4 ms·
As a pro solar pragmatic engineer response: > At the point my solar panel is installed all the death is built in. No. The toxic waste ponds left after creatin
by defrost 3y ago
As a pro solar pragmatic engineer response:
> At the point my solar panel is installed all the death is built in.
No. The toxic waste ponds left after creating your solar panels remain with all the carcinogenic after effects. The large volume of low level radiactive waste from lithium processing for batery banks remains in ponds (again, see Lynas, Malaysia) awaiting possible pond leakages.
> no one can agree what the impact of Chernobyl is. For instance, the UN cites a report and claims 4000 dead post accident. The report itself says 9000. Greenpeace says 90,000.
So .. how many actual body bags definitive linked then?
Once a waste problem hits ANOVA analysis to tease out deaths from other background deaths it's an acedemic exercise not dissimilar to estimating cancer deaths from eWaste (like solar panel production waste bybroducts).
> billions of years for the fuel (uranium)
So .. hardly breaks down at all, barely radioactive is what you're saying here?
Lead has a half life in the billions of years also - anywhere there's granite has uranium .. and it's the daughter products like Radon gas that fill granite valleys and basements that kill (like a packet a day smoking habit).
> 20k years to move the elephants foot out of chrernoble.
Why move it when it's sufficient to glass it over and stay a few hundred feet back ?
> IF we grew nuclear to 2000 plants the accident rate is going to go UP.
By how much though? Designs have changed since Chernobyl, lessons were learned from Fukishima (which had fewer deaths than the earthquake events and fewer deaths than serious mining accidents).
There are risks everywhere - it's difficult for many to pragmatic assess and compare risk.
You appear myopic WRT risk in the sense that some risk appears much larger and other risk isn't seen at all.
- arcticbull 3y ago> So .. how many actual body bags definitive linked then? Several hundred, most of them in the days and months immediately following the incident. The remainder are based on the UNSCEAR estimates over the fullness of time including people who commited suicide because they fear they're somehow contaminated. The majority of the deaths are derived the statistical projections of death. They estimate the impact of the fallout using the linear no threshold dose-response model (itself, contested for being too conservative). Suffice it to say Greenpeace is out to lunch with their projections.
- defrost 3y ago> Several hundred. Okay, for Part Two .. is that a high number or a low number when compared to a dam burst or a Bhopal type chemical plant accident? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster Point being, are we globally casual about all manner of destructive events and relatively over sensitive to OMG! nuclear!! accidents?
- mech422 3y agoWow..Thats a name I haven't seen in ages! I remember when that happened..Horrible and last time I looked (10-15 years ago??) the wells were still contaminated, and people still had to drink the water :-/
- arcticbull 3y agoSorry, I'm not the person you were replying to, I suspected they wouldn't so I wanted to share the research I did earlier on. I agree with you, and to me these numbers seem rather low relative to the known harms associated with other generation methods. To steelman, it could certainly have been a lot worse, but also, it wasn't, and much was learned that has been incorporated into modern designs.
- defrost 3y agoMy apologies if I seemed combative :) I noted at the time that you were another commenter and that you seemed in general agreement, I added further framing to point out that while a large number and that all death is tragic it's not been the case that nuclear power accidents have been worse than other industrial | power accidents in world history.
- arcticbull 3y agoNot at all, I would have replied the same way to OP, heh. I agree with you. All death is bad, less death is better, and the scale of nuclear accidents doesn't seem out of line with other industrial accidents. People get spooked by the spicy rocks.
- zer00eyz 3y ago> The toxic waste ponds left after creating your solar panels remain Yes we're bad at cleaning things up AT SCALE. We do stupid and shitty things to make a buck AT SCALE. People are terrible... >> Chernobyl, lessons were learned from Fukishima (which had fewer deaths than the earthquake events and fewer deaths than serious mining accidents). https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/international/2017/11/03/470349.htm https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/international/2017/11/... Disasters at power plants are dangerous. There is a coal plant whose explosion killed about the same number of people who died on site at chernoble. That toxic pond left over from solar. No one looks at it, no one gives a fuck about it, and though we know how to clean it up we dont. The clean up from Fukushima, from Chernobyl is at present close to 100 billon, and will continue for 1000's of years. The the melted down fuel on both sites will remain in place for a long time to come. ( https://apnews.com/article/japan-nuclear-fukushima-plant-decommissioning-water-release-fe953a597cc86004e525e1816d6c9c49 https://apnews.com/article/japan-nuclear-fukushima-plant-dec... ) Thats 860 tons of nuclear waste at Fukushima that we dont know what to do with. There is also the off site storage, that cotiains rubble removed from site, and the spent fuel from ponds on site. All of this material remains a threat, it will have to remain tagged, tracked and under guard for the rest of its life. OR get dug up, buried and hidden away in so deep that we hope no one finds it. > By how much though? Designs have changed since Chernobyl, lessons were learned from Fukishima ... There are risks everywhere - it's difficult for many to pragmatic assess and compare risk. The risks from nuclear are so high that everything gets tagged, tracked, checked on by national and international agencies, and remains under guard. Nulcears toxic pond is going to last for 1000's of years, longer than any human civilization has. It's going to need to be tracked, tagged and guarded for that time or it will become an existential threat all over again (dirty bomb any one). All the toxic ponds are over and forgotten and nuclear is rearing its ugly head, is costing us still. We know the risks for solar, we know the risks for nuclear. There is a reason no one is building more at scale. There is a reason we only built one (comerical) reactor in 40 years in the us. The economics of them dont make sense (no one wants 1000 years of liablity) . The one we did just build (new site, not adding to an existing one) is a whole story in and of itself, money the DOE and the DOD are all involved in that (and the potential for producing tritium in the us again).