6 ms·

Type 1 and RA in the family here and they are life re-defining conditions. Everyone of us is watching this research like a hawk.

josefresco 3y ago
Same here, I have RA, my dad had RA (remission now) and I have two sisters with still mysterious auto-immune disorders. This news and all news on treatments that aren't blunt immune response hammers gives us hope. Tip for those watching prescription TC commercials: When they say "you may be more prone to infection" take it very, very seriously.
- hirvi74 3y ago
  > When they say "you may be more prone to infection" take it very, very seriously. I suppose it depends on the disease. I have read rather conflicting research about whether certain DMARDs/Biologics actually increase cancer rates, infections, etc.. I'm about the furthest thing from a expert one can be in regards to this topic, but I will say that I have always purposely tried to stay away from those medications "just in case." I am also in a fortunate enough situation that I am not required to go on such medications despite having the option in order to live a mostly normal life. I'm not some "big pharma bad" person, but something about those medications have never sat well with me. I suppose for many, the risk of the cure outweighs the risk of the disease. But in regards to something as integral as the human immune system, I real do not want to "fuck around & find out" as people say these days. Until there is a legitimate cure or safer medicines, I suppose I am (dis)content with the level of disease activity I currently have.
  - parrellel 3y ago
    This is great if your particular immune disorder doesn't kill your ability to walk or eat or type, but the increased cancer risk definitely seems worth not having to comparison shop foot-pedal mice. I've read that the increased cancer risk isn't so much an increase in cancer rate as a reduction in bodily policing of early cancers?
    - spondylosaurus 3y ago
      Unchecked autoimmune diseases tend to raise cancer rates, too. In which case now you have cancer and an active autoimmune condition... so you should've just taken the meds in the first place :P Plus, as I've rationalized it for myself: you have decent odds of surviving cancer if it's caught early enough, but damage to your organs/skeleton is permanent and irreversible.
      - hirvi74 3y ago
        > In which case now you have cancer and an active autoimmune condition Good, then the chemo can kill two birds with one stone. ;) I'm kidding, but it's not like people without AI diseases are immune to cancer. So, I'd imagine it'd be kind of hard to definitively link causality. Everyone is focused on the cancer side-effects, but that honestly seems like a lesser concern to me than some of the other potential side-effects of some of the biosimilars. > damage to your organs/skeleton is permanent and irreversible There are a lot of cancer survivors that would agree and are living examples of this statement too. Surviving != a full recovery.
        spondylosaurus 3y ago
        > a lesser concern to me than some of the other potential side-effects of some of the biosimilars Biosimilars as in, Infectra vs Remicade? I haven't heard of anything in that vein :O
        frankus 3y ago
        Also if the chemo wipes out your immune system apparently you can start fresh (Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation).
    - hirvi74 3y ago
      > This is great if your particular immune disorder doesn't kill your ability to walk or eat or type Mine can, and still might, it just *fingers crossed* has not happened yet and hopefully never will. However, I do have many of signs that have a high correlation with such outcomes. =( The cancer is not my concern. For my disease in particular, the research, from what I have read, seems to believe that biologics do not increase the rate of cancer more than what the AI disease already does. Some studies have shown that there might even be a decrease in cancer once inflammation is controlled. With that being said, it's the other potential side-effects like new incidents of Demyelinating diseases, Lupus-Like Reactions, seizures, liver damage, heart failure, etc.. The biologics seem to be getting safer with each iteration, and I would feel more comfortable on something like Skyrizi than Humira or Enbrel, but still not comfortable enough to pull the trigger. Back story: 8 years ago, I had a minor sore throat and flu-like symptoms for about three days, then I was back up an running. Less than two weeks later, I was diagnosed with an autoimmune disorder. Thus, I am quite hesitant to open the doors for more infections. As the saying goes, "You can't put shit back in the horse."
  - deleted 3y ago
    [deleted]
- spondylosaurus 3y ago
  Have you had increased infections on RA meds? (Not sure what TC stands for in context, but I'm guessing you take biologics.) Maybe I'm the outlier, but spending several years on TNFis hasn't lowered my immune threshold in any noticeable way, knock on wood. Oral steroids, on the other hand... when I go on those every fungal creature in a ten-mile radius decides to take residence on my skin. Nasty fuckers.
  - Log_out_ 3y ago
    Most of them are defacto immune system suppressants
  - josefresco 3y ago
    I did take biologics and did have an uncontrollable (skin related) infection. Not life threatening but life altering. I stopped the biologic and within 2 weeks the infection was gone.
    - spondylosaurus 3y ago
      Ouch! Glad it cleared up after you quit the meds, at least.
robocat 3y ago
RA = Rheumatoid Arthritis. Everyone, please explain your acronyms especially if they are common knowledge to you. We all have unique contexts - especially us foreigners!
1kurac 3y ago
Just curious, has any of you tried, or would you consider trying, fasting for a few days every month? https://chriskresser.com/could-type-1-diabetes-be-reversible-after-all/ https://chriskresser.com/could-type-1-diabetes-be-reversible...
- lolc 3y ago
  The article hypes increased beta cell generation but as far as I skipped doesn't address the characteristic T1 immune response attacking them. Seems incomplete to me.
  - 1kurac 3y ago
    If the immune response is stalled/reversed during the fast, the causal agent seems pretty clear (and corroborated by studies innumerable): it's the food you eat.
    - lolc 3y ago
      I didn't see anything about immune response. The omission is a rather common occurrence with crank T1 "advice". Which is why I stopped reading.
- dbrueck 3y ago
  I think the problem is that if you can't fix whatever is causing your body to attack your own pancreas first, it doesn't really matter if you're able to slowly regenerate the insulin-producing cells - you can't make any headway.
- cesarvarela 3y ago
  Fasting is great! After 48 hours, you can feel how "inflammation" goes away. The problem is that it is difficult to make money out of it, so it doesn't get the attention it deserves.
darkclouds 3y ago
[dead]

josefresco 3y ago

Same here, I have RA, my dad had RA (remission now) and I have two sisters with still mysterious auto-immune disorders. This news and all news on treatments that aren't blunt immune response hammers gives us hope. Tip for those watching prescription TC commercials: When they say "you may be more prone to infection" take it very, very seriously.

hirvi74 3y ago
> When they say "you may be more prone to infection" take it very, very seriously. I suppose it depends on the disease. I have read rather conflicting research about whether certain DMARDs/Biologics actually increase cancer rates, infections, etc.. I'm about the furthest thing from a expert one can be in regards to this topic, but I will say that I have always purposely tried to stay away from those medications "just in case." I am also in a fortunate enough situation that I am not required to go on such medications despite having the option in order to live a mostly normal life. I'm not some "big pharma bad" person, but something about those medications have never sat well with me. I suppose for many, the risk of the cure outweighs the risk of the disease. But in regards to something as integral as the human immune system, I real do not want to "fuck around & find out" as people say these days. Until there is a legitimate cure or safer medicines, I suppose I am (dis)content with the level of disease activity I currently have.
- parrellel 3y ago
  This is great if your particular immune disorder doesn't kill your ability to walk or eat or type, but the increased cancer risk definitely seems worth not having to comparison shop foot-pedal mice. I've read that the increased cancer risk isn't so much an increase in cancer rate as a reduction in bodily policing of early cancers?
  - spondylosaurus 3y ago
    Unchecked autoimmune diseases tend to raise cancer rates, too. In which case now you have cancer and an active autoimmune condition... so you should've just taken the meds in the first place :P Plus, as I've rationalized it for myself: you have decent odds of surviving cancer if it's caught early enough, but damage to your organs/skeleton is permanent and irreversible.
    - hirvi74 3y ago
      > In which case now you have cancer and an active autoimmune condition Good, then the chemo can kill two birds with one stone. ;) I'm kidding, but it's not like people without AI diseases are immune to cancer. So, I'd imagine it'd be kind of hard to definitively link causality. Everyone is focused on the cancer side-effects, but that honestly seems like a lesser concern to me than some of the other potential side-effects of some of the biosimilars. > damage to your organs/skeleton is permanent and irreversible There are a lot of cancer survivors that would agree and are living examples of this statement too. Surviving != a full recovery.
      - spondylosaurus 3y ago
        > a lesser concern to me than some of the other potential side-effects of some of the biosimilars Biosimilars as in, Infectra vs Remicade? I haven't heard of anything in that vein :O
      - frankus 3y ago
        Also if the chemo wipes out your immune system apparently you can start fresh (Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation).
  - hirvi74 3y ago
    > This is great if your particular immune disorder doesn't kill your ability to walk or eat or type Mine can, and still might, it just *fingers crossed* has not happened yet and hopefully never will. However, I do have many of signs that have a high correlation with such outcomes. =( The cancer is not my concern. For my disease in particular, the research, from what I have read, seems to believe that biologics do not increase the rate of cancer more than what the AI disease already does. Some studies have shown that there might even be a decrease in cancer once inflammation is controlled. With that being said, it's the other potential side-effects like new incidents of Demyelinating diseases, Lupus-Like Reactions, seizures, liver damage, heart failure, etc.. The biologics seem to be getting safer with each iteration, and I would feel more comfortable on something like Skyrizi than Humira or Enbrel, but still not comfortable enough to pull the trigger. Back story: 8 years ago, I had a minor sore throat and flu-like symptoms for about three days, then I was back up an running. Less than two weeks later, I was diagnosed with an autoimmune disorder. Thus, I am quite hesitant to open the doors for more infections. As the saying goes, "You can't put shit back in the horse."
- deleted 3y ago
  [deleted]
spondylosaurus 3y ago
Have you had increased infections on RA meds? (Not sure what TC stands for in context, but I'm guessing you take biologics.) Maybe I'm the outlier, but spending several years on TNFis hasn't lowered my immune threshold in any noticeable way, knock on wood. Oral steroids, on the other hand... when I go on those every fungal creature in a ten-mile radius decides to take residence on my skin. Nasty fuckers.
- Log_out_ 3y ago
  Most of them are defacto immune system suppressants
- josefresco 3y ago
  I did take biologics and did have an uncontrollable (skin related) infection. Not life threatening but life altering. I stopped the biologic and within 2 weeks the infection was gone.
  - spondylosaurus 3y ago
    Ouch! Glad it cleared up after you quit the meds, at least.

robocat 3y ago

RA = Rheumatoid Arthritis. Everyone, please explain your acronyms especially if they are common knowledge to you. We all have unique contexts - especially us foreigners!

1kurac 3y ago

Just curious, has any of you tried, or would you consider trying, fasting for a few days every month? https://chriskresser.com/could-type-1-diabetes-be-reversible-after-all/ https://chriskresser.com/could-type-1-diabetes-be-reversible...

lolc 3y ago
The article hypes increased beta cell generation but as far as I skipped doesn't address the characteristic T1 immune response attacking them. Seems incomplete to me.
- 1kurac 3y ago
  If the immune response is stalled/reversed during the fast, the causal agent seems pretty clear (and corroborated by studies innumerable): it's the food you eat.
  - lolc 3y ago
    I didn't see anything about immune response. The omission is a rather common occurrence with crank T1 "advice". Which is why I stopped reading.
dbrueck 3y ago
I think the problem is that if you can't fix whatever is causing your body to attack your own pancreas first, it doesn't really matter if you're able to slowly regenerate the insulin-producing cells - you can't make any headway.
cesarvarela 3y ago
Fasting is great! After 48 hours, you can feel how "inflammation" goes away. The problem is that it is difficult to make money out of it, so it doesn't get the attention it deserves.

darkclouds 3y ago

[dead]