3 ms·
Good points. I'm struggling to come up with a better second factor for "normal people". * Email: good if it is different than your login identifier and not ti
by mooreds 3y ago
Good points.
I'm struggling to come up with a better second factor for "normal people".
* Email: good if it is different than your login identifier and not tied to something ephemeral like work or school. But how many folks have two email accounts they regularly check.
* Passkeys: tied to a single device, so you need multiple devices. Or you can trust a bigco to sync private keys (!) across devices.
* Social sign-on: has the issues you point out, primarily that it is a single point of failure and the company providing the service doesn't do customer support (typically).
* Paper mail: latency is too high.
* Phone call: subject to same SIM card issues as SMS.
* Questions about identity, such as mother's maiden name: hard to find ones that are secure/private but can be accessed at scale only by "good" actors.
TOTP: hard to get normal folks to adopt.
What am I missing? Am I reluctantly forced to conclude that SMS is better than, or at least on par with, the alternatives?
- egberts1 3y agoTOTP is a great concept, except for trying to obtain the hash algorithm and secret key associated with the QR-based registration so that one can equally sync it across multiple devices/laptops/cellphones/desktop-PCs.
- phyphy 3y ago> TOTP Cannot count the number of times I have fomatted my phone and had to beg support teams for access to my accounts. I like to use custom ROMs and I cannot afford another phone just for TOTPs. I hate TOTPs. so much.
- mooreds 3y agoAsked on a slack and someone mentioned push notifications, which is a good option if your company has an application that someone would want to download. Not always possible for consumer apps (no thanks Chipotle, I don't want your app) but for some cases like banks it makes sense.
- j_not_j 3y agoThere are three more I have to use: 4x4 matrix: you are challenged with letter/number for row/column and must respond with the matrix entry. Not much better than totp; try to find it on your phone. photo array: given an array of challenge photographs, select the one you know is your secret photo. not-so-secret Q&A: what is your mother's maiden name? Name of your first car? Your second wife's third brother's cousin's name?
- mooreds 3y agoThanks for sharing these. Is the 4x4 matrix a shared secret you get at registration? I've definitely seen photo array as an additional factor in a 3 factor setup, never as the second factor.