5 ms·
This is a pretty good argument for having criminal jurors submit their verdict in the form of vote by secret ballot and then just having the court count the bal
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
This is a pretty good argument for having criminal jurors submit their verdict in the form of vote by secret ballot and then just having the court count the ballots and see if they were unanimous.
- munchler 3y agoThe whole point of jury deliberations is to discuss and debate the case. It would be counterproductive to keep one’s position secret during the process. Multiple votes, including informal straw polls, are often necessary.
- eru 3y agoIt would perhaps be useful to run some experiments to see whether having a jury of 12 discuss is more accurate than having 12 independent jurors that don't communicate. (Or only communicate in very formally prescribed ways, but never meet.) You could run those experiments by constructing cases, or re-constructing known cases.
- skissane 3y agoThe problem with measuring the accuracy of juries, is what do you measure them against? Whether the person is really guilty? In the general case, you can't actually know that. Even for people who are wrongfully convicted, we can't always say the jury made the wrong call. In many of those cases, the conviction is overturned due to new evidence being discovered, or because the police or prosecution wrongly hid exculpatory evidence from the jury, or because the defendant's lawyer was grossly incompetent – in those cases, it is entirely possible the jury made the right call given the evidence actually presented to them, even if it turned out ultimately to be the wrong one.
- devmor 3y agoFor this hypothetical comparison process, I imagine that real cases could be used and re-presented with actors in place of the defendants and witnesses?
- rrr_oh_man 3y agoWhat would be the thing you test in this case?
- pests 3y agoIf 12 communication jurors vs 12 non communicating jurors make different decisions.
- eru 3y ago> The problem with measuring the accuracy of juries, is what do you measure them against? Whether the person is really guilty? In the general case, you can't actually know that. Yes, in the general case you can't know that. That's why you need to construct artificial cases where you do know. Very similar to getting labelled training data for your machine learning.
- timv 3y agoIt would also be interesting to consider smaller groups for discussion. Break the jury into 2 groups of 6, or 3 groups of 4 people. I wonder whether you could get the benefits of weighing the evidence collectively but reduce the influence that 1 or 2 dominant jurors might have. If 2 or 3 independent groups reached the same conclusion, does that increase the chances of them being correct?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey can debate the case all they want. The arguments a juror makes might imply how they're planning to vote, but deliberations are over when each juror has made up their mind. You don't have to say how you've made up your mind for deliberations to end, you just declare that you have and when the last one has then everyone marks their ballot and packs up their things.
- Cacti 3y agoThe why is kind of incredibly important though in law.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoJuries don't have to explain why as it is.
- awb 3y agoThat would probably create a lot of hung juries which wouldn’t be ideal from a very time and cost perspective.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoOnly if you allow the prosecution to retry the case in that event.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoWho cares?
- Gunax 3y agoI suppose it is for discussing, but does the discussion actually promote justice? Afterall, that's why we have juries. I am not sure whether the deliberation actually increases or decreases false verdicts.
- kergonath 3y agoOn the contrary. They can have all the deliberation they want but the votes need to be secret to avoid peer pressure, bullying, blackmail or coercion. In all these cases, the juror is not following their conscience, which is supposed to be the whole point. It has been known for centuries that public voting is ripe for abuse.
- hackerlight 3y agoConvictions would go down a lot without the social pressure element that's for sure. But with a sufficient number of jurors it'd become impossible to convict even if the person is clearly guilty, because you just need one to dissent.
- Ekaros 3y agoSounds like then there is not sufficient proof given. Or maybe that one juror doesn't agree with the law. Also reasonable reason to let people go free.
- hackerlight 3y ago> Sounds like then there is not sufficient proof given You can always find 1 person who will disagree about anything? If you have 1000 jurors that each vote independently I would find it hard to imagine that anyone can get convicted, even people you are basically certain are guilty. After some N, the probability of a conviction becomes indistinguishable from 0, which is not a good system either.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe number is typically 12 rather than 1000, and it's pretty unambiguous that it's possible to convince 12 random people to convict someone when the evidence is clear. And sometimes when it isn't.
- kazinator 3y agoThis is a pretty good argument for doing away with pulling randos into jury duty.
- KingMob 3y ago??? Historically, non-random juries were comprised of white male landowners. Not an improvement.
- kazinator 3y agoI didn't mean to bring focus on the randomness of jury selection. (In fact it's obvious that in this particular case, it was very biased, which was a big part of the problem.) Rather, "juror" should be someone's job. People pulled off the street are not going to have the critical thinking skills, and will be broadsided by pressure tactics and manipulation. Also, some people who are inconvenienced by jury duty will be resentful and just focus on their personal exit strategy (get it over with ASAP).
- KingMob 3y agoProfessional jurors wouldn't be an improvement. They will get cozy with, and biased towards, the people they see and interact with on a daily basis. It completely undermines the concept of being judged by a jury of your peers if there's a permanent juror class. I went to school at the University of Virginia, which offered something like this for honor trials. (UVA Honor violations were specifically: lying, cheating, or stealing.) For a trial, you could choose between a random student jury, a jury of Honor Society members, or a mix. Statistics showed that non-random juries were way more likely to convict students, and I have no doubt permanent jurors would do the same over time. I understand your criticisms for sure, but the alternatives are worse.
- kazinator 3y agoYour argumentation isn't very strong, because you're presenting random jury selection from the population as being the only viable alternative, due to issues in other alternatives, without considering ways in which those could be mitigated or fixed. Elsewhere in the thread, there are comments about how some countries have eliminated random juries; so a good start would be to study how things work elsewhere. > non-random juries were way more likely to convict students All that matters is whether they were more or less likely to correctly convict or acquit. If it so happens that all the accused liars, thieves or cheaters are actually guilty, then the higher the conviction rate, the more accurate it is. Honor Society members are not professional jurors; they are just a set of people from which a jury is less randomized than from a broader set.