4 ms·
I get the uncomfortable feeling that there are post-hoc and genetic fallacies floating around this piece, especially when the author keeps implying certain atti
by Terr_ 3y ago
I get the uncomfortable feeling that there are post-hoc and genetic fallacies floating around this piece, especially when the author keeps implying certain attitudes or beliefs are inseparable from Christianity. (Directly or indirectly, historically or potentially.)
> When we accept the Christian emphasis on weakness as a crucial prior, many other moral conclusions follow.
Perhaps... but it does not follow that emphasizing something while Christian is the only possible way to maintain those practical moral policies.
> Here’s the problem for the feminists busy sawing at the branch on which they sit: The same Christian ideas that grant feminism its moral force carry other implications.
This sounds an awful lot like "Feminism has to be Christian because it involves caring for the weak and Christianity is the only real way to do that."
> Whether we like it or not, we cannot place the protection of the vulnerable at the heart of our ethical system without reaching the conclusion that the unborn child ought not to be killed.
By that logic, when the "protection of the vulnerable" is "at the heart of your ethical system" then all those believers must be vegan.
Yet, strangely enough, Christianity has existed through many centuries without being notably known for that! The discrepancy means Christianity does not reeeeealy prioritize protecting the vulnerable... or else it means that additional conditions--like considering personhood--are permitted.
- aebtebeten 3y ago> ...like considering personhood... The Nazi ideal of femininity was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinder,_Küche,_Kirche https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinder,_Küche,_Kirche . At one point, they'd placed the camps for the League of German Girls and the Hitler Youth next to each other at the Nazi Party Days, which led to scandal when (several?) dozen nazi girls came home knocked up. Adding to the scandal, the Nazis had recently outlawed abortion.