3 ms·
You can make dry ice directly from air, by cooling and compressing it, because after the condensation of water the other gases have much lower boiling temperatu
by adrian_b 3y ago
You can make dry ice directly from air, by cooling and compressing it, because after the condensation of water the other gases have much lower boiling temperatures than carbon dioxide.
Obviously, the efficiency of the cycle is lower when starting from air instead of from pure carbon dioxide, but the input energy is unlimited, as it comes from solar or wind energy.
This does not compete directly with batteries, which have very good cycle efficiency but poor mass, volume and maximum storage time. It competes only with other energy storage technologies that can also store energy for many years and/or which have comparable energy per mass and energy per volume ratios.
To judge whether the technology of this company can be competitive, we need some numbers that they do not provide. Nevertheless, it is also impossible to dismiss it a priori, because there are good chances for it to have a good enough efficiency.
What they say about having a better efficiency than the 2-step process through carbon monoxide is plausible, and even the indirect Fischer-Tropsch synthesis has been economically viable in the past, in the absence of enough fossil fuels, despite the fact that it is not competitive today, as long as the fossil fuels are still cheaper.
- leoedin 3y ago> Obviously, the efficiency of the cycle is lower when starting from air instead of from pure carbon dioxide, but the input energy is unlimited, as it comes from solar or wind energy. What sort of energy inputs are required for a kg of CO2? If the process is so inefficient that e-fuels contain only a few percent of the energy inputs, then it's pretty unlikely to be a good use of electricity (even excess renewable energy). That's the pivotal number. kWh per kg of CO2. It needs to be reasonable. Ultimately only 0.04% of the air is CO2. You need to process a lot of air to extract large amounts of CO2.
- adrian_b 3y agoIf you look through your window, it is likely that you will see the proof of concept that the energetic efficiency of extracting the 0.04% of CO2 from air and the hydrogen from water, and of converting both of them into hydrocarbons can be high enough to allow you to breathe and to satisfy your hunger. The artificial alternatives already have better efficiency for capturing the solar light and for extracting the hydrogen. It remains necessary to improve the efficiency of the CO2 capture and of the conversion to hydrocarbons.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoAir has a bit over 400 parts per million CO2. Extracting CO2 from air in meaningful amounts involves pumping a lot of air. The preferred source of CO2 for most carbon capture schemes is the exhaust fumes of those burning fossil fuels. Basically how this works is that you burn some dead dinosaur juice/lumps/gas, you capture (a fraction of) the CO2, use lots of energy to turn that into synthetic dinosaur juice/gas, and when you burn that, 100% of the CO2 ends up in the atmosphere. That's right, 100% CO2 comes from fossil deposits and at the end of the process 100% of it ends up in the air.
- jonkho 3y agoAnd 100% of the CO2 found in fossil deposits also originated from the atmosphere, many, many years ago (I.e when the fossils were not in the ground, that quantity of CO2 pre-existed in the air). Let us pause and think about that.