4 ms·
Here's some really insightful feedback on this idea from Baldur Bjarnason, who has spent significant time working with various W3C groups relevant to EPUB: http
by simonw 3y ago
Here's some really insightful feedback on this idea from Baldur Bjarnason, who has spent significant time working with various W3C groups relevant to EPUB: https://toot.cafe/@baldur/111819472053623911 https://toot.cafe/@baldur/111819472053623911
Example note: "EPUB originally didn't support remote resources and people put a lot of work into changing. Loading stuff over the network is HTML's killer feature. Blocking network assets is a setback for format adoption, not progress."
- zaphirplane 3y agoAllow loading of network resources is not good for security. Surprised this isn’t a worry, tbh didn’t read baldur’s writing
- criddell 3y agoBut it’s good for tracking what books people are reading. If the history of the internet shows anything, it’s that if surveillance is possible, it will eventually happen. Lots of governments around the world would love to know what their citizens are reading. Few would be bold enough to go after this directly, but if some company operating in their country has the data then there’s a path for that government to get the data.
- starkparker 3y agoOh for Christ's sake, someone pry Baldur off his cross again. > Blocking network assets is a setback for format adoption People are standing here telling him that _allowing_ network assets _is a setback for format adoption_ and he's just going to keep pounding this stupid, obnoxious drum of his until he runs everyone off. > almost all of the problems described would be solved by getting OS vendors (Google, MS, Apple) to invest more money in EPUB That's back-asswards. Google, MS, and Apple don't give a shit about EPUB, they never will, and it's arguable that we're better served with them not buying a seat at that table considering how poorly their "help" has helped web standards, as much of the rest of his dismissive thread helpfully notes. If he wants money for EPUB standards he should shake the cup at IDPF members who rely on it, and particularly Amazon, to whom he quite vocally abdicated the publishing space 12 years ago.[1] Barking at operating system companies is nonsense at best and how we wind up with another, even more avoidable situation where the space is held hostage by them at worst. At least Amazon can chuck some goodwill money at EPUB development while continuing to kick its ass up and down the market with MOBI. (Aside from all this, his dismissals of the "clunky" reading system complaint, citing how EPUB has "too many divergences", only further proves to me how tunneled the vision is of the people involved. To hell with forking or improving EPUB, then, because it can't be improved if that's the attitude of the people most involved with or influential within it. What bloody point is there in the customizability of a format that _nobody_ can effectively build tools for or consume?) 1: https://www.baldurbjarnason.com/notes/amazon-wins/ https://www.baldurbjarnason.com/notes/amazon-wins/, in which he also admits that he has no idea how to work with IDPF, which is a really great sign of how long things have been going this badly in this space
- sirsinsalot 3y agoI also don't want my e-reader phoning home (to publisher/author) read time and page turns because the EPUB loads a pixel.
- Someone 3y ago> Google, MS, and Apple don't give a shit about EPUB https://www.w3.org/groups/wg/epub/former-participants/ https://www.w3.org/groups/wg/epub/former-participants/ certainly shows Google and Apple participated in the working group. Apple also has a book store selling EPUB books and has EPUB readers for both MacOS and iOS. Google also has an app that handles EPUB.
- crabmusket 3y agoI really enjoyed this response, though I feel your points could have been made with a little less personal vitriol. Do you have history with Baldur? I don't ask because I think that would undermine your arguments, I'm just interested why you had such a strong reaction.
- mft_ 3y ago> > Blocking network assets is a setback for format adoption > People are standing here telling him that _allowing_ network assets _is a setback for format adoption_ and he's just going to keep pounding this stupid, obnoxious drum of his until he runs everyone off. I don't know the background that you're frustrated about, but I'd suggest that the answer might be: 'it depends' - and it depends on the intended purpose of the format in question. PDF is self-contained, and can be read (mostly) reliably on almost any device with the right software; PDFs having to have internet access to be read or opened would be a bad thing; further, the same goes for most formats - including EPUB (as you say) and audio files, picture files, etc.
- chasil 3y ago> PDF is self-contained, and can be read (mostly) reliably on almost any device with the right software Article: "A PDF is a single file that contains all the images, fonts, and other data needed to render it." This is only true if you are using PDF/A, or have explicitly bundled all of your fonts in some version of the PDF standard. Otherwise, 14 total typefaces must be rendered by the viewer. These 14 are: Times (in regular, italic, bold, and bold italic), Courier (in regular, oblique, bold and bold oblique), Helvetica (in regular, oblique, bold and bold oblique), Symbol, and Zapf Dingbats. The 14 standard typefaces can vary between viewers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDF#Text https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDF#Text "...the base fourteen fonts... or suitable substitute fonts with the same metrics, should be available in most PDF readers, but they are not guaranteed to be available in the reader, and may only display correctly if the system has them installed." Depending upon what the viewer bundles, PDFs using these 14 might not render as expected. Below is a deeper discussion from the wiki: https://web.archive.org/web/20110718231502/http://www.planetpdf.com/planetpdf/pdfs/pdf2k/03e/merz_fontaquarium.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20110718231502/http://www.planet...
- watwut 3y agoJust about the last thing I want is for epub to stop working offline on my phone, because the damm book needs to download something.
- jxdxbx 3y agoMy view as a heavy ebook reader: ePubs should be inert data. No javascript, no interactivity, no network resources. Just a fancy text file with some appearance settings all of which the reader can override.
- harshreality 3y agoThink about what javascript exclusion means, and all the things a good universal ebook format needs to support. Nicely rendered math? Currently the best option to do that is embedded mathjax (maybe you could pre-build mathml and ship that, but I'm not sure that covers all cases). Graphs or charts? There are nice js libraries for that, while doing it manually means exporting images or svgs. Even static svgs are annoying and brittle to font-size changes without javascript to adjust the svg size appropriately. Don't confuse what's necessary for standard fiction books with what the format should support. JS and interactivity are fine, in technical books, reports, or niche fiction. What I absolutely agree on is that epubs don't need is networking. Resources on the internet get stale after years or decades anyway, so inclusion of any network assets into an epub guarantees that the work will degrade over the years. References can be web links, but nothing from the internet should be embedded.
- criddell 3y agoEPUB 3 includes MathML. https://www.w3.org/TR/epub-33/ https://www.w3.org/TR/epub-33/
- harshreality 3y agoSure. That doesn't mean an author would want to maintain MathML inside an ebook. a) What epub editor software allow direct editing of MathML, and is it a good idea to depend on such software being available in order to edit the book without tinkering directly with the MathML by hand? b) Does MathML support everything mathjax does?
- maratc 3y agoThis describes several existing formats, from Markdown to XSL-FO to the (rather niche) FB2 which is a glorified XML that supports some base64-encoded images.
- bmacho 3y ago> "EPUB originally didn't support remote resources and people put a lot of work into changing. Loading stuff over the network is HTML's killer feature." And it is a feature of books that they stay the same. Both can be a feature, the ability to change (e.g. they fix something in the cloud), and the disability to change (e.g. you can have it as you bought it).
- criddell 3y agoI don’t get the impulse for homogenization everywhere. PDFs, EPUBs, Word documents, HTML documents, etc… all have different strengths and weaknesses and I think that’s a good thing. Never needing an internet connection is a strength of EPUB IMHO.