4 ms·
Ask pg: I know the HN algo is secret, but can you explain something to me?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3909868
This story I submitted hit the front page, was starting to blossom into an interesting discussion, and suddenly dropped to #1204 (yes, I went down several pages to find it).
What gives?
- ig1 15y agoProbably got flagged
- tzz 15y agoMaybe the algorithm detected a voting ring. Did you ask your friends to vote up the link?
- DiabloD3 15y agoNope, in fact I don't think many people even know I have an HN account.
- igorsyl 15y agoI think the moderators have greater control over content than the ranking algorithm.
- DiabloD3 15y agoThen why have a voting system at all?
- allenbrunson 15y agoBecause it allows us to have some control over the site's content, rather than none at all. I agree with the commenter you're replying to: The moderators are really the ones in control here. And that's the way it should be. If this site was managed as a strict democracy, it would have been overrun with trolls and spam years ago, and we would have all moved on to something better.
- chc 15y agoIt probably got flagged. The penalty for a flag is greater than the boost from an upvote — it seems like even a 1:4 flag rate is enough to sink a story like a rock. Possible reasons for flagging include: • Deepak Chopra is widely considered to be a quack, but the article talks semi-approvingly of him • Although the general topic of the article is kind of interesting, the article itself says very little (sans quotes, it's seven very short and not particularly info-dense paragraphs) • The article seems a bit afield from the general focus of Hacker News, so people might have just thought it was OT clutter
- mattm 15y ago> Deepak Chopra is widely considered to be a quack Can you explain this a bit more? I'm just curious as I've come across his stuff before but never opposing views.
- chc 15y agoWell, his teachings are sort of a weird mix of medicine, psychology and pseudo-religious mumbo-jumbo, apparently borrowing and adapting liberally from anything that suits him. For example, he has repeatedly tried to tie his ideas into quantum mechanics, to the chagrin of physicists everywhere: http://www.skepticblog.org/2009/11/16/deepak-chopra-mangles-quantum-mechanics-again/ http://www.skepticblog.org/2009/11/16/deepak-chopra-mangles-... Needless to say, there are a lot of people to whom this does not signal credibility.
- itsprofitbaron 15y agoFWIW the HN algorithm isn't a secret[1] it's: (p-1)/(t+2)^1.5 Where votes are divided by age factor P = points from users T = time from submission in hours [1] http://www.seomoz.org/blog/reddit-stumbleupon-delicious-and-hacker-news-algorithms-exposed http://www.seomoz.org/blog/reddit-stumbleupon-delicious-and-...
- RiderOfGiraffes 15y agoBased on my experience, and measurements I've made over the years, I would say that one or both of two things happened: 1) You triggered the voting ring detection code, and/or 2) You got several downvotes. I do feel that there is a sizeable collection of people here on HN who, for whatever reason, don't like discussions about philosophy of consciousness and similar. If you get 10 or so downvotes and only 10 or so upvotes, your item will sink to the 1000s. I have seen it happen. (based on surmise about flags - they are not explicitly visible.) This discussion happened recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3890565 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3890565 The item was flagged dead, but the discussion is still there. HN remains a remarkably civil forum, and perhaps the occasional apparently draconian measures are part of the price to pay.