6 ms·
Religious 'Nones' are now the largest single group in the U.S.
- hollywood_court 3y ago[flagged]
- fishtacos 3y agoAs a previous resident of Southcentral US and currently Southeastern US, I concur. Organized religion is the most potent socio-cultural poison in modern times in the US. Sadder than that, what we're mentioning in tandem is but a small portion of the larger inter-and-intra religious conflicts occurring worldwide, as well, or geo-political conflicts aided by them, which are almost equivalent. Even worse, in some respects. I'll forever miss you, Hitchens. Until we become worm food again, that is.
- whoswho 3y agoThis is an obtuse thing to say. Religion is simply being used as a cover to exact the will of people. You can remove religion, they’ll find a different rallying point and organize around it. And they have. In this day and age, we ought to know better than to blame religion for what are ultimately negative actions done by people who have mental problems.
- 0134340 3y agoReligious apologists have used this excuse for ages to try to invalidate those who criticize it but it's a really naive take to say that religion has no manipulative influence on people whatsoever. And in a different conversation, the religious are generally sure to admit that it has had manipulative influence on them.
- ChainOfFools 3y agoI think the point being made is that a religion is just an idea a bunch of people have. It doesn't have a mind of its own, Religion writ large doesn't either,. To blame religion is to take away the agency, and the accountability, of the people who actually do take action on these ideas.
- 0134340 3y agoI think you missed my point. Many religious people would say that their religion provides agency for them and you can't deny it, in itself, isn't an agent of forces, for better or worse.
- paulmd 3y ago> a religion is just an idea a bunch of people have. It doesn't have a mind of its own, Religion writ large doesn't either, it literally does and that’s the point of it as a memetic complex. It is quite literally the “mind of its own” that ensures its memetic survival. lmao @ the concept that large masses of everyday people all independently choose to not wear mixed fabric because they each performed a reasoned analysis of the facts and determined that poly-cotton blends are a threat to a 20th century society. Like that’s just facially ridiculous as a concept - of course religions have a mind of their own. This isn’t an empty point either, when religions make “yeah, it’s good to stone people to death for having sex with other men” as a tenent in their holy books then you are going to see that show up in people’s belief structures. It’s not just a one-way street from people’s personal feelings into the religion, the religion itself has a significant if not majority influence for deep believers. And while some people will buck the holy book (“the Old Testament doesn’t count” etc) - the reality is that most people will not, because that’s apostasy. Or at most they will abandon a few key precepts and keep the rest (“the gays can live, but marriage is still an inherently religious institution” etc). Go around a church and ask people and you will find the overwhelming majority believe in the overwhelming majority of their religion’s precepts. Because that’s why they’re there in the pews. It’s as ridiculous as claiming the US government “doesn’t have a mind of its own” - we have elections of course, so in principle people get the government they want, but it also doesn’t mean it doesn’t have things where it’s completely out of step (drug policy etc) and it certainly doesn’t change the fact that if J Edgar Hoover is coming after you (read: vigorously enforcing the legally ratified will of the people’s duly-elected representatives) that it’s gonna feel a whole lot like the USG has a mind of its own. The whole point of governments and corporations and religions is precisely that they have a will of their own. They are living creatures - self-executing colony organisms. Memes and systems of rules instead of genes. That’s why they exist and why they work and why they hold real power in the world.
- jackcosgrove 3y agoI agree religion is almost always a pretext. However I disagree that our problems are caused by people who have mental problems, or some other distinct group. I blame human nature, which while capable of social behavior is at root selfish and hypocritical.
- whoswho 3y agoWe are saying the same thing.
- Retric 3y agoReligions do adapt to the times, but they aren’t simply reflecting the current will of the people. Current pork prohibitions for example date back thousands of years. The only way they could simply reflect the will of the people is if they had no influence whatsoever.
- djha-skin 3y agoWho's "we"? Assuming that everyone in HN is without religion is false. I myself do not affiliate in the "None" group.
- talldatethrow 3y agoTo show you some contrast, I'm in California, and I think the lack of religion is the single biggest destructor of our current society. From the destruction of women/the family, to simple gluttony, sloth, and even pride.
- basil-rash 3y agoAlso in California, I was alone and unhappy until following Jesus. Since then I’ve met a ton of like minded youth in my area and we engage in all sorts of good and fun activities. It is without a doubt the best choice I’ve ever made (modulo Calvinist objections). I’d highly recommend anyone feeling unsatisfied by the social norms of the day to try visiting a few local churches of various denominations with an open mind.
- jemmyw 3y agoDo atheists destroy women? Or do you mean women no longer filling some role you think they should because of what your religion prescribes?
- talldatethrow 3y agoYa, I think watching most of my exgfs age into their mid and late 30s single or just into the next 0.5-1 year relationship, makes me think something is wrong. I wouldn't really know it was a problem if every single one of them didn't cry in front of me at some point during or after our relationship about being upset they have to work forever, feel like they might miss out on kids, that guys don't want to settle down anymore, and so on. Obviously the guys are at fault too. We were all clueless in our teens and 20s and not told what we should have been. I suppose parents could tell you, or friends, but they haven't been. The church for the most part is still trying.
- jemmyw 3y agoI don't think religion is the major factor there. Losing religion is lagging behind these social changes. I mean, anecdotally, I'm not religious and my wife is fiercely anti-religions and we have 3 kids and she doesn't work. We just decided to step outside the rat race we felt we were in and lose some of the lifestyle people seemed to think was so important - moved away from the city, only had one car, didn't take overseas holidays. There are quite a few people in the area I'm in who have made the same choices, some are religious, some are not. And we're still in touch with plenty of folks who match what you describe and they don't want to give up the career/city/car/lifestyle. Again, some of those people are religious and some are not. You could make broad strokes about the relationship between religion and social culture but I think in your comment you have the relationship inverted. When you have religious freedom religions are an expression of the social culture of their members, they are not an enforcement of the social culture on their members.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoI thought it was the breakdown of family structure. (50 years ago most kids were raised by their biological parents, now it's about half).
- tomohawk 3y agoHow many millions of people did Hitler, Stalin, Lenin, Mao, Pol Pot kill? They were all atheists. Communist parties like the CCP require all members to be atheists.
- manuelabeledo 3y agoHitler was very much not an atheist.
- 0134340 3y agoNone of those were done under the decree of atheism. There was no atheist doctrine giving them authority so you can't blame atheism.
- jackcosgrove 3y agoI think the loss of belief in some sort of ultimate judgment did give a certain type of person who is restrained by a fear of punishment rather than any ethical commitment or sympathies, more of a free rein.
- ChainOfFools 3y agoIf there is a moral code regarding killing in which atheism comes out as the stronger, more compassionate philosophical system, it would be the one that points this fact out, without an afterlife or any sort of reincarnation this existence is the only one you've got. And to deprive someone therefore of a meagre 90 or 100 years, the only glimpse they'll have out of potentially hundreds of billions of years underscores the preciousness of life and why it should not be taken.
- 0134340 3y agoThat's a nice hypothesis but it breaks down when you historically look at just how many people were killed in the name of religiuos jihads, crusades, witch trials (including all the individual people killed for rather benign reasons but against religious doctrine). The religious are just as guilty of using fear to kill others. I will give you that there are surely some who can say fear of gods kept them from killing but in fairness surely there are some who were set free from those gods and realized they didn't have to persecute others just because a religious doctrine says, even if their sympathies said otherwise to the doctrine.
- bitshiftfaced 3y agoWhat makes you say that?
- voisin 3y ago> the single most destructive force in our society I have no faith to speak of, but more and more I think we sorely need the role of a church to provide fellowship, reflection, community, and reinforce shared values. I certainly don’t believe any of the major religions are perfect at these tasks, but losing these as focal points or objectives has been a great loss to society.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoThere's a lovely sci-fi book series Ada Palmer's Terra Ignota where one of the speculative fiction aspects is that there had been some awful world war iii fought over religion, and the world decided to outlaw organized religion. Religion is allowed, but it's between you and your "sensayer" and they're not allowed to preach or tell you what to believe. It allows search & exploration, but everything has been set up to prevent organization. If you've read Sanderson's Mistborn, there's maybe some parallel to the Keeper Sazed, who inventories religions/beliefs & tries to help folks find beliefs that suit them.
- ren_engineer 3y agoreally comes down to strong ideology of any kind that rejects or censors other opinions that go against their ideology. The Soviets rejected Mendelian genetics and modern agriculture because it came from a monk and went against communist ideology. Lysenkoism killed 50 million+ in China and Russia as a result of the famines it created https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
- trelane 3y agoThe Soviets and Maoists were no slouches when it came to killing the infidels either. Gotta keep the populace from their opium.
- MattGaiser 3y agoThe demographics of a lot of religious denominations have got to be painfully inverted pyramid for a lot of them, with ironically, immigration probably being the one thing keeping any inflow into the pews.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoAnd having above replacement rate fertility:)
- ericra 3y agoHere is a link to the report that the article gets info from (but does not link to for some reason, unless I missed it): https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2024/01/24/religious-nones-in-america-who-they-are-and-what-they-believe/ https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2024/01/24/religious-no...
- MattGaiser 3y agoArticles rarely seem to link to source material.
- davewasthere 3y agoNow they just need to organise effectively. But how do you organise a disparate group whose only common characteristic is that they don't believe in imaginary deities?
- infectoid 3y agoStart a subreddit. I don’t think I’m actually joking.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIf the defining principal is you don't trust organization/s/, that might not help:)
- simonebrunozzi 3y agoAnecdotally, most people interested in The Network State [0] are nones. Perhaps that could be a "place" to aggregate them (us)? [0]: https://thenetworkstate.com/ https://thenetworkstate.com/
- ars 3y agoYou misread the article. They believe in God, they just are not interested in grouping. So basically exactly the opposite of what you said: They specifically do not want to organize.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAccording to the article, a small majority of "nones" believe in God or gods.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eagerpace 3y agoNo, they don’t. They aren’t a group. They’re not anti-religion, they just aren’t yes. Just because you’re not for something doesn’t mean you’re against it for others.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- blueyes 3y agoThe things people worship now, they don't call God. That doesn't always make them irreligious. I can think of more than one popular modern movement that is deistic, in that it fashions a god-like power out of some idea, a soul-like essence out of another. The church of the subreddit.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI'm not religious but I am spiritual.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI thought you were going to say the Church of, capital s, Science.
- 0134340 3y agoThat take assumes there's some sort of religious vacuum, that if they don't worship a god then those desires will go into worshiping other things. It's naive in assuming their lack of desire to worship someone or something is a lie. There are many who actually feel no need to worship anything powerful and even some of them assume the powerful are doing well enough to not need worshiped.
- blueyes 3y agoI don't think it does. I think it simply poses an analogy between religious activity and the other belief-driven activities that people constantly engage in, even when they are not actively attaching themself to a metaphysics and an afterlife.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoRedefining terms doesn't change a metaphor to literal truth.
- cal85 3y agoImportant to note Christians as a whole still vastly outnumber “Nones”.
- defrost 3y agoWhy? Ants outnumber both groups ... although global ant mass is only one fifth the dry weight of all humans. Addendum: No response to why it matters that christians outnumber others then? FWiW in Australia Christianity has been a matter of increasing indifference my entire life, it's mainly popular with those over 55 (moreso the over 70's) of European descent. https://www.abs.gov.au/articles/religious-affiliation-australia https://www.abs.gov.au/articles/religious-affiliation-austra...
- cal85 3y agoSorry, very late responding here. I never said it matters to me! I just pointed out the headline is false, unless you split up 'Christian' into separate denominations. But to answer your question anyway, it's obvious why people are interested in this kind of statistic: because billions of people follow a variety of different religions, which disagree on everything from how the world was created to how one is supposed to spend their free time, and these disagreements continue to cause a lot of violence.
- jfengel 3y agoIn the US, it matters a lot that Christians are, collectively, a majority, because of voting. Christians are not a unified voting bloc, but we have one political party that explicitly supports Christianity. It often uses Christianity as the basis of its decisions, to the detriment of non-Christians. It's not as simple as a tyranny-of-the-majority by Christians. There are also some nonbelievers who support them, in a way that baffles many observers because they're often explicitly voting against their own best interests. And there are some Christians opposed to this, though they should be able to use Christianity to support that choice and they don't. This further bolsters the nominally-Christian political party in forcing their version of Christianity on others.
- chaseadam17 3y agoHeadline is misleading. Christianity would be the largest if the survey didn’t separate the branches into Catholics, Protestants, etc.
- chrisoverzero 3y agoChristianity would be the largest if they themselves didn’t separate the branches into Catholics, Protestants, etc.
- ars 3y agoThat's a grouping meaningful to Christians themselves, but meaningless to non-Christians, which means it's not a good way for this survey to be grouped. To group things for statistics, pick the grouping level that is meaningful to all the entries in that same list.
- devindotcom 3y agoFunny that the word is the same as the 9th "canonical hour," Nones, which is what I thought at first. Probably because I'm reading a book set in the 15th century.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoFather/Bishop Robert Barron on the Nones: The Religious "Nones": https://youtu.be/tSVlZDnu-Uw?si=fBDGw_f_cFk-tgRO https://youtu.be/tSVlZDnu-Uw?si=fBDGw_f_cFk-tgRO The Rise of the "Nones": https://youtu.be/pG2mtELrxkg?si=ffxZjscRHKx5hJ8d https://youtu.be/pG2mtELrxkg?si=ffxZjscRHKx5hJ8d "Looking for the Nones": https://youtu.be/tuQq3nn15ZE?si=a2xlPemMAl6xbSJl https://youtu.be/tuQq3nn15ZE?si=a2xlPemMAl6xbSJl Signs of Hope with the "Nones": https://youtu.be/Pa_1GQHaGq4?si=oD520IccFaFy1paI https://youtu.be/Pa_1GQHaGq4?si=oD520IccFaFy1paI "Nones" Rediscovering the Bible: https://youtu.be/llYrTb4zqFQ?si=weh6iwCY6rlfL-NP https://youtu.be/llYrTb4zqFQ?si=weh6iwCY6rlfL-NP
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThese are great discussions on the topic. One of the challenges nones face is finding a meaningful third place / community.
- swat535 3y agoHe is absolutely one of my favourite Catholics and runs a massive worldwide ministry. Ironically his ministry really took off thanks to the New Atheists back when they were gaining steam with Hitchens and his gang. As a side note I loved Hitchens as well even if I disagree with his arguments myself. If I had a pick a favourite Atheist it would be him.
- ars 3y ago> "Within the Nones, however, atheists and agnostics are more likely to be politically and civically engaged, whereas those who responded that their religion is 'nothing in particular' are far less likely to vote." > "Pew also found that, overall, Nones are less likely to volunteer in their local communities than religiously affiliated adults." > "Most Nones believe in God or another higher power, but very few attend any kind of religious service." I'm getting quite a different picture of these "Nones". Rather than being atheist or agnostic, they believe in God, but just don't care about any kind of group or group activities. Almost like they have checked out from social public life. This also connects with surveys about 25% of Gen Z (virtually the same percent as these Nones) are not having sex: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-08-03/young-adults-less-sex-gen-z-millennials-generations-parents-grandparents https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-08-03/young-ad... 31% of Gen Z live with parents: https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/4405595-almost-a-third-of-gen-z-live-with-parents-or-family/ https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/4405595... There's also huge declines in people going out. (Although not the 25% that matches the other numbers.) To me this all paints a picture of people who are just tired, depressed, don't care, etc. I would very interested to know if these groups are all the same people, or if it's just a random 25% of any survey that doesn't care much.
- usrusr 3y ago“they believe in God, but just don't care about any kind of group or group activities.“ Is that an American thing? I might be projecting, but over here in Europe (or just Germany?) my impression is that many see some good in organized religion for the community aspects and historical continuity, but all that despite being quite certain that no god actually exists. I don't need to believe that god exists to consider it nice that our cathedrals and village churches aren't just museums, but living museums. Where professionals do give solace to people in need. Even many (most?) of those professionals seem to consider themselves more as custodians of an idea that does not have to be true to be good than as representatives of truth. They certainly don't go around declaring god is dead, but they certainly appear prepared to more on shared nature of belief than assumed truthfulness.
- 3y ago
- mensetmanusman 3y agoNote that like 7% of nones are atheists, most are just people that don't prescribe to organized religion.
- djha-skin 3y agoMisleading title. Makes it sound like Nones have a majority, instead of the 28% plurality. Catholics are at 24% and protestants at 27%.
- happytoexplain 3y agoI disagree - "largest single group" is quite explicit. More people probably understand what that means than know the word "plurality".
- why_at 3y agoPolls like this are always interesting to me because there's so much that can go into a person's answer to any of these questions. For instance, per the article most of these "Nones" still believe in God or Gods but don't subscribe to a particular religion. They're definitely not atheists as you might expect from the label. On the flip side, I know some people who would probably answer this poll as Catholic even though they don't attend church, don't believe that any miracles in the bible literally happened etc. To add to this even more, there is the lumper/splitter problem of which groups we count as one. As others have pointed out, Christians would outnumber the Nones if they were all put in the same group. But how we decide to slice things up can affect how the results look.
- fishtacos 3y ago>For instance, per the article most of these "Nones" still believe in God or Gods but don't subscribe to a particular religion. They're definitely not atheists as you might expect from the label. As an atheist, not that it makes me special in any way, since we're all born tabula rasas, it does work in favor of the slow elimination of blind faith due to the dilution of the importance of strongest way of dissemination of that poison. Personal faith has the capability to dissolve organized religion into nothingness. That is the ultimate succession toward worldwide secularism and hopefully, secular humanism.
- hprotagonist 3y agoWe're still about 20 points shy of 1906. 41% of the population considered themselves a member of a religious organization, in 1906, per the Census.
- ralmidani 3y agoLots of anti-religious sentiment being echoed here. Marx said the right thing for the wrong reason when he described religion as “the opium of the people/masses”. I definitely believe that religion can be effectively misused to pacify people who are suffering injustice. I would imagine in all major religions there are “clergy” (I hate both the word and the concept it represents) who tell people “it’s OK if you’re oppressed and poor while bad people literally get away with murder, everything will be righted in the next life”. Or, even worse, they use religion to whip people up into a frenzy and justify religious wars and genocide. All while amassing wealth and influence for themselves. However, as a practicing, fairly conservative Muslim, I know first-hand there are many religious scholars who live very modest, even impoverished lives while being a force for good and fighting against all forms of injustice. In fact, I would say the majority of dedicated scholars are not wealthy and not OK with injustice. The problem isn’t organized religion, it’s that we live in a time, perhaps unprecedented in history, when the world is generally rotten. The existence of charlatans and hypocrites is a reflection of that reality, and the ones who ally themselves with dictators and corrupt politicians are the loudest and most visible. Let’s not throw the baby out with the bath water.
- vba616 3y agoWhat was Marx's "wrong reason"? I had the impression his point was that religion distracts people from improving this world, not that he had a substitute. > we live in a time, perhaps unprecedented in history, when the world is generally rotten It has been argued - I forget by who - that this was the normal view of history across cultures for thousands of years, that there was a golden age before writing now fallen into decay, until Western progressivism became a prominent ideology. It seems to me there is a lot of religious scripture in support of the idea that history is a cycle of decline, corruption, false prophets, and indiscriminate punishment from God.
- geoduck14 3y ago>The problem isn’t organized religion, it’s that we live in a time, perhaps unprecedented in history, when the world is generally rotten I'm a Christian. One belief that I hold to is that all of creation is broken and needs to be fixed - and can only be fixed by the Creator God. Until that happens, we will continue to see people do bad things