2 ms·
Honestly, there should be tension and arguing there. For example, Google should (IMO) very clearly be treated as selling products in the cases of Android and Ch
by bee_rider 3y ago
Honestly, there should be tension and arguing there. For example, Google should (IMO) very clearly be treated as selling products in the cases of Android and Chrome despite the fact that these technically are related to open source projects.
I’m quite glad they aren’t ignoring the complexity.
- alilleybrinker 3y agoI agree that there are details to sincerely work out here. I know in earlier drafts the wording of the "commercial" definition was such that it could be read to classify cases like a solo OSS developer who makes $10/month from GitHub Sponsors as "commercial" (and thus assign liability to them). This received substantial pushback from organizations like (as I recall) the Eclipse Foundation and the Electronic Frontier Foundation. I'm not sure where the draft language stands now.
- bee_rider 3y agoThat seems like a really hard edge case. I wonder how the liability works out for, say, a carpenter who makes home-made chairs if one breaks and hurts somebody.