4 ms·
Indeed. Perhaps I can explain a little more what she discovered, and why this connection to QFT is almost surely nonsense. The flag manifold in question comes
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
Indeed. Perhaps I can explain a little more what she discovered, and why this connection to QFT is almost surely nonsense.
The flag manifold in question comes from matrix groups; basically, consider some subset of 3x3 matrices which satisfy a certain property. I.e., certain types of transformations of a 3d space. While the space of 3x3 matrices has 3x3=9 dimensions, subsets can have fewer dimensions (in this case, 6).
The two-dimensional projections she discovered are functions of the 6 dimensional matrices.
So here is the occams razor explanation for what is happening. Inside the bee's head is an ODE (ordinary differential equation) solver, basically an analog computer. Just think of the ODE solver as a complicated timer, but with output depending on both time and some hidden variable. These are common objects in biology, and don't require many neurons.
The output of the ODE solver is wired to some neurons which reduce 6 variables to 2, according to the formula she discovered.
This is a fantastic discovery, a triumph of applied math. But the connection to QFT is almost surely coincidence: QFT uses symmetries of matrix groups over 3 dimensions, and the bee (which lives in 3 dimensions) also does.
This phenomenon is called universality. Certain objects repeat across diverse areas simply because it is the only logical way (or the most common logical way) that things could happen.
- snorkel 18y agoAll at once you brought together Occam's Razor, Universality, differential equations, manifolds, and quantum field theory into a comment I actually understand. You should teach.
- arjunb 18y agowow, great explanation. thanks.
- mmmurf 18y agoDo you happen to know any other examples of such things from biology, particularly in a shockingly small number of neurons? Great explanation, btw.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoWell, neural integrators are known, I know the ocular system has some. A quick google search finds this: http://hebb.mit.edu/courses/9.29/2003/athena/bearlee/Neural_Integrator.htm http://hebb.mit.edu/courses/9.29/2003/athena/bearlee/Neural_... An integrator basically solves the ODE y'(t)=f(t); the firing rate is proportional to y(t). So if you wire up integrators appropriately, you could solve most ODE's (obviously, there are scaling issues, noise, etc). In principle, one could reproduce the bee's behavior by appropriately connecting six of these. But I admit, this example is one of the more fantastic examples I've seen. It's a simple algebraic manifold (1) and obtained purely from observation of behavior rather than lab work. (1) In biology, you usually get shapes which are big ugly messes, imagine the surface of a child's playdough sculpture. Instead, she found something pretty like kepler's conic sections (to borrow the analogy from the article). That's uncommon in biology.
- mmmurf 18y agoVery interesting, thanks!