3 ms·
This is a pretty good argument for doing away with pulling randos into jury duty.
by kazinator 3y ago
This is a pretty good argument for doing away with pulling randos into jury duty.
- KingMob 3y ago??? Historically, non-random juries were comprised of white male landowners. Not an improvement.
- kazinator 3y agoI didn't mean to bring focus on the randomness of jury selection. (In fact it's obvious that in this particular case, it was very biased, which was a big part of the problem.) Rather, "juror" should be someone's job. People pulled off the street are not going to have the critical thinking skills, and will be broadsided by pressure tactics and manipulation. Also, some people who are inconvenienced by jury duty will be resentful and just focus on their personal exit strategy (get it over with ASAP).
- KingMob 3y agoProfessional jurors wouldn't be an improvement. They will get cozy with, and biased towards, the people they see and interact with on a daily basis. It completely undermines the concept of being judged by a jury of your peers if there's a permanent juror class. I went to school at the University of Virginia, which offered something like this for honor trials. (UVA Honor violations were specifically: lying, cheating, or stealing.) For a trial, you could choose between a random student jury, a jury of Honor Society members, or a mix. Statistics showed that non-random juries were way more likely to convict students, and I have no doubt permanent jurors would do the same over time. I understand your criticisms for sure, but the alternatives are worse.
- kazinator 3y agoYour argumentation isn't very strong, because you're presenting random jury selection from the population as being the only viable alternative, due to issues in other alternatives, without considering ways in which those could be mitigated or fixed. Elsewhere in the thread, there are comments about how some countries have eliminated random juries; so a good start would be to study how things work elsewhere. > non-random juries were way more likely to convict students All that matters is whether they were more or less likely to correctly convict or acquit. If it so happens that all the accused liars, thieves or cheaters are actually guilty, then the higher the conviction rate, the more accurate it is. Honor Society members are not professional jurors; they are just a set of people from which a jury is less randomized than from a broader set.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> All that matters is whether they were more or less likely to correctly convict or acquit. Which you have no way of knowing, because if we had a process to determine that, we wouldn't need juries to begin with. What you can tell, by comparing the outcomes between decisionmakers, is which way their bias leans relative to the alternative. And "biased towards convicting more innocent people" is bad.
- kazinator 3y ago> And "biased towards convicting more innocent people" is bad. How can you write that following a sentence which admits we "have no way of knowing". We can't even say that more convictions is no fewer innocent convictions, let alone more. Say that 1% of the accused in some jurisdiction are innocent. In that situation, the ideal conviction rate is 99%. It's possible to have a 2% conviction rate where the convictions are wrong half the time (and the acquittals are all wrong), and a 1% conviction rate where the decisions are all backwards in relation to guilt.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're assuming the full-time aristocrat will do a better job, which is the thing there is no evidence of. It could be completely the opposite -- the aristocrat makes their decisions based on political connectedness, finding everyone guilty except their cronies who are actually guilty. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, the assumption should not be that either of them is inherently better at the job, and then a higher total conviction rate implies a higher false conviction rate.
- Cacti 3y agoI know why uninformed comments pop up here on non-tech articles, but why is it always so aristocratic and elitist. Was the bullying really that bad?
- kazinator 3y agoA jury has a very important decision to make, which could send someone innocent to prison for life. Selection of those people calls for serious gatekeeping. It's not a community college finger painting night class. Say, would it be aristocratic/elitist to refuse to fly in an airliner staffed by people pulled off the street for pilot duty?
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Selection of those people calls for serious gatekeeping. It's quite the opposite. You should have to convince all of them, and so the jury should include everyone. The aristocrats and the finger painters. > Say, would it be aristocratic/elitist to refuse to fly in an airliner staffed by people pulled off the street for pilot duty? What if the staff are overseen by a pilot and in order to crash the plane you need to convince all 12 randos and the pilot to crash the plane? Would've prevented 9/11.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Cacti 3y agoI’m confused here. Are you asking if I would get in a plane piloted by someone with zero experience or training?
- gambiting 3y agoAs a non American, I don't understand how juries are compatible with the entire idea of a fair justice system. I'm very very glad they don't exist where I live. The whole idea of "being judged by your peers" is lovely on paper but cases like this show how stupid this is.
- trilbyglens 3y agoYep as an American living in Europe, my experience is that most people here are shocked to learn we put the lives of accused people in the hands of non-expert random people from the street. It's not a great system, but it's still only a tradeoff between the bias of one person (a judge) and the average of the bias of many (a jury)
- socialdemocrat 3y agoThink you are a bit quick to judge what people in Europe think. Juries have also been widely used in Europe. They are not unknown. It depends entirely on where you are. Britain famously use juries. That is where the US gets it system from. In. All Nordic countries have had them. In Norway we phased it out years ago, but it isn’t one judge but several. Some are picked by citizens others are professionals. They determine guilt together.
- kazinator 3y agoSeveral judges is a good idea; a judicial panel. Particularly in grave criminal cases. Maybe not so much in shoplifting or red lights.
- gambiting 3y ago>>Britain famously use juries. And it's a mistake there as well, but fortunately Brits keep juries only for the worst of the worst cases, jury trials are relatively rare. >>Juries have also been widely used in Europe. And now they are not. I can't speak for every reason behind this in every country that decided to do so, but I'm sure if you looked into it it would be "because it isn's working out". >>but it isn’t one judge but several. and this is how it should be done - you still get judged by a panel of people who can vote, but they are actually trained in the law.