8 ms·
Japan's precision moon lander has hit its target, but appears to be upside-down
- M95D 3y agoThis looks so much like one of the main menu background images of Kerbal Space Program. https://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/topic/79115-where-is-the-mun-or-bust-csm/#comment-1283989 https://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/topic/79115-where-is-th... "Mun or Bust!"
- j4yav 3y agoWhy appears to be? Is there some doubt?
- braiamp 3y agoBecause it could be a error in the instrumentation.
- world2vec 3y agoThe photo clearly shows it's upside-down.
- n6242 3y agoThey need more data to verify that the camera isn't also upside down.
- j4yav 3y agoBut then how will we prove the planet isn't upside down?
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoJust ask the Australians.
- chasd00 3y agoImagine the vehicle upside down and the camera twisted upside down so the photo is right side up but conflicts with the other sensors. In that situation I would take the rest of the day off.
- dcuthbertson 3y agoThe author is being coy.
- zem 3y agoit's just a manner of speaking
- tim333 3y agoAs mentioned elsewhere it's not actually upside down but seems to be tipped over about 90 degrees.
- midasuni 3y ago[flagged]
- shashanoid 3y ago[flagged]
- avidphantasm 3y agoSo it’s precise, but inaccurate.
- ryathal 3y agoJust accurate. Precision is a measure of how close each attempt is to the other attempts, you need at least two to get a measure of precision.
- sublinear 3y agoAccurate but imprecise. It was on target, but not precisely as expected.
- iamthepieman 3y agoAccurate but not reliable. Precision would come into play if they launched more than one.
- numpad0 3y agoThey had an engine anomaly and excess velocity from it, it wasn't a failure in intended tipover maneuver
- chasd00 3y agoIt wouldn’t be “precise” unless they launched a second one and the same thing happened at the same location. So accurate would be a better word but I would want to see multiple attempts before declaring it accurate or precise. (Thinking about this in terms of target shooting)
- samus 3y agoThat would be consistency.
- the-dude 3y agoWe choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard ... etc etc.
- whalesalad 3y agoPut it in reverse, terry!
- matthewfelgate 3y ago¿uʍop-ǝpᴉsdn llɐ sʎnƃ noʎ ǝɹɐ ʎɥʍ ʎǝH
- boeingUH60 3y agooʞɔǝƃ llɐʍ ɐ ɯɐ I ᴉH
- alenrozac 3y agoSomeone right now at JAXA is performing a dogeza.
- feverzsj 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nuker 3y ago[flagged]
- somenameforme 3y agoSomebody had way too much fun writing the lead paragraph: "Japan's space agency said Thursday that its first lunar mission hit the tiny patch of the moon's surface it was aiming for, in a successful demonstration of its pinpoint landing system—although the probe appears to be lying upside-down."
- sublinear 3y agoMaybe I'm saying what you're saying, but that's a sentence, not a paragraph. I find it very annoying when I encounter these and it makes me question the competence of the author. It seems like the complexity of the grammar used reduces with more writing experience. My opinion is that it should be: "Japan's space agency said Thursday that its first lunar mission hit the tiny patch of the moon's surface it was aiming for. It was a successful demonstration of its pinpoint landing system although the probe appears to be lying upside-down."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- devjab 3y agoIf my kerbel space program has taught me anything it is that being upside down, side ways or whatever after a semi-safe landing, is only an issue if you want to go home.
- gggmaster 3y agoOr if you want your solar panel to work.
- plasticchris 3y agoNah, kerbal panels are smart enough to pivot around
- yieldcrv 3y ago
- VMG 3y agois there a Japanese translation for Vorzeichenfehler?
- snickerer 3y ago日本のロケットが逆さまに。 符号誤差と言うより、月の新しいダンススタイルだね!
- numpad0 3y agonitpick - 誤差 is used for numerical deltas, 錯誤 would be more appropriate for boolean errors, or 反転 which is inversion, or transliteration for the English word, エラー also works("ー" is important, エラ without the elongation sign ー is gills on a fish)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wigster 3y agomaybe they used nasa code, but forgot that they were starting from the other side of the earth
- broeng 3y agoI think you might have hit the moo^Wnail on the head.
- analognoise 3y agoOne of 5 countries in the world. Amazing accuracy too - within 100m^2, and it lost an engine within 50 feet of the lunar surface. That’s an incredible result.
- jacknews 3y agoGoodhart strikes again.
- dcuthbertson 3y agoSLIM wins the outdoor high dive championship!
- andyjohnson0 3y agoThe snark is strong in this - but I'll resist and just note that landing on the moon is hard. I reckon they did exceptionally well with nailing the landing site, and hope that next time they'll be completely successful.
- HarHarVeryFunny 3y agoI wonder if they had accelerometers recording exactly what happened as it touched down and ended up on it's back? It was meant to use a rather odd "two-step" landing procedure where it first touches down on the lunar surface on it's rear/primary landing gear, then pivots forward/falls under gravity to also touch down on the front/secondary landing gear. Presumably this landing procedure was simulated under lunar gravity, but it seems there are multiple potential failure modes: 1) After rear "leg" touchdown, over-rotate forwards over front leg (ending up on back), OR 2) After front "leg" touchdown, bounce/recoil backwards off front leg, flipping onto back, OR 3) Front landing gear hits rock on one side (left or right), thereby flipping it sideways onto back The whole procedure seems to rely not only on having correctly simulated under lunar gravity (and with correctly simulated stiffness of the vehicle) to avoid scenarios 1) & 2) (which would be different under earth gravity), but also the softness of the landing site being uniform and as simulated - otherwise if landing site surface was harder (rock) or softer than expected, or uneven, then this type of pivot and bounce/not landing would not go as planned. NASA seems to have done a better job in designing fool-proof landing mechanisms, from the bouncing ball of the first mars rover, to the sky-crane landing of the latest one (which appears over-complicated, but no doubt was chosen at least in part because it is in fact more predictable than the alternatives).
- yencabulator 3y ago> NASA seems to have done a better job in designing fool-proof landing mechanisms The purpose of this landing design was explicitly to allow landing in areas that wouldn't previously be considered acceptable: slopes.
- jvanderbot 3y agoThe two-step sounds precisely like how all forward-moving aircraft land: Rear touch first. The alternative (front touch first) is dangerous for reasons any BMX biker could explain: You're much more sensitive to pitching forward from forward-of-gravity friction. I wouldn't read too much into that choice. More likely the velocity was a tad too high.
- mikecoles 3y ago
- NiloCK 3y agoRemember American Bugs Bunny digging through the earth to find himself upside-down in Asia? Life imitates art. Astonishing.
- mariodiana 3y agoSince I do remember that episode and got curious, I asked ChatGPT. Apparently, the antipodal point on the globe from Hoboken, NJ is somewhere in the Indian Ocean, southeast of Madagascar. From Tokyo, it's in the South Atlantic Ocean, northeast of the Falkland Islands. Undoubtedly, I'll forget all this by tomorrow morning and remember Asia :-)
- 8organicbits 3y agoWhy are you quoting ChatGPT? It's well know to confidently generate incorrect answers. The antipodes in question are very far from Madagascar and the Falkland Islands. Near Brazil and near Australia are much better answers. Blindly quoting ChatGPT just adds noise, you've got to fact check it (at that point, why bother asking ChatGPT?) https://www.geodatos.net/en/antipodes/united-states/hoboken https://www.geodatos.net/en/antipodes/united-states/hoboken https://www.geodatos.net/en/antipodes/japan/tokyo https://www.geodatos.net/en/antipodes/japan/tokyo
- mariodiana 3y agoThank you. Lesson learned.
- fhars 3y agoYou might enjoy the concept of an earth sandwich https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a30633840/earth-sandwich/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a306338...
- gnramires 3y agoSo... can they give it a bump? :)
- numpad0 3y agoNot mentioned in the article but touched in the conference is this is at least third time a 500N-class thruster failed on an ISAS probe. Last time it blew off on Akatsuki/PLANET-C Venus probe, before that was Nozomi/PLANET-B Mars probe, both cut apsis burn shorter than intended and later determined to be from salt buildups due to propellant leaks. Apparently apogee motors has been proving harder to do right than anticipated.
- maxglute 3y agoLooks like we need to add upsidedownness to the accuracy-precision spectrum.
- smeej 3y ago> For the pinpoint landing, Sakai said, he would give SLIM a "perfect score." I get being really, really proud of what you accomplished here, but...perfect? Really? You can't think of anything that maybe could have gone better? I know it's a much more sophisticated problem than this, but my inner child thinks they just forgot "the planet(oid) has to be 'down' on both ends of the trajectory."
- bee_rider 3y agoYou could engineer-ize that kind of problem. Maybe they plugged it into a complicated optimization package (want to minimize stresses from the landing) but forgot to add a crucial orientation related constraint… Probably, almost certainly, that isn’t what happened. But it could!
- wozniacki 3y agoI cant help but think the Japanophile contingent on HN are super eager to grade-inflate anything and everything remotely applause-worthy Japan related in general.
- cesaref 3y agoIf you can walk away from a landing, it's a good landing. If you use the airplane the next day, it's an outstanding landing. Chuck Yeager
- Fatnino 3y agoWell this one isnt being reused. But the passenger payloads deployed correctly, so we'll count that as walking away.
- numpad0 3y agoFWIW, ISAS Director General(the "faculty" president, also a PM in another probe in the past) Hitoshi Kuninaka scored it at 63 points, with 60 for the landing and bonus 1 point each for scientific camera and two payload probes, you could say he's more based or whatever. OTOH, in defense of the PM, the lander showed exceptional robustness against loss of an engine, so he'd have a reason to be proud of an explosionless landing.
- m3kw9 3y agoWait a sec, who’s the camera man?
- dan_hawkins 3y ago"The image was captured by the small baseball-sized robot called Sora-Q that was ejected from Slim moments before touchdown last Saturday." https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-68091389 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-68091389
- bluSCALE4 3y agoI think this is a best-worst case scenario. Pretty embarrassing if you ask me. I'm imagining the Star Trek teleporting thing and one guy appearing upside down, at an angle. Argh must be the Japanese teleporter.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoThat is an absolutely amazing photograph. It tells the whole story in a single picture.
- jnsie 3y agoI'm curious if it is standard practice to name space-related-entities in English ("Smart Lander for Investigating Moon, or SLIM"), if this is a translation and in Japan they call it something different, or why the named it in English in case this is an exceptional case.
- cbracken 3y agoIn Japanese it’s called both 小型月着陸実証機 (roughly: small moon lander probe) pronounced “ko-gata tsuki chakuriku jisshōki” or スリム (SLIM). It’s not uncommon to have an English name alongside the Japanese one for some scientific projects but not always the case — e.g. I don’t recall hearing the Hayabusa probe referred to by any name other than Hayabusa (which means falcon) in the news.
- jnsie 3y agoLovely insight. Thank you!
- dotancohen 3y agoYou might be the person to ask a question that my children asked years ago. In Japan, do Japanese cars have e.g. Toyota written on them in Japanese or English? How about the model names, especially for domestic-only models? Thank you!
- numpad0 3y agoBadges are often in English for cool factors, and then often katakana transcribed on documents and brochures for readability, e.g. Camry -> カムリ(kamuri). China does that inventing vaguely close Chinese names thing, e.g. Nokia -> 诺基亚(nuòjīyà, pronounced "no, ghee-yer") but that's confusing and we don't do that.
- dotancohen 3y agoThank you.
- 3y ago
- boastful_inaba 3y agoWell I now have context and explanation for the art I recently saw! See this X thread: https://twitter.com/MADOguchimoto/status/1750415013343596786 https://twitter.com/MADOguchimoto/status/1750415013343596786 The artist has anthropomorphized the lander - along with the "Sora Q" probe coming to document its misfortune.
- vpribish 3y agoIt’s not upside down. The up-side is facing away from the camera. This is basic stuff about this mission.
- mckirk 3y agoCan't help but imagine a passive-agressive lander AI... 'Ha, they told me a million times exactly _where_ I should land, but they never specified _how_ I should land'
- phkahler 3y agoHow could the U.S. get to the moon in the 1960's when it seems super difficult to do it today? Humans on board.
- jccooper 3y agoI suspect Apollo spent a great deal more money in quality assurance than this $120 million-ish project.
- orangepurple 3y ago[dead]
- pbc 3y agoMaybe there outsourced the landing firmware to Australia :)
- Aspos 3y agoCan somebody knowledgeable speculate why they are not using RCS to try turning the probe? I am guessing RCS engines can be reignited and don't need a certain orientation to work, right? Is Moon's gravity strong enough to cause damage to solar panels or antennas if probe tips?
- numpad0 3y agoIIUC, it has 12 strategically arranged RCS and 2(1 broken) main thrusters, ALL installed on a back facing mounting plate now pointing spaceward. I'm kind of suspecting there could have been cool factor involved in the decision leading to this design.
- Aspos 3y agoSo, yeah, what prevents them from rolling the probe using RCS?
- numpad0 3y agoThe fact that it's all pointing up!
- Aspos 3y agoBut the roll thrusters are not pointing up, are they?
- numpad0 3y agoSo, a pair of thrusters tilted 45 degrees up and down like ailerons can be called roll thrusters, and anyone who says that in deadpan straight face as an actual spacecraft engineer is completely insane, right? 1: https://www.isas.jaxa.jp/home/slim/SLIM/assets/img/SLIM_exp.png https://www.isas.jaxa.jp/home/slim/SLIM/assets/img/SLIM_exp....
- Aspos 3y ago
- ziofill 3y agothe engineers must have put a wrong sign somewhere
- sandworm101 3y agoIt isnt upside down. It wasnt ever meant to land thrusters-down. It should be on its side but is on its nose... 90 out rather than 180. The BBC has better renderings of how it should have landed. https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-68091389 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-68091389
- gibolt 3y agoHere is Scott Manley's great discussion of it: https://youtu.be/7bFiJvbKyPs?si=EPXhBYba3XnQN1YB https://youtu.be/7bFiJvbKyPs?si=EPXhBYba3XnQN1YB
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> They're the same picture. That juxtaposition is just uncanny. This japanese mission is surprisingly kerbal.
- lisper 3y agoThe first image on that page, the one showing the spacecraft nose-down, is said to be an actual photograph, not a rendering. Is that true? On the one hand, the image has a few flaws that I would not expect on a rendering, but on the other hand, how in the world could such a photograph have been taken? Were there two landers?
- FearNotDaniel 3y agoApparently there is an HN rule stating that we should never ask a commenter whether or not they have read the article posted. I respect that rule, it's there for a reason to prevent snark and all sorts of flamebait that can turn a forum toxic. However, for the sake of encouraging thoughtful and constructive discussion I am going to politely point out that the answer to that question was to be found in both the original article posted and the BBC story subsequently linked in the parent comment.
- _xerces_ 3y ago
- FredPret 3y agoThis is exactly the type of thing that happens to my Kerbals. It’s vindicating to learn that even the pros struggle to land on a particular spot and end up knocking over their moon lander anyway. Of course, their environment is much more detailed than KSP and doesn’t have a quick-save button. Space is hard.
- freeopinion 3y agoThe pinpoint accuracy of the landing is encouraging. As just one example of the implications, Japan could now have a mission whose purpose was to reach this probe and reposition it. The rescue mission could be vastly simplified because they could be extremely confident of landing within 100m without accidentally landing on the original probe.
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agohow about turning those engines on the probe ON again and see what happens, before its batteries totally go out ?
- wayeq 3y agoI bet the unit tests all passed though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]