3 ms·
It seems like an odd framing to me. If you have a vulnerable device, you’ll need to replace it, whether or not it is actively being exploited. So, you’ve been d
by bee_rider 3y ago
It seems like an odd framing to me. If you have a vulnerable device, you’ll need to replace it, whether or not it is actively being exploited. So, you’ve been damaged by the device producer’s negligence.
- mustache_kimono 3y agoImagine: The vulnerable device is on your internal network, and the likelihood of damages is very small. I suppose you can construct a regime in which feds come in a fine you simply for having an insecure device, but a lighter touch approach is to wait for damages, which given this scenario, perhaps never comes.
- bee_rider 3y agoI think I might not have been totally clear. If you’ve been sold a vulnerable device, you are the victim. You have to replace the device. The damage is to you, the one who did the damage is the company that sold you a defective device. They should pay to replace the functionality, and some punitive fine, as a start. Then we can get into whatever damage their negligently designed device did (did it participate in a DDOS? Did it attack other devices on your network?)
- mustache_kimono 3y ago> If you’ve been sold a vulnerable device, you are the victim. Ahh. Simply having to replace a defective device would be "damages". The only Q would be: Was it reasonable to replace given the threat?
- bee_rider 3y agoI’ve edited it, hopefully for clarity :)
- abirch 3y agoYou seem to have fortunately survived orphaned software. I've seen scientific software running on a 15 year old OS. The lab equipment functioned so we took out the Ethernet port to prevent viruses.
- bee_rider 3y agoThis reminds me of cars—the first time I got a recall notification, I nearly panicked. Oh man, I’m going to have to bring it in and get a new one or something? What a pain! Nope, the recall usually just means you bring it to a mechanic and they get a replacement part that does basically the same thing, but hopefully correctly this time. Fixes like yours… hey, if it works it works, right? But the device is not exactly what was sold, if it had an Ethernet port and presumably some corresponding network functionality, there’s some value they ought to owe you for. Maybe the fix could be to ship out locked down raspberry pi to sit between the device and the rest of the network, haha.
- abirch 3y agoOrphaned as in the vendor is out of business. Like there's no mechanic, no parts, no nothing. Only the last version of the software and the working scientific equipment.