3 ms·
Unfortunately you've missed the point of why it is unethical, everyone else has to pay more to support your avoidance instead. If they paid their way then the
by mattmanser 15y ago
Unfortunately you've missed the point of why it is unethical, everyone else has to pay more to support your avoidance instead.
If they paid their way then the overall tax rate would be lower for everyone, instead of just for the rich. The irony being they're the ones who need it the least.
So effectively Bill Gates made the decision to make everyone else pay more tax so that he could go and cure Malaria in Africa. Causing babies to die in America instead. His tax avoidance can be indirectly linked to other people's deaths. That wasn't his decision to make and was unethical.
It's stealing but in a weird way. And by people who don't actually need to steal but just do it because they can.
- beagle3 15y ago> If they paid their way then the overall tax rate would be lower for everyone, instead of just for the rich. That is the truth in theory. In practice, the US federal government these days borrows 30% of the money it spends; the percentage has been growing through the years. If they paid their fair share of taxes, then either (a) the government would borrow less -- or, more likely (b) the government would spend more (and the population in general you may or may not be the beneficiary). The "if you pay less taxes I pay more taxes" only works in a closed system. IIRC, the last time the US wasn't, at the end of the day, a pure borrower is in the '70s. edit: fixed 50% to 30%. There's an underlying philosophical discussion, but I'll just use the official government number.
- olalonde 15y agoUh? What law says you have to pay more because some people legally avoid taxes?
- clarky07 15y agoThe rich not only pay far more in taxes by virtue of making more, they also pay more in relation to how much they make. The top 1% earns 17% of the income, and pays 37% of the taxes.[1] It's complete BS to say that Bill Gates following the tax code is unethical. [1]http://www.heritage.org/federalbudget/top10-percent-income-earners http://www.heritage.org/federalbudget/top10-percent-income-e...
- swombat 15y agoIn practice, all that happens if there are more taxes paid is that the government spends more money. Do you really think you would pay less tax if the government received a $100b windfall? Of course not. The way the government can cut its debt is by cutting its spending - the biggest slice of which is the military.