an enlistment bonus to a recruit. That is, it was more effective to give the seller (the guidance counselor) an incentive to “sell” the occupation than it was to give the buyer (the recruit) an incentive to “buy” the occupation. Nice to know that government funded studies show tricking people is more effective than convincing or bargaining with them in good faith
- austin-cheney 3y agoI fail to see where anybody is being tricked in your quote. Research has indicated that Americans are progressively becoming more risk adverse, obese, and more injury prone over time. If only 23% of Americans qualify for military service now that number will become much smaller in the future. The potential rarity of viable recruits could become a new unexpected driver of personal wealth as military service becomes a new form wealthy exceptionalism available only to those gifted few.
- photonthug 3y agoHuh? My read is, this basically says there's no reason to give a recruit bonuses for priority (like say, undesirable and dangerous front line) work. It's more effective incentivizing the recruiter (like maybe he could just forget to mention other work is even available). There is no way this incentive structure leads to honesty for recruiter or upward mobility for the recruit
- eru 3y ago> My read is, this basically says there's no reason to give a recruit bonuses for priority (like say, undesirable and dangerous front line) work. Huh? Don't they say that those bonuses work really well? So that's a lot of reason to use them, ain't it?
- bravura 3y agoThat's a really cynical take. Early experience in learning how to fall correctly is important for safety as you get older. Dan John, in Intervention, talks about how a lot of movement patterning is developed during youth, and thus encourages a broad range of activities. This includes learning to tumble.
- dappermanneke 3y agonow many hackernews residents are parents the conspiracy theorising about the government trying to get to theirs and theirs kids precious bodily fluids is even more neurotic
- magicalhippo 3y agoNot just safety. There's research showing that improved physical skills like balancing, coordination and so on at an early age correlates with improved performance in school.
- viraptor 3y agoI'm not sure why the riskier play would address any of the issues actually linked there: https://prod-media.asvabprogram.com/CEP_PDF_Contents/Qualified_Military_Available.pdf https://prod-media.asvabprogram.com/CEP_PDF_Contents/Qualifi... If they want systemic solutions, then sorting out healthcare, mental health care, not charging weed users, and maybe replacing the corn subsidies could have a bigger impact... What happens on the playground has way more steps separating it from enlistment criteria then any of those. It would be like counting on 5th order effects working just right.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoDamn, usually I'm pro risky play but if this is the long game to neuter the war machine, it can't be all bad.
- agapon 3y ago> the war machine Your country's war machine, right?
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoAny, all, yeah. I believe my country is most often the aggressor in the wars it has participated in. Without a big enough stick, aggression for material gain is a worse gamble. I'm not saying no military is needed, but it has become the proverbial hammer.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]