3 ms·
They sold cars to stoke demand for batteries [1] and prove the world could move to EVs. They used battery manufacturing to scale up to build and sell utility sc
by toomuchtodo 3y ago
They sold cars to stoke demand for batteries [1] and prove the world could move to EVs. They used battery manufacturing to scale up to build and sell utility scale storage [2]. Nimble companies should always be prepared to pivot and maximize opportunities based on core competencies if they are to survive (Kodak and Xerox are examples of not doing this). If their EV business becomes second to legacy auto, but the org keeps expanding power controls and storage, is that a loss? They already forced every other automaker to go electric. The global energy market is somewhat larger than the light vehicle market, and batteries will be required to phase out every last fossil generator (not for energy arbitrage primarily, but for grid stability). The product is riding the global energy transition.
(early Tesla investor, no current exposure)
[1] https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/blog_attachments/gigafactory.pdf https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/blog_attachments/g...
[2] https://www.tesla.com/megafactory https://www.tesla.com/megafactory
- dragontamer 3y agoExcept Panasonic owns the cell-manufacturing portion of the Nevada Gigafactory. And Panasonic can sell those cells to anyone.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoBut they don’t, because Tesla’s demand is voracious and they are a proven partner. Supply chain relationships matter.
- dragontamer 3y agoBut Tesla has constantly sold these cells as "their cells", constantly misleading (almost lying) to the public like these are a significant moat or technology that's exclusive to Tesla. Panasonic also has very tight relationships with Toyota, for example. There's nothing about the Panasonic/Tesla relationship that's really a "moat". ---------- If all your competitors need is just to establish a relationship with Panasonic to get their technology, that's a very different thing than like holding a patent or other "true moat".
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou’re upset about words when all that matters is outcomes. Toyota ain’t building anything until they start rolling EVs off the line at scale. They’ve been talking about EVs longer than Tesla has been building them. https://insideevs.com/news/694239/toyota-cuts-ev-sales-expectations-record-profit/ https://insideevs.com/news/694239/toyota-cuts-ev-sales-expec... (“Toyota Cuts EV Sales Expectations By 39 Percent As Its Profits Soar Thanks To Hybrids”) If I had a Tesla share for every time someone said “but $legacy_automaker plans!” Talk is cheap, building is hard.
- dragontamer 3y agoToyota's battery consumption is pretty high all else considered, thanks to Prius, Rav4 Prime, etc. etc. etc. No pure EV, but plenty of opportunities to establish a relationship with Panasonic. In any case, my point remains clear. There's no kg/watt-hr advantage that Tesla holds here. Panasonic is the owner of the chemistry. Its Panasonic that's key to this relationship. And if not Panasonic, then CATL, the Chinese company Tesla has partnered with for Gigafactory Shanghai. In both cases, Tesla does NOT own the chemistry. That's a huge deal to anyone trying to pretend that "Tesla is an energy company" or other such claims. ---------- The energy companies are Panasonic and CATL in this relationship. These are the companies people should be focusing on. Moving into Utility scale, the bulk of the manufacturing problem is once again, CATL (for pushing LiFePo4 chemistry), or Panasonic (for the other Li-ion chemistry Tesla uses). EDIT: It does seem like LiFePo4 is the push for utility-scale, while the Panasonic one looks increasingly obsolete in comparison. But there are very high tariffs on CATL cells for USA's use at least. I do believe there are some non-Chinese LiFePo4 producers selling in the USA's market. EDIT: But its _these_ issues that are currently plaguing the utility market today. I'm not really sure if Tesla is on top of its utility game. Or if the Panasonic relationship is even relevant (especially due to the current trend of LiFePo4 vs other Li-ion chemistries).
- redwall_hp 3y agoThey're also building new factories to do just that, with a third US one on the way. https://insideevs.com/news/670249/panasonic-third-ev-battery-plant-us/ https://insideevs.com/news/670249/panasonic-third-ev-battery...
- epistasis 3y agoCars are a much higher margin way to sell storage than selling it without the attached car. Or at least that has been the justification in the past for Tesla prioritizing shipping cars over more grid storage. I don't think that's changed, as grid scale storage is a cut throat market. Maybe residential storage paired with solar will have higher margins, but the limit there is regulatory, and there's also ample competition in the solar market. Which is to say, cars really seem to be Tesla's best bet and core driver of other value, IMHO.
- amluto 3y agoHmm. This is a bit of a silly comparison, but Tesla will sell a Megapack with 1.9MW, 3.9MWh for about $2M, “ready to install”. Signature Solar has an 18kW, 61.44kWh battery plus inverter setup for about $22k. If you could buy 64 of these, you get just over 3.9MWh and 1.15MW for about $1.4M. Tesla’s system presumably operates at a nicer 480V and is intended to scale larger, but the cost isn’t amazing if you pretend this is apples to apples.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoUtilities and energy developers buy solutions, not parts. Megapack + Autobidder is turnkey. Also, cost sensitive buyers are not a great cohort to market to; market to folks with capital to spend and who understand the value prop. Let someone else chase garbage margins. Price is what you pay, value is what you get. https://electrek.co/2023/09/15/tesla-autobidder-product-330-million-energy-investors/ https://electrek.co/2023/09/15/tesla-autobidder-product-330-... ("Tesla’s little-known Autobidder product has already made over $330 million for energy investors")
- amluto 3y ago> Also, cost sensitive buyers are not a great cohort to market to … > ("Tesla’s little-known Autobidder product has already made over $330 million for energy investors") A lot of investors looking for returns would love to save 30-40%. I also wonder whether Autobidder, which is hosted on Tesla’s cloud, would actually be very exciting for grid operators who value reliability and things like black start. Anyway, my real point is that I’m comparing apples to oranges, but Tesla’s value proposition in the energy sector doesn’t look unassailable to me. If I worked at a company like EG4, I would seriously consider trying to compete.
- blackoil 3y agoCATL is bigger battery maker and CATL, BYD are better at it.