3 ms·
I don't have a lot of data points, but I've lived in both the U.S. (non-public healthcare) and Denmark (public healthcare) and the quality and convenience of th
by _delirium 15y ago
I don't have a lot of data points, but I've lived in both the U.S. (non-public healthcare) and Denmark (public healthcare) and the quality and convenience of the latter is quite good in comparison, imo. The amount of sheer bureaucracy is much lower in Denmark as well; I don't have to file reimbursement forms for a half-dozen different doctors, worry about copay rules or what precisely constitutes a "preexisting condition", or spend time on the phone with insurance agents to figure out why a bill was rejected. It just works: you go to the doctor, you never receive a bill, the end. Outcomes seem on par or better than in the U.S. as well.
However I would be open to a voucher-type system where the actual providers are private, competing for customers who pay into a common risk pool. It's the tying of the risk pool to employers that's most problematic to me, and which imo severely weakens other parts of the free market, by reducing labor mobility. That might actually improve some free-market elements of healthcare, since the actual customers would choose providers, rather than their employers doing it for them.
- paulhauggis 15y agoEveryone I know that lives in a country with public health care says the same thing: 1) long wait times for any major surgery 2) sub-par equipment/hospitals 3) elderly patients don't get treated as well as they should Nearly all of them come over to the US and pay for major surgery. I also find it strange that in any of these discussions, nobody that lives under universal health care will talk about the bad things. Without this sort of honesty, I will never want a public system in the US.
- _delirium 15y agoDo you know anyone who lives in Scandinavia? And, beyond anecdotes, have you looked at any actual studies or statistics? I don't think every public health system is well run, but I think the better ones are better-run than the US, and lead to much greater peace of mind, because I don't have to worry if I'm covered or not--- I know I am. The total expenditures are actually lower, too, because the U.S. spends a lot of money on public healthcare, just very inefficiently. Perhaps I'm part of some evil conspiracy to lie about how I like living in Denmark, but the numbers seem to back me up. There's plenty of other things I'll be happy to complain about about Denmark and Danish culture, too, but the healthcare system isn't one of them. I don't think I've been treated well in the US healthcare system, in any case, and there were long wait times and subpar equipment. I also had to change doctors when I changed jobs, something that Denmark doesn't require me to do. And I had to spend a lot of time on the phone with insurance companies, who seemed to always make mistakes and miscode things; anyone who thinks governments are bureaucratic hasn't tried to deal with a large corporation's phone tree. But I suspect you are putting ideology above any actual interest in rationally evaluating different healthcare systems based on evidence.
- specialist 15y agoSince we're comparing anecdotes, friend #1 went to Thailand for eye surgery ($5k vs a gajillion dollars), friend #2 went to India for Lasik (sic?). Yes, like all other systems, universal health care has problems. Canada definitely has a shortage of specialists in rural areas. So what? The USA has plenty of shortages. If you desire "honesty" in a policy debate, I encourage you to start with the widely published, thoroughly vetted, and oft cited comparative studies. If you're feeling very daring indeed, and want to learn something, you could start with google. http://www.google.com/search?q=health+care+costs+per+capita http://www.google.com/search?q=health+care+costs+per+capita http://www.google.com/search?q=life+expectancy+by+country http://www.google.com/search?q=life+expectancy+by+country TL;DR: Canadians spend 1/2 per person and live 2 years longer.