I agree with you. She may be technically correct (the best kind!) but only in post hoc analysis of completed games. That should have 0 bearing on a coach's de

I agree with you. She may be technically correct (the best kind!) but only in post hoc analysis of completed games. That should have 0 bearing on a coach's decision making during a game, since from the in-progress perspective it's still a 12.5% increase in win probability. So from a coach's POV, what's the worst that can happen: not getting the conversion and still losing by 1 (assuming :00 on the clock and no additional opponent possession). What's the best that can happen: tying and having an opportunity to play for the win in ensuing possessions.