3 ms·
It is measurable, it improves the standard of living of those affected, and has other environmental benefits. On the measurable, the fact that some has found t
by graemep 3y ago
It is measurable, it improves the standard of living of those affected, and has other environmental benefits.
On the measurable, the fact that some has found that the measures were wrong is encouraging. It can be monitored. When will we find out if tree planting offsets do not happen? Years or decades down the line. In this case I think it is probably fixable - obviously the new stoves are not as good from the users point of view. I suspect outside experts designing things without user input -
they should be treated as customers and their feedback incorporated early.
I think you are entirely right about reluctance to change some people's lifestyles, but is not as simple as "rich western" vs "poor non-western". For one thing, the world is not longer that simple - there are plenty of rich non-western countries. Even economies that are not as rich per capita as a whole, have both substantial rich groups and regions within them and they have large economies (and CO2 eomissions) in total.
Also, it is western countries that have reduced their emissions the most. I linked to a blog post of mine with a graph before: https://pietersz.co.uk/2023/03/co2-emissions-will-keep-rising https://pietersz.co.uk/2023/03/co2-emissions-will-keep-risin... on HN.
The problem you mention happens a lot within countries. It looks to me as though, for example, net zero policies in the UK will affect the lifestyle of the rich far less than that of the hoi polloi.
- _Algernon_ 3y agoEncouraging is not the term I would use. This has been known for years. There was a huge piece of journalism a couple of years (which I am unable to find atm, I'll edit it in if I find it) ago that went through a bunch of carbon offsets projects including this one and already revealed the problems with it. If anything this just shows that even though problems are revealed, they keep happening, and companies keep getting away with their greenwashing claims. That is the exact opposite of encouraging.
- graemep 3y agoThis is not just carbon offset though, it is emissions reduction too (not sure what the proportions are) and it could work. Agree completely about offsets being used for green washing. There is a large element of Goodhart's law here. Policy is driven by meeting metrics.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoThis one ? https://www.france.tv/france-2/cash-investigation/saison-4/172255-climat-le-grand-bluff-des-multinationales.html https://www.france.tv/france-2/cash-investigation/saison-4/1... More than a couple of years though (2016).
- grotorea 3y agoThere was a couple of The Guardian investigations, but it was mostly about another type of questionable carbon credit source, forest protection: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verified_Carbon_Standard#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verified_Carbon_Standard#Contr... And the fact that this article mentions Gold Standard as being much better with the cookstoves and it avoiding some of that forest credits makes me think it's the good carbon credit issuer. Anyone with access to the scientific article proper can tell who issued the carbon credits for cookstoves? edit: I also forgot where I read this but IIRC Verra has more corporate origins while Gold Standard comes from the NGO world may also be relevant.
- berkes 3y ago> It is measurable, it improves the standard of living of those affected, and has other environmental benefits. The last two parts have nothing to do with greenhouse emission reduction. They are important, don't get me wrong. And valuable. But if the only reason to start reducing greenhouse emissions in a sector is "it is measurable", we are doing a poor job. Because I am certain there's far lower-hanging-fruit, that is also measurable, but simply not as popular as "these other people have to change their lifestyle" and therefore omitted. Edit: I am specifically thinking about severely reducing meat from our diets (i.e. go partially, or entirely vegetarian), or about not flying to Bali for a 2 week holiday. Because those are far bigger than 2% globally. Estimates go to resp. 30% and 15%. Reduce half of all of them, and the "cooking on wood" might reduce 1% (which acc. to the article actually is merely 0.1%) and 15% or 7.5% resp. It is blindingly obvious what has the biggest impact on greenhouse gas emission reduction.
- graemep 3y agoMeat is another thing that is oversimplified. It varies a great deal between countries, and depends what meat you compare to what vegetarian food. Locally produced grass fed meat vs grain fed meat, for example. Fake meat suffers from many of the same problems as meat.
- zo1 3y agoNo one is going to agree to such non-trivial impacts to their lives so long as it seems unfair. I will never give up meat, but will do so tomorrow if we blocked all mass global transportation networks, mandated fruit trees in all houses, and blockaded all imports from China. Those are far bigger issues for me and that means I'll be stubborn as a voter.
- wolvesechoes 3y agoYeah, that is my issue with all that climate-saving, top-down efforts. Normal people have to ditch everything: meat, travels, stoves. And they probably really should, but EVERYONE should do that. Yet, those that advice or enforce such polices always have some excuse that justifies their exclusion from their own policies. So it is not that suprising that there so much resistance, because it really is just another way for the rich and powerful to keep poor people in their places.