3 ms·
> "There are multi-day periods with low wind and solar output." That's the real problem. Days of storage are required if most power is coming from non-dispatch
by Animats 3y ago
> "There are multi-day periods with low wind and solar output."
That's the real problem. Days of storage are required if most power is coming from non-dispatchable sources. Batteries are not cost-effective for that, at least not at present. Electricity to hydrogen and back is maybe 30% efficient. Pumped storage is much more efficient but you need the right geography - two nearby lakes at very different elevations.
This keeps leading back to natural gas peaking plants.
- otherme123 3y agoNote that the simulation is only for Germany. If you add other countries to the grid, there will be less no solar-no wind days. But also peaking gas plants are not that bad. We should dream about a zero emission scenary, but a 90% less emissions is not bad either, and we can always get better and better. This is, in fact, the current trend: each month is cleaner than the last.
- sofixa 3y ago> Note that the simulation is only for Germany. If you add other countries to the grid, there will be less no solar-no wind days. But more transmission losses.
- pmontra 3y agoThere is always some place on Earth where it's windy, where the sun shines, where it's summer. I have no idea if transporting such high loads on a global grid is feasible (let's say Australia's summer sun powering Europe in winter nights) but that probably works better in a peaceful world.
- defrost 3y ago> let's say Australia's summer sun powering Europe in winter nights https://www.afr.com/companies/energy/germany-s-660m-pitch-for-australia-s-green-hydrogen-20240118-p5ey7m https://www.afr.com/companies/energy/germany-s-660m-pitch-fo... Not all energy is electricity, this is a deal for Australian sunlight --> Hydrogen | Ammonia --> Germany https://arena.gov.au/blog/hydrogen-deal-unites-australian-innovation-with-german-expertise/ https://arena.gov.au/blog/hydrogen-deal-unites-australian-in...
- Animats 3y agoAveraging over subcontinent-sized areas still leaves a 4:1 wind variation in wind output over a day. You can look at the data for the PJM grid (most of the east coast) and the CAISO grid (most of the west coast), and see 4:1 ranges most days. Tying the east and west coast together is technically feasible. China has a megavolt DC grid with links thousands of miles long. (China's cheap energy sources are in the northwest, while the big loads are in the southeast, so that makes sense.) But it doesn't seem to make sense for the US. The US wind belt is roughly from the Texas panhandle north to Canada. That area does not, as yet, have enough links to either coast.
- Certhas 3y ago30% efficiency is fine if you only need it for like 5% of the overall energy consumption. The price and efficiency of H2 storage is contained in the models.