3 ms·
> online scams could be argued as a "colonialism tax" on the richer, dumber citizens of western nations that are used to a government that at least feigns givin
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> online scams could be argued as a "colonialism tax" on the richer, dumber citizens of western nations that are used to a government that at least feigns giving a shit about their security.
Which brings us to the actual problem that causes these others.
We don't put the consequences of bad security practices on the people who could have taken better precautions because they're "the victim" even though they're also the only person who could have prevented it. So instead we move the cost to the merchant via the credit card companies etc., or some other intermediary whose fault it was not.
Which removes the incentive for ordinary people to care about security, and then they don't. Who cares if your IoT garbage provides an entry point into your home network and some Russians get your credit card number? Don't spend time choosing a device with open source firmware that gets indefinite community support. Don't worry about giving your credit card number to scammers. Just buy whatever's cheap and when it happens you can call the credit card company and make it their problem.
Which in turn makes it the credit card company's problem, which they don't like, so they start asking for awful cybercrime bills to do something about this, even though the only something that works is to make consumers feel meaningful consequences for not caring about security.
- grotorea 3y agoAre people that indifferent to cybersecurity in your opinion? There are lots of ways to lose money that can't that easily be clawed back.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoPeople are indifferent specifically in the cases that it can be clawed back. They keep their valuables in a safe etc. But they're much more willing to give their credit card to shady websites than their bank routing info, specifically because it's easier to claw it back if there is fraud. But it isn't the criminal who pays for that. They get your credit card number via their shady website, then use it on a legitimate one, take possession of the goods and leave the legitimate merchant to take the chargeback when the user sees the fraudulent transaction on their credit card statement weeks later. The users also persist in using credit cards, instead of demanding a system with better security, e.g. one in which the card contains a chip that can connect to a PC or phone and requires the card to be physically present for the first remote transaction with a given merchant (you sign their key as authorized to charge you going forward), so you couldn't just breach one merchant, get all their customers' credit card info and use them fraudulently at any other merchant.
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> We don't put the consequences of bad security practices on the people who could have taken better precautions because they're "the victim" even though they're also the only person who could have prevented it. So instead we move the cost to the merchant via the credit card companies etc., or some other intermediary whose fault it was not. Eeeeeehhhhhhhhhhh waves hand The fact that tons and tons of what constitutes the backend of modern finance tech is the exact same shit that was originally built in the 70's is not something that I think can be overlooked so easily. A lot of what constitutes that ecosystem is just, practically allergic to security. Your social security number (if you're American) for example is basically a unified ID number that corresponds to everything from your medical records to your credit report to bank accounts to insurance, on and on, and accessing information with that number is nearly completely insecure. If someone gets ahold of yours and your basic public info, they can turn your life upside-down in such a way that will take hundreds of hours and thousands of dollars to resolve. And it would be like, trivial to lock that behind some sort of MFA situation with a state-centralized solution. The entire ecosystem around EFTs is just incredibly needlessly bloated and slow. I understand why they were slow when I was born, right? But we have advanced so much since then and yet EFTs despite just being like... digital checks remain basically inaccessible to working class people, despite them being objectively useful and, again, literally just checks in a different form. And their difficulty in use and desire for people to use something like them has given birth in turn to entire new financial products and services, many of which are pretty scammy in their own right, and subject to their own risks of abuse with even less overall security since most are tech companies and not insured with the FDIC. That's not to say that people shouldn't be security conscious, of course they should be. But that requires education on how to be that, and frankly I don't think it's unreasonable to say that the finance sector could, itself, make being security conscious quite a bit easier without dinging their own profits too badly.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The fact that tons and tons of what constitutes the backend of modern finance tech is the exact same shit that was originally built in the 70's is not something that I think can be overlooked so easily. Which is the thing enabled by moving the responsibility somewhere else. Because then their customers don't care, and the industry doesn't lose business to an alternative by failing to improve security. > Your social security number (if you're American) for example is basically a unified ID number that corresponds to everything from your medical records to your credit report to bank accounts to insurance, on and on, and accessing information with that number is nearly completely insecure. Which is why it should never be used for authentication, and isn't for companies with reasonable security, and doesn't have to be. You authenticate the user with passwords, cryptography, one-time email tokens, etc., not unchangeable not-so-secret numbers shared across all institutions. But see above regarding what causes them to not care about security. What we could have done, and maybe still should, is limit social security numbers to use as a tax ID and ban their use for any other purpose. Why does your healthcare provider need your social security number? They can issue their own patient ID if they need something like that, and then if that gets compromised it limits the scope of what it can be used for. > But we have advanced so much since then and yet EFTs despite just being like... digital checks remain basically inaccessible to working class people, despite them being objectively useful and, again, literally just checks in a different form. So this is also part of the scam. Credit cards charge the merchant ~3%. That's way more than the cost of handling chargebacks, especially because they also put the cost of chargebacks on the merchant. But then the finance industry doesn't want to make EFT easier to use, because then merchants would want to use it instead of paying 3% to the credit card companies, who are really the same companies and therefore drag their heels in making EFT easy to use. And the chargebacks are part of what enables this, because the customer might be willing to use a more secure payment system in order to save 3%, if they had any reason to care about security. The other part is credit card rewards programs, which make the user think they're getting rewards, when really they're paying twice that much or more to the credit card companies for the transaction.