3 ms·
Speculation, yes, but it's still science. She has a theory, and hopefully she'll come up with a way to test it. This is how progress happens. I modded the stor
by scott_s 18y ago
Speculation, yes, but it's still science. She has a theory, and hopefully she'll come up with a way to test it. This is how progress happens.
I modded the story up not because of the content releated to the headline, but because it appears the bee dances are 2D projections of the flag manifolds she studies. She may be wrong about the mechanism she proposed for why this happens, but when you find things that fit together so neatly in the natural world, that's a clear sign: this warrants investigation.
- geuis 18y agoIts only a hypothesis until she can find a way to test it. She discovered a similar mathematical principle that encompasses the envelope of recorded bee dances. That is not necessarily the only mathematical principle which can contain the same envelope. She then starts thinking about quantum states of quarks and such but doesn't have a valid way to test this yet. Its similar to ideas some people have that the brain utilizes quantum effects. No one has been able to experimentally prove or disprove this idea yet, therefore its still a hypothesis. If she, as a mathematician, had at least an encompassing mathematical model that could theorize how a bee's brain could interact on a neuronal level with quarks, then we could venture into calling it a theory. She doesn't have that though, so its still only a hypothesis.
- scott_s 18y agoYes, you are correct. But I think my point still stands.