2 ms·
> The person didn’t break any of the rules — how dare you ban them? Very simple: articulate new rules which cover the behavior, and publish them. Alert the us
by kazinator 3y ago
> The person didn’t break any of the rules — how dare you ban them?
Very simple: articulate new rules which cover the behavior, and publish them.
Alert the user that their former behavior is now against the rules.
Have a meta-rule that anyone who triggers the above workflow more than twice will be banned.
There is also this alternative: say that there are hidden rules that are completely unrelated to the written rules, even in "spirit". You can be removed from the community for any reason, without any explanation, by the powers that be, due to any behavior they find displeasing.
- varjag 3y agoVery simple: articulate new rules which cover the behavior, and publish them. You essentially argue for common law: an enormous corpus of precedents that is impossible to navigate without dedicated lawyers, is a pain to arbiter and still does not preclude injustice.
- hkt 3y agoTo continue the comparison, some of common law's shortcomings can be overcome with an entity like the UK's law commission, eg, rewriting statute (or the code of conduct) to incorporate changes based on new precedent. Which does appear to somewhat be what has happened.
- howenterprisey 3y agoTwice? Seems like that'll get argued about endlessly, at the very least.
- kazinator 3y agoEven if so the arguments can get settled, any agreed upon changes made, and the discussion archived. Next time someone runs into it, you have that to point to.