10 ms·
I'm not sure what Apple would bring to cars. Waymo is almost uncatchably far ahead in self-driving. Tesla has already brought minimalism to cars, and will proba
by xnx 3y ago
I'm not sure what Apple would bring to cars. Waymo is almost uncatchably far ahead in self-driving. Tesla has already brought minimalism to cars, and will probably have an affordable car with mass appeal by 2028 if BYD doesn't get there first. Apple might be better off making a luxury fifth wheel.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dataking 3y agoApple vision pro integration ;-)
- dmoy 3y ago> if BYD doesn't get there first I mean, BYD is already there. It's mostly a question of tariffs vs subsidies at a geopolitical level now.
- bobthepanda 3y agoBYD is also subject to C-NCAP safety standards, not NCAP, which is much less stringent. Does BYD make an NCAP compliant car?
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoBYD sells in Europe. How would they be able to do it without meeting the Euro-NCAP standards which are actually higher than global NCAP?
- cpursley 3y ago100% this. I don't think Americans in general are aware of what the current state of Chinese cars (EV and gas) is like right now since they're not in our market. It's worth checking out some YouTube videos, this guys channel is pretty good for Chinese EVs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmQPwlHixWo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmQPwlHixWo
- juunpp 3y agoThat BYD U8 is $150k. Who can afford that shit?
- dmoy 3y agoThat's like knocking Toyota affordability because the Lexus LS whatever is >$100k. BYD has $10k cars and >$150k cars
- practicemaths 3y agoIf approximately half the cost of an EV is the battery pack I'm terrified by the prospect of a $10k car...
- dmoy 3y agoYea I do want to know what the costing on this is. It's a bit hard to figure for BYD because: (a) there's unknown government subsidies going on, and (b) they mine and refine their own lithium and make their own batteries (also make Tesla's batteries too, I think). So their battery cost is... unusually low
- cpursley 3y agoNobody, unfortunately Chinese vehicles are not sold in the US of A. Which is too bad, we need the competition.
- bluescrn 3y ago> I'm not sure what Apple would bring to cars The world's first non-repairable car. Minor fault, major accident, or inevitably-degraded battery? No problem!, just throw it away and buy the latest model, like you would with a phone or tablet! You wanted an upgrade anyway, didn't you? (Meanwhile, Apple will keep boasting about their green credentials...) What about consumables?... You'll still be able to change the tyres, brake bads, and wiper blades. But Apple will take 30% from every sale/service of these items, and the vehicle won't start if you install non-genuine-Apple replacements. (And then there's the chargers... don't expect to be able to put electricity into that battery without Apple getting their god-given 30% cut) Starting at $99,999 for the base model (50 miles range). A maxxed-out model will do 750 miles, but they're really going to make you pay for those battery up-sells, and the well-glued-in battery pack is non-upgradeable after purchase.
- BoostandEthanol 3y agoThey wouldn’t be the first. The Audi A2 launched without a bonnet you could open. Oil changes were done using a hatch in the grille.
- bobthepanda 3y agoAlso it seems like a lot of the new EVs have sky high repair bills, like the infamous $42,000 Rivian fender bender repair. https://www.theautopian.com/heres-why-that-rivian-r1t-repair-cost-42000-after-just-a-minor-fender-bender/ https://www.theautopian.com/heres-why-that-rivian-r1t-repair... So if you're going to have minor bumps result in a repair bill more expensive than many cars, it's not that much of a stretch to say that'd make it virtually unrepairable.
- red369 3y agoInteresting! But may have actually not have been sealed. The Wikipedia page says: “ The bonnet was widely rumoured to be sealed – Car and Driver wrote: "...feature of the A2 that may foretell the future: the sealed hood". Actually, the bonnet is easily removed, being held in place by two twist-lock catches. The bonnet, weighing 8 kg, then comes away from the car altogether, unlike the usual hinged flip-up arrangement on most other cars. Due to the service hatch, the bonnet does not need to be removed frequently for access to the engine.”
- threeseed 3y agoTesla cars have poor build quality, average interiors and awful after-sales support. So there is definitely room for Apple to take the Tesla route but improve in those areas.
- pokstad 3y agoHow is Apple going to have better quality? Apple specializes in making devices with almost no moving parts. Mechanical products are very different.
- EA-3167 3y agoApple can literally buy that expertise with petty cash.
- oldpersonintx 3y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 3y ago$1,000 monitor stands beg to differ!
- Smoosh 3y agoI think the more appropriate example would be the Mac Pro wheels. https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-wheels-kit https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MX572ZM/A/apple-mac-pro-w...
- eps 3y ago$700 for 4 wheels. Jeeeezus!
- mensetmanusman 3y agoMore expensive than the corolla wheels.
- wolverine876 3y ago> Tesla has already brought minimalism to cars, I certainly wouldn't call that minimalistic. Do you mean the exterior surface? The controls, UI, etc. are complex and difficult. People can even open the door the first time they ride in one. The big screen and all its software are not minimalistic.
- _ea1k 3y agoIf minimalism means intuitive, I no longer find the android/ios ui minimalistic either. They've gone to a system of gestures that aren't particularly intuitive. The buttons were far more discoverable.
- rodgerd 3y ago> I certainly wouldn't call that minimalistic. Surely you jest. A fart app is automotive minimalism!
- xnx 3y agoThere's been a long term trend in Apple hardware of simplification (removal of buttons, ports, flourishes, etc.). The iPhone was a big jump in that direction from the Blackberry, but I can't imagine an Apple Car being that different from a Tesla/Rivian/BYD one.
- fragmede 3y agoa fully self-driving car need not have a driver's seat, so it might be quite different.
- xnx 3y agoEventually yes, but in the near future seats will probably stay forward facing for crash safety and motion sickness. Waymo's steering-wheel-less vehicle will be the Zeekr CM1e https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a45711737/zeekr-cm1e-waymo-autonomous-taxi/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a45711737/zeekr-cm1e-waymo...
- resolutebat 3y ago
- spandrew 3y agoSomeone in 2006 asked what Apple would bring to the cellphone market, too. The issue with Apple and the automotive market is the units don't have enough turnover for Apple's business model to thrive.
- bdcravens 3y agoThe iPhone wasn't that big of a leap. At that point, they had 30 years of experience shipping computers, and 5+ years shipping handheld devices.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- snowwrestler 3y agoIt’s easy to say that now but at the time there were obvious huge obstacles to Apple doing a great cell phone. And not just technical; the business relationships between cellular network owners, handset manufacturers, and software companies was totally different. Apple essentially had to restructure the industry to make the iPhone what it is today. I suspect a car would need to have a similar impact in order for Apple to succeed. They would need to launch a new kind of product that just happens to have the shape of a car.
- bigstrat2003 3y ago> Someone in 2006 asked what Apple would bring to the cellphone market, too. And that would be a fair question. The iPhone never did anything others weren't already doing, nor has Apple ever done that in recent history. They sell products not because they're better, but because they've convinced people Apple is cool.
- twoWhlsGud 3y agoI think you underestimate how bad the competition has usually been. Apple is bad but the competition is usually terrible. Tech stuff has always had a pretty low bar, especially for actually working without a huge amount of sysadmin.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoI wonder the same thing. Apple's MO is to make a premium version of a product and sell a huge quantity of them, and ideally it's a new product category. Right now there IS a category of vehicle that we don't have in the USA, the cheap small electric cars that have taken over in China. I could see semi-plausible arguments for mass adoption of those in the USA, as secondary cars for short errands and beginner drivers, and if they were cheap. But Apple's move is to sell the nicest, most expensive version of a product. It's sort of what their position in the market demands. I don't see any way to put those requirements together in a vehicle, especially considering how we can't import cars from China.
- _ea1k 3y agoA phenomenal commuter EV for between $25k-30k would do incredibly well in the US. It doesn't look like a huge market, mostly because there are enough alternatives that are all relatively similar. But an EV at a competitive price would take a very large slice of that pie.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y ago> especially considering how we can't import cars from China. Are you referring to the US tax credit rules around battery origins or vehicle import tariffs? Because there certainly isn’t an actual ban on Chinese-made cars in the US. You can go down to your local Buick or Volvo dealer and buy a Chinese-made car today.
- nlh 3y agoI thought and wondered this before I drove a Tesla, and then it all made sense. Teslas feel like what we would would have gotten with an "Apple car" had Tesla never launched -- next-gen hardware, software at its core, great UX, etc. What apple brings is, I think, the same thing they brought to cell phones when we all thought a Palm Treo was the pinnacle of mobile tech. The same basic ideas as Tesla, but better design, better hardware, better software, etc. I have no idea if they can actually pull it off, but if they can, they have a good shot at relegating Teslas to Palm Treo status.
- amirhirsch 3y agoMy primary purchasing criteria for my next car is how easy it is to recover my iPhone when I drop it between the seat and the center console. Surely Apple will solve this problem in an elegant way.
- int_19h 3y agoSure; you just drive it to the nearest Apple service center.
- rhuru 3y agoApple will come up with a car to signal wealth. Like a $20K camry disguised in $200K white colored unrepairable car which will demand money if you want to drive it outside your city.
- charlimangy 3y agoTesla has been setting fire to their brand, mostly by their CEO acting out. Apple has the affordable-luxury design chops to leap to the head of the class, as they did with the watch. Phone and Siri integration, plus I'm sure their product teams would come up with a bunch of great stuff. Maybe it's Apple Car built by BYD.
- resolutebat 3y agoElon's antics are wrecking Twitter, but Tesla is chugging along nicely all the same. Most of the world doesn't follow or care about Silicon Valley CEO drama in the same way that we here on HN do.
- eps 3y agoFWIW I cancelled Tesla order because of Musk. Wouldn't be caught dead driving one after the unhinge that keeps unfolding (and that is also very easy to pick up in the mainstream news).
- __d 3y agoAnecdata: I know multiple people who are intending to buy an EV for their next car, and all of them have removed Tesla from their list of possible purchases because of the CEO's behavior over the last couple of years. And sure, maybe I live in a "woke bubble", but that's a bunch of revenue that would almost certainly have ended up with Tesla that's now going elsewhere.
- rpmisms 3y agoAnd I know multiple rural people (who disagree with you on everything) who either have bought or are planning to buy Tesla vehicles because they're now affordable and really really good. Also, people who already own Teslas aren't going anywhere. Immense brand loyalty for good reason.
- __d 3y ago
- renewiltord 3y agoPeople say this about everything they make but they end up being better.
- huytersd 3y agoHaving taken 2 dozen Waymo rides, it’s all it’s cracked up to be. Confident driving, feels safe, clean. I just hope Google doesn’t decide to just turn around and kill it one day.
- gambiting 3y agoOf course they will. It's been billions spent on development to just offer you a slightly cheaper taxi ride, with no clear path to any kind of viable commercial service beyond "ok-ish" taxi provider in few American cities. Someone will get bored of it eventually and it will get shut down.
- xnx 3y agoNo Way[mo] that it gets shut down. Possibly split off and IPO'ed, but no one is going to throw away technology that is very close to cracking a multi-hundred billion dollar market.
- TillE 3y ago> no clear path The path is building an entire centrally-directed transit network out of custom vehicles. Waymo currently doesn't look anything like that because they're still doing R&D on the critical technology, but if we have good self-driving even in just nice weather, it's very easy to imagine a radical transformation of transit. Of course you can make money on that.
- gambiting 3y ago>> it's very easy to imagine a radical transformation of transit Really? How? Because I don't see it at all, and I don't think it's "very easy" either. All they have created is a very slightly cheaper taxi service. How does that transform anything? You could be taking a taxi instead of driving everywhere right now - why aren't you?(not literally you I mean people in general) Is that going to change if the ride is couple dollars cheaper? Of course not.
- kart23 3y agowaymo really isnt that confident. No way the avg human driver would be as hesitant as this. https://youtu.be/Y6GxDr0L-64?t=1589 https://youtu.be/Y6GxDr0L-64?t=1589 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kN0MLclnWa0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kN0MLclnWa0 https://youtu.be/XOuG1MQSvYM?t=1287 https://youtu.be/XOuG1MQSvYM?t=1287