3 ms·
Patience. There was a time when executives didn't have screens and keyboards on their desks. That was for the little people. There are still some who still don
by Animats 3y ago
Patience. There was a time when executives didn't have screens and keyboards on their desks. That was for the little people.
There are still some who still don't, but they are dying off.
- Mathnerd314 3y agoI think it is possible for AI to actually deliver a better experience than an expert. Like with the trip booking example, the expert still has to look up the flights and so on but an AI can process them instantly. And with language models it seems possible to be as flexible as a human. I think the biggest issue is trust - nobody trusts an AI right now (and rightly so), but an expert has a reputation and that is really what the rich people are paying for.
- SirMaster 3y ago>the expert still has to look up the flights and so on but an AI can process them instantly. I get the idea though that the expensive experts actually have access to back channels that can allow them to skip right to the result. So unless the LLMs also are granted access to these sorts of exclusive channels, how can they compete? It's often who you know that will get you results. So who exactly do LLMs know? And will those people even interface with LLMs or provide a way for LLMs to interface with their exclusive resources?
- groby_b 3y agoThere is an upside for not having to work through indirection. There's absolutely no upside to talking to a robot. Or a "hold" line. And it's worth keeping in mind that for services, the money flows in the opposite direction - work is buying your time on the keyboard/screen, but you are buying a non-robot experience. And rich people buying convenience won't ever die out.
- noduerme 3y agoThat's because at a certain point those things became time-saving as opposed to picking up a phone and asking someone to do them for you. Things will change to the exact degree that the robots are able to provide more real time-saving value than humans, meaning a higher degree of accuracy and satisfaction. FTA: >> Rich people don’t attempt to save money by agreeing to sit on hold. This is the salient thing. If dealing with something for an hour saves you $1000, but you could have made $5000 doing something else for that hour, you won't deal with it (even if you don't, in fact, spend that hour doing something productive).
- dkasper 3y agoIt’s not even that, if I could save $1000 but I don’t care about $1000 I wouldn’t do it. I wouldn’t sit on hold for $10. A billionaire isn’t gonna sit on hold for $1000 unless they have an axe to grind.
- noduerme 3y agoI'd quibble with that, depending on what you mean by "axe to grind". I'm not a billionaire, but I'm fairly well off. My billing rate is $300/hr. Still, I don't like to feel ripped off. Spending my time not being ripped off does add some ineffable value beyond the monetary. Maybe this puts me in an unusual category of people who love having axes to grind, but I feel like I didn't amass my savings by letting things slide. If it's $10, I might let it go. But I'm currently taking a company to small claims court over $800 for breach of contract. So I guess I'm contradicting myself... but there also is another element which is that you can't become wealthy if you make a habit of allowing people to chisel you. [edit] I don't think this contradicts the OP at all, because taking this company to court is the alternative to wasting my time talking to their robots.
- mr_mitm 3y agoI know exactly what you mean. Recently I was on vacation in a country where a cab would take you through town for a price which would not be enough to get a taxi driver in my country to even start the engine. Of course some would charge you twice as much as others, which would still be very cheap compared to home, but that's not the comparison you make. You compare it to what the last taxi driver charged you and now you feel ripped off and disrespected by this particular taxi driver, even though now you are haggling about what is peanuts to me.
- noduerme 3y agoThis is a great example because it shows just how relative "wealth" is, and makes the thought experiment accessible to anyone in a first-world country. It's just my conjecture, but I don't think most billionaires "don't care about $1000". The few people I've met with a net worth over $100M are sharp bargainers. I think the view that "they won't miss $1000" or "why would they care" is a fundamental misapprehension of the psychological make-up of wealthy people that's commonly held among people who don't have a lot of money. (And so when the wealthy do notice and care, the explanation would be that they must have an axe to grind).
- mlhpdx 3y ago> There are still some who still don't, but they are dying off. I'm not sure what's more profound with that: the hostility or stupidity. Patience isn't going to win the day here; there is a fundamental truth to what the article is saying. If there is such a thing in the future as a financial advising AI for individuals _and families_ of significant wealth, it won't be anything like what serves the "mass market". The complexity is incomparable, in addition to the expectations.
- rukuu001 3y agoSure, but it’ll still probably be for the “I need two nights in Boca Raton midtown next week, make it happen, robo travel agent” type trip rather than “best of everything that suits my personal tastes” type trip.
- noduerme 3y agoYou hit on a really core thing... another way to say it is that a robot can only sell the experiences that exist in some packaged form, and that in itself is exactly what UHNWIs explicitly don't want.
- lchengify 3y agoFWIW, I don't think the author is talking about executives. I think he's talking about people on the level of ultra high-net-worth individual (UHNWI). People with roughly $30m or more in investable assets. People like that prefer to be focused on exactly whatever their building, and babysitting the money is rarely that thing. They often approach their private wealth manager with a broad plan on goals, and the PWM goes out and executes them with light direction. There are lawyers and accountants in the loop as well, all working on paper to manage the cash pile. It's a long term, multi-generational relationship that often involves multiple parties, one of which is often some or many governments. In addition, the PWM in this position prefers to get the client directly on the phone when possible. This is both to manage the relationship, and to sell novel finance products, often ones that aren't available on the open market. Until we get AGI, it's just not quite there to be outsourced to AI. People at that level really prefer having a person be responsible.