3 ms·
It would perhaps be useful to run some experiments to see whether having a jury of 12 discuss is more accurate than having 12 independent jurors that don't comm
by eru 3y ago
It would perhaps be useful to run some experiments to see whether having a jury of 12 discuss is more accurate than having 12 independent jurors that don't communicate. (Or only communicate in very formally prescribed ways, but never meet.)
You could run those experiments by constructing cases, or re-constructing known cases.
- skissane 3y agoThe problem with measuring the accuracy of juries, is what do you measure them against? Whether the person is really guilty? In the general case, you can't actually know that. Even for people who are wrongfully convicted, we can't always say the jury made the wrong call. In many of those cases, the conviction is overturned due to new evidence being discovered, or because the police or prosecution wrongly hid exculpatory evidence from the jury, or because the defendant's lawyer was grossly incompetent – in those cases, it is entirely possible the jury made the right call given the evidence actually presented to them, even if it turned out ultimately to be the wrong one.
- devmor 3y agoFor this hypothetical comparison process, I imagine that real cases could be used and re-presented with actors in place of the defendants and witnesses?
- rrr_oh_man 3y agoWhat would be the thing you test in this case?
- pests 3y agoIf 12 communication jurors vs 12 non communicating jurors make different decisions.
- eru 3y ago> The problem with measuring the accuracy of juries, is what do you measure them against? Whether the person is really guilty? In the general case, you can't actually know that. Yes, in the general case you can't know that. That's why you need to construct artificial cases where you do know. Very similar to getting labelled training data for your machine learning.
- timv 3y agoIt would also be interesting to consider smaller groups for discussion. Break the jury into 2 groups of 6, or 3 groups of 4 people. I wonder whether you could get the benefits of weighing the evidence collectively but reduce the influence that 1 or 2 dominant jurors might have. If 2 or 3 independent groups reached the same conclusion, does that increase the chances of them being correct?