9 ms·
Proposed Oklahoma skyscraper gets redesign to become USA's new tallest building
- pjc50 3y agoThe densification people are winning, at least on one block. Is Oklahoma one of the flat states? I wonder how far away this will be visible.
- c0brac0bra 3y agoIf it's anything like this, I would say from quite a long ways: https://thelostogle.com/2024/01/02/tlo-unveils-plans-to-build-worlds-second-largest-skyscraper-in-oklahoma-city https://thelostogle.com/2024/01/02/tlo-unveils-plans-to-buil...
- jakespencer 3y agoI live 20 miles away from the current tallest building in Oklahoma (Devon Tower). If I stand on my roof (for an unobstructed view) I can see it clearly. This will be 1,907 ft tall vs 844 ft for the Devon Tower.
- chankstein38 3y agoThat's pretty incredible. I live in rural Appalachia so I'm only used to seeing mountains that way for the most part and the extreme flatness of the midwest has always been interesting to me. If this gets built I may have to check it out just for the distance views haha
- coffeebeqn 3y agoHaving been to many (lived in one) Midwest cities - one block is hardly winning the battle or the war. It’s still 99% parking lots.
- ta1243 3y agoI would guess the very top would be about 50-60 miles to the horizon, depending on refraction. That assumes a perfectly clear day. Oklahoma is about 4000 ft from the lowest point to the highest point.
- c0brac0bra 3y agoI haven't been to downtown OKC in a long while, but I don't call it having heaps of tall buildings. Having the tallest American building with not as much around it would look... interesting. In fact, I recall the construction of a lot of OKC being 60s-70s era squat concrete bunkers. That was 20 years ago so maybe things have changed but it was sort of a depressing feel.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- balderdash 3y agoLast time I was there I feel like there were probably at least a dozen buildings that were ~30-60 floors, definitely not anything close to this, but it’s not like it’s going to be around a bunch of 6-12 story buildings… I do wonder what the economics of the building look like
- apgwoz 3y agoMaybe it’s an intentional “middle finger” to the other US cities. Why else would you choose OKC for the tallest skyscraper? Literal dick measuring contest.
- voisin 3y agoI highly doubt the private developer is spending billions of dollars to give the middle finger to other cities. Clearly they see demand and are trying to fill that demand at a profit.
- allenrb 3y agoDevelopers can be very adept at making money for themselves even as the project tanks. Not saying that’s what will happen here (I lack data) but it happens often.
- apgwoz 3y agoHighly doubt? We’re in the midst of the biggest cultural clash in the US since the civil war, where the midwest is flanked on both sides of the country by liberal states/cities. There’s no question that developer isn’t doing this only out of spite—the need for space must be there, but imagine the board room scene in the movie… Architect/Urban planning: “we’ve designed a unique promenade with a four building complex, one that is primarily housing, next to shopping and office. A true “never leave your block” lifestyle with urban green space… Developer: “I’m gonna stop y’all right there. Let’s put up the tallest tower in the US to tell everyone watch out! OKC is back and ready for action! Just give the rest of those woke cities the biggest salute you can imagine!” Come on. The story writes itself!
- TriangleEdge 3y ago[flagged]
- frob 3y agoI think Oklahoma is just trying to prove everything isn't bigger in Texas.
- gretch 3y agoSince our ape brains evolved millions of year ago, we've always been fascinated with big, tall things. Stone henge, pyramids, etc It's not rational, but it is pretty fucking cool
- Workaccount2 3y agoYou would not have a hard time filling a 90th floor apartment if it meant taking the elevator down to their job.
- ladberg 3y agoThen I'll be the first person to tell you that I'd love to live on the 90th floor of a building... I don't have a family yet and am going to live in an apartment regardless, so why not have one with a great view?
- bombcar 3y agoI've little experience with "[being sent] to work in tall buildings" besides staying in hotels in the non-penthouse suites and it seems to me that usually the view you get is of a street and a building across said street. Obviously tall buildings make sense in places like New York where there are more people who want to live there than available dwelling units.
- ladberg 3y ago> a street and a building across said street I guess different cities have different distributions of building heights, but living in NYC I feel like this is accurate living on any floor <10 and inaccurate on any floor >=10 (roughly). Even in the densest neighborhoods the fraction of tall skyscrapers is pretty low so if you're 10 stories up you'll usually be able to see pretty far even though you're still surrounded by much taller buildings.
- aa_is_op 3y agoSoon to be empty tower... like all the recent skyscrappers. Just look at China struggling to fill theirs in so-called economical hotspots. You must be crazy to believe Oklahoma is a major business center these days.
- blisterpeanuts 3y agoI think China's difficulties stem from an excessive speculative bubble in real estate, based on the notion/hope that manufacturing and technology industries would continue high rates of growth. Oklahoma's main economic basis is oil and gas, plus some agricultural and manufacturing, which doesn't seem to justify a massive investment in corporate office space, especially in a city that is so spread out that working from home is a strong argument over driving 20 miles to work. But, maybe they're betting that oil and gas will make a rebound if there's a change in government in November, who knows.
- Ekaros 3y agoWhy does the picture make me think that much better use of resources would be to build more building of the size at bottom of this tower... Instead one of this is area where average height is not that high...
- bombcar 3y agoThere's a reason skylines are basically look the same (like a standard deviation graph) - after a very short height, it's only worth going taller if the land is insanely valuable. It's something like one or two floors in temperate areas, maybe a maximum of three in areas that get heavy snow. Especially for commercial buildings, additional costs start to climb quickly (a one-floor building needs zero elevators, for example) above about five floors.
- dylan604 3y agoI would say 4 stories as building codes say that up to 4 stories can use wooden structures. After that, more expensive materials are required
- tromp 3y agoTalking about supertall buildings in unexpected places... construction on the world's tallest building in Jeddah, that started over a decade ago but was halted for many years, is supposed to resume this year [1] (I'm not holding my breath). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeddah_Tower#Restart https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeddah_Tower#Restart
- ryanwaggoner 3y agoIs there a market in OKC for this much space at the psf you’d need to support developing it? Or is this some local billionaire’s vanity project?
- DHPersonal 3y agoThe way I see it is that it's an attempt to gain support by suggesting a two-phase construction project with only the intention of ever completing phase one — the smaller buildings.
- bombcar 3y agoThis is exactly what it is - you see these kinds of proposals all the time and the real reason is to make some other proposal look reasonable and a compromise.
- s3rv3rsi7e 3y agoIt looks like Biff Tannen's Pleasure Paradise from Back to the Future 2.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- southernplaces7 3y agoThe amount of sniffy negativism on this site is absurd. The building certainly does look out of place in OKC but so what? If the local council and zoning procedures approve it, then maybe, just maybe the people of the city don't mind too much. We'll see. A tiny bit of a sense of wonder at a new supertall, even if it's in an unlikely location is more of what I'd have expected from a site filled by supposed tech enthusiasts. Bear in mind also, the NIMBY bullshit of places like SFO has nothing to do with any housing problems or lack of them in Oklahoma City.
- browningstreet 3y ago[flagged]
- notyourwork 3y agoOwnership aside, what do you mean lobbying? My house is also the outcome of lobbying, it was built here because the city zoned the land in such a way that my house was able to be built.
- justrealist 3y ago> The amount of sniffy negativism on this site is absurd I don't want to be monocausal, but a lot of this is simply Europeans spending time on this site and voicing opinions about American architecture. It's well-understood that Europe doesn't build significant buildings anymore, and there's confusion about why a US city would want to build something large and noteworthy.
- sib 3y ago>> It's well-understood that Europe doesn't build significant buildings anymore, and there's confusion about why a US city would want to build something large and noteworthy. That seems a little unfair. For example, Philharmonie de Paris, France; Elbphilharmonie, Hamburg; The Shard, London; MAAT Museum, Lisbon.
- 3y ago
- jmathai 3y agoDoesn't seem like the author of the post is supportive of the proposal - but I'm also unsure if it's all parody. The renderings in this and a couple other articles look silly.
- jurassicfoxy 3y agoHaha, I had a good chuckle at the rendering with all the ads. The brew pub especially.
- TravisCooper 3y agoThis is awesome. A lot of good comes from colocating office work into a central building so the outlying areas can be used for "life affirming" purposes. Housing, parks, churches, restaurants, entertainment etc. We should want more "lone wolf" office buildings like this in every city.
- jl6 3y agoThey're rather expensive though, so you might be able to get more of what you like using the money differently.... instead of a single $750m 100-story tower in one block, build ten 10-story towers over 10* blocks, and you'd probably have $500m left over. * Realistically, you could pack the equivalent square footage into less space than this, because you can build shorter buildings wider.
- voisin 3y agoHow do you figure this? One tower has less than 10x the elevators, less than 10x the footings, less than 10x the roof area, etc etc etc., vs 10 smaller buildings 1/10 the size. There are massive economies of scale to density.
- gottorf 3y agoConstruction costs don't scale linearly with height, so I'd imagine the sweet spot of cost per square foot is a mid-rise building. But I admit I don't have the hard figures on hand.
- hvdtbb 3y ago[dead]
- nemomarx 3y agoYou might need more elevator banks per floor, though - a high capacity office building usually has more worries about routing the elevators and might have extra banks on middle floors that you switch to, etc I would definitely expect the elevator set up to be complex in a 90 floor building.
- brycewray 3y agoSpeaking as a nearly lifelong resident of Tornado Alley, I wonder how this thing, especially its upper floors, will fare the first time it meets up with a Moore-level storm (either 1999[0] or 2013[1]). [0]: https://www.nssl.noaa.gov/about/history/may3rd/ https://www.nssl.noaa.gov/about/history/may3rd/ [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Moore_tornado https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_Moore_tornado
- daxfohl 3y agoTaipei 101 has survived many a typhoon.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agotyphoon != tornado. I am sure they have something in mind, though. Japan is really good at designing skyscrapers that handle earthquakes. But whenever I see one of these skyscrapers, I wonder if Freud had a point...
- beej71 3y agoSometimes a skyscraper with balls is just a skyscraper with balls.
- hwbehrens 3y agoJust as a frame of reference, the most severe typhoon to directly hit Taipei seems to be Typhoon Morakot, which recorded wind speeds of 150 km/h (90 mph). The most severe tornado to hit Oklahoma seems to be from 1999, in which wind reached 484 km/h (301 mph).
- pie420 3y agoanother important point, typhoons are very big, so wind blows against a building in one direction. Tornadoes are very small, and would push on a skyscraper in multiple directions in the rare event that it hits a skyscraper and doesnt immediately dissolve due to lack of airflow. Airflow from multiple directions would mostly cancel out.
- troelsSteegin 3y agoThat looks like potentially a lot of people coming into and out of one city block, like a 10X spike in density relative to everything else. There's public transit in OKC, https://www.embarkok.com/ https://www.embarkok.com/ and https://www.odot.org/transit/s5307/okc.htm https://www.odot.org/transit/s5307/okc.htm, so maybe parking is not an issue, but the "flow" perspective will be interesting....
- qaq 3y agoI wonder if designers ever watched How I Met Your Mother
- bouk 3y ago> Between all four buildings, they will include 1,776 residential units America is incredible
- aweijr 3y agoNo mention in the article of whether or not the height increase is accomplished by adding a spire. Any idea what the max habitable floor height is?
- TSiege 3y agoIs there enough office space demand for a building this size in Oklahoma City? Seems like a strange time to be building giant buildings for office space. It seems like the smaller buildings will have some housing, but still strange.
- blisterpeanuts 3y agoHaving grown up in Okla. City, I am surprised and proud that they're contemplating this structure. If it comes to be, it's a sign of a can-do attitude that this region has always boasted. However, in recent years, earthquakes have become increasingly common in Oklahoma, probably because of oil and gas fracking projects in the eastern part of the state. Just the other day there were six earthquakes, including a 4.1 magnitude (one report stated 4.4 magnitude) quake in Oklahoma City. I assume modern skyscraper design can handle such events, for example designed to sway several feet in each direction, massive springs or other vibration suppressing mechanisms in the base as per Tokyo buildings, but it's still a bit worrisome. Tornadoes are also frequent phenomena; every spring, TV shows would be interrupted for tornado alerts or warnings on almost a weekly basis. You get used to it. But when it comes to a high rise building, the damage to windows could be massive.[1] Anyway, good luck to them and I hope the construction goes forward (and finds enough tenants to be worth it). 1. https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2023/12/18/proposed-okc-skyscraper-what-we-know-about-apartment-plans-financing/71958934007/ https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2023/12/18/proposed-okc...
- yowzadave 3y agoI think the odds that this gets built are slim to none--the economics won't make sense, because the property values in OKC don't warrant it. The only way it could happen is if the owner wanted to do it as a vanity project, and was willing to lose a lot of money. Anybody can make a drawing of a supertall building. It takes a lot to go from a rendering to actually building it.
- coldcode 3y agoHudson Yards in NYC makes sense on paper for that size/density of a city, yet it's a financial failure. Something like this building in OKC makes zero sense to even start.
- InitialLastName 3y agoEven Hudson Yards only made sense because they could use zoning shenanigans (drawing lines to put it in the same district as Central Park and a very poor area of Harlem [0]) to get state funding for it as an "economically troubled area". [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-12/the-visa-program-that-helped-pay-for-hudson-yards https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-12/the-visa-...
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoAny building above about seventy some floors gets taller by ego, not financial value.
- dylan604 3y ago>slim to none "and slim just left town" if you want to keep to the Western motif
- jqpabc123 3y agoSkyscrapers are expensive to build and maintain. They are built as a solution to high population density (the only place to go is up) combined with high demand and standard of living that can and will absorb the added cost. Oklahoma City fails to meet these criteria. To see this, compare OKC to a nearby major city like Chicago. - Population density of OKC is 1100 per sq. mile. Chicago is 12000. - Per capita income in OKC is $36K. Chicago is $46K. Based on demographics, this sort of tower in OKC looks out of place --- more like maybe a marketing/financing gimmick rather than a serious proposal. I doubt it will ever be completed as proposed because most bankers/financers are likely to reach the same, rather obvious conclusion. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/chicagocityillinois,oklahomacitycityoklahoma/PST045222 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/chicagocityilli...
- beams_of_light 3y agoIt is odd, because OKC is a large city, but it's not dense. However, the Bricktown area of downtown is a cultural hub, which hosts the NBA team as well as lots of dining and activities.
- jqpabc123 3y agoAtlanta, GA has 3 times the population density of OKC and it hosts NBA, NFL and MLB teams. All without any apparent need/justification for the tallest building in the country. There are lots of other similar examples. The justification for this in OKC just isn't there IMO --- and is unlikely to ever be there for one major reason --- limited water supply. https://www.koco.com/article/oklahoma-city-utilities-department-water-conservation-request/46446110 https://www.koco.com/article/oklahoma-city-utilities-departm... Major high density cities demand a large water supply.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoOKC is a bit weird, in that it's the center of a particular sort of religious movement. "Prosperity doctrine" types. The headquarters of Hobby Lobby and several other major "christian-owned" brands are there. This is more about them proving themselves ascendant, than anything else, if I don't miss my guess. A better model might be Dubai, also home to some famously tall skyscrapers... its density is probably lower than can justify those, but they were built anyway to prove how ascendant their form of Islam is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paxys 3y agoA tiny fraction of skyscrapers that are designed ever go up. At any point in time there are a dozen "tallest buildings in the world" on someone's drawing board, but when it comes time to build the money dries up. I'm not holding my breath for this one.
- skywhopper 3y agoWeird that the fact that this is in Oklahoma City specifically is left out. Yes, sure, that'd be the obvious choice, and I know most folks in the world and even the US would stop processing at "Oklahoma" anyway. But this is such a ludicrous project for OKC; why wouldn't it be in Tulsa or Muskogee or Bartlesville instead? Regardless, the money going into this would be so much better spent across a wider area of the city, where it could actually contribute to other development and revitalization. Take a look at the Renaissance Center in Detroit for a great example of a block of high-intensity development in a crumbling city that did nothing to help the city's overall state, and probably made things worse in the short to medium term.
- realityenigma 3y agoI'm not sure a lot of you have ever been to Oklahoma City or if you have, even recently. Tulsa is not the premier city in Oklahoma anymore and hasn't been for close to 2 decades. While this is a ridiculously tall proposed structure, Oklahoma City is growing fast and a lot of the residential domiciles in that area are full. 1,776 (a funny number) of housing isn't that much when we have entire subdivisions with 500 - 2000 houses going up all over the city at a constant rate. Will this be built, probably not. Will the smaller towers be built, quite possibly. I drive by the proposed spot often and it could support some of the smaller towers etc.
- Scubabear68 3y agoSelfish of me, but I wish we got out of the sky scraper business. I’ve had chronic and acute sinusitis for years, and one result is I get vertigo very easily. And buildings are designed to sway in high winds, which I can feel. I can’t describe how awful it is to have vertigo in a high building. I wonder how many other people suffer from this?
- stronglikedan 3y agoLots of people live on the upper floors of skyscrapers without issues. Therefore, it can be presumed that a lot of people don't suffer from your symptoms. Some people having some adverse effects doesn't seem like a good reason to completely abandon the skyscraper business.
- dcchambers 3y agoI love it, but how is this thing going to handle a direct hit from an EF4/5 tornado? A very, very real possibility for OKC.
- doodlebugging 3y agoI think the obvious answer is to consider that the ones financing this are already billionaires so all they really need to do is to spend some of that coin on a ballistic glass exterior skin that would function as a prophylactic, protecting the tower from anything swirling around in the Oklahoma City sky. The damage to the high-rise towers in the Fort Worth tornado was largely due to glass shattering causing the interiors to be open to the winds. This one practical step could be at least 87% effective against intrusion of debris from outside the protective skin and maybe up to 98% effective against dispersal of contents inside the ballistic glass prophylactic skin. That will solve the problem of lost documents, furnishings, etc that existed after the Bank One Tower in Fort Worth was hit by a tornado. They could even, for the science, use the central spire as a high altitude mount point for a radome so that they can issue weather forecasts and alerts well before the storms arrive. A nice, round white sphere on top of that spike would really dress it up in a way that is immediately useful to people all over the region. To take that a step further they can even use the central spire as a sensor launch point so that they can refine existing severe weather models. All they need to do is to use the central spire as a sort of skewer, grease it up with a durable, environmentally friendly lubricant, and set up a string of rounded sensor packages, like a string of pearls, that are lightly tethered so that when the inevitable tornadic winds pass nearby the updraft pulls those sensors off in a steady stream and carries them on the wind across the landscape. The tether should be light enough that the turbulent flow of the winds severs the tethers allowing them to maximize their dispersal. To aid in recovery of the data just color those sensor packages pearlescent white with a distinctive logo and make them large enough to be easily spotted once they come to rest on the ground and offer a reward to any Okie or anyone else downwind who returns one or reports finding one and you can get some useful science data about debris transport under severe weather conditions. You could even model the central opening to function as a whistle as they disperse so that they can be tracked as they travel on the winds. Years ago when the tornado hit Wichita Falls there was a guitar shop that had a large guitar on a pole outside. That guitar was found hundreds of miles away in Broken Bow, Oklahoma I think. As a Texan I think we should all support this, for the science.
- m3kw9 3y agoThat shape on top doesn’t allow for helipad, thought it was required
- fermentation 3y agoLove big buildings but this area is not very dense. Imagine a city downtown then make it 60% parking lots. Kind of convenient because of you don't have to worry about parking there but annoying once you want to walk to a coffee shop or something and realize it is a 15 minute walk.
- bluedino 3y agoMaybe it will end up as a 1100 foot tall unfinished eyesore, like that hotel in North Korea.
- Multicomp 3y agoSomewhere along the way, I came to the belief that the rebuilt One World Trade Center in NYC (1776 ft because we count the antennae as a spire) had been protected by a special law passed forbidding other buildings from exceeding that height so that it would retain a record height in honor of the 9/11 attack victims and responders. Does anyone else remember that being a thing? I can't find references after a few web searches and I'm trying to decide if I'm the only one or if this is a Mandela Effect thing.
- dylan604 3y agoThat would have to be a federal law passed by congress and signed by some president. Maybe some NYC law, but I can't imagine any other city in the US agreeing to that just because of some form of honor. If it turns out this is a thing, I will be thoroughly disgusted that we've spent effort on that vs something actual useful to the people.
- novolunt 3y ago[dead]