3 ms·
No kidding. The first part, and even the alpha sounds cool, but the quantum part is bunk. She seems to have skipped chemistry: what physical mechanism can a bee
by ars 18y ago
No kidding. The first part, and even the alpha sounds cool, but the quantum part is bunk. She seems to have skipped chemistry: what physical mechanism can a bee use to detect these fields? After all they are made of proteins. What chemical mechanism would do it?
Plus saying "detect quantum fields" is meaningless anyway.
There is no such thing, it's a mathematical abstract, it's not an actual thing. There are many kinds of fields, saying quantum field gives some information about the type (for example that it's discontinuous), but it's not a specific field.
- ionfish 18y agoActually, there are some interpretations of quantum mechanics under which the wavefunction is an "actual thing", for example De Broglie's pilot-wave theory and Bohm's developments of it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohm_interpretation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohm_interpretation
- dhimes 18y agoThe other way to think about it is we all interact with quantum fields all the time. A photon is a quantum field. Interacting with electric, magnetic, or an other force is interacting with a quantum field. Nothing new there. [/Disclaimer: I read the comments above and declined to read the article. ]
- david927 18y agoExactly. The idea that bees could somehow be experiencing a six-dimensional manifold doesn't seem crazy to me.
- Retric 18y agoBee's have a ~million neurons and they have a simple language etc. Now you might assume they think like we do and then say "there brains are to tiny to do that" and then go off on a tangent. However, building a neural net with 50k neurons would let them do complex calculations without understanding them. They don't need to "think", flap wing, flap wing, flap wing, flap wing to fly just have a few cells which pulse every few fractions of a second and it works. So, the calculation of a six fold manifold might be going on in their tiny brains but it's not thought just raw math. Evolving systems don't need to produce maintainable code they just need to work. The idea that our brains can get our eyes to work and walking works etc but bee's can't do calculations is silly. They don't need to understand what's going on just simulate something that works.
- helveticaman 18y agoTrue. I would like to add that an eye can detect a single photon, but there's really no way to use that meaningfully to make use of quantum mechanics at a bee-level.