4 ms·
[stub for offtopicness]
by dang 3y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
- ken47 3y agoThe semantics of the title seem off and written by a non-scientist. A scientific theory cannot be proven, so the significant word choice of “confirm” is poor.
- Jensson 3y ago> written by a non-scientist Yes, journalists aren't scientists.
- ken47 3y agoShame that instead of highlighting one of the many great things that this man did, they use incorrect phraseology to claim he did something he didn’t do.
- Gimpei 3y agoWhy not? Are you making some oblique reference to Popperian refutationalism or is your point just that it’s very difficult to 100% prove something, so often it’s more a matter of a significant updating of priors? If it’s the latter, using “proof” doesn’t seem like the worst shorthand to me. Anything more involved would go over the head of the average nytimes reader.
- ken47 3y agoI assumed the average New York Times reader is above average in intellect and could appreciate an irrefutable word choice, like “advanced” in place of “confirmed.” I could be wrong.
- somenameforme 3y agoEvidence of [x] is not proof of [x], but in this specific case the claim is particularly unreasonable. Because while a cosmic microwave background radiation is something that would be expected from a Big Bang, its actual reality is weird and contradicted previous expectations. It has to do with casual connectivity. "A" can only possibly influence "B" if A could reach B at the speed of light. But the relative homogeneity of our universe is suggestive that parts of the universe which should not be casually connected, are causally connected. So this discovery quickly led to the invention of cosmic inflation [1] whereby the early expansion of the universe is said to have dramatically accelerated well beyond the speed of light, and then slowed down - in order to enable these regions of space to become causally connected. No possible means or mechanism have been suggested, so it remains nothing but a rather inelegant hack to try to make what we observe fit a preexisting hypothesis that it largely contradicted. As experiments to try to provide supporting evidence for inflation have also turned up negative, it's also becoming one of those contemporary model driven hypotheses that requires ever more exotic physics to even make it possible, as each failed prediction gets assimilated into the model to make it keep fitting what we see. Just add more epicycles. [2] [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology)#Motivations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation_(cosmology)#Motivati... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hoc_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hoc_hypothesis
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mr_mitm 3y ago> A scientific theory cannot be proven, Yes, that's why the title doesn't say "Physicist proves Big Bang theory"
- TheRoque 3y ago"confirms theory" I know it's valid, but it sounds weird
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mocha_nate 3y agoI agree. Makes me think someone over-spiced the headline
- cryptonector 3y agoHow is it valid? "Conforms" to theory would be OK. "Tends to confirm" would be OK. "Fails to disprove" would be OK. We don't "confirm" theories. We don't "prove" theories.
- eisvogel 3y agoTired light forever!!!
- flykespice 3y agoWhat does it means to confirm a theory?
- cryptonector 3y agoIt's unscientific nonsense.
- mr_mitm 3y agoWhat are you all on about? This phrase is used all the time in science.
- cryptonector 3y agoSince Karl Popper we take science to be the development of falsifiable theories and experimentation to show them to be false (therefore ruled out) or not-false, therefore still theories. We don't say that General Relativity is proven -- we say that it is in agreement with all experiments carried out so far. One does not 'confirm' the Big Bang theory. One finds evidence that does not disprove it. Or one finds evidence that does disprove it, then someone (possibly the same person or persons) elaborates a variant of that theory, or a whole sale replacement of it. Note the prominence of the need for falsifiability in the following: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method https://www.google.com/search?q=karl+popper+falsification+quote https://www.google.com/search?q=karl+popper+falsification+qu... So, yes, speaking of how a Nobel physicist "confirmed" the Big Bang [theory] is unscientific nonsense. What should one expect though? It's a headline in the New York Times, not Nature! My above comment is at -3, which normally I'd not care about, but collective ignorance of what the scientific method is is a bit depressing.
- dotnet00 3y agoYou're acting like the people posting here don't know that about theories. Language works within contexts, and the context for "confirm" in science reporting tends to be finding strong supporting evidence. Since the discovery of the CMB ruled out a large chunk of the other theories and left the Big Bang as the leading candidate, it obviously fits the finding strong supporting evidence case. We see similar titles every once in a while when someone does a new kind of test for relativity too.
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- passedandfuture 3y agoIt's clear by the title an athiest wrote this.
- Jensson 3y agoWhy couldn't god have created the big bang? Science has nothing to do with religion.
- ken47 3y agoA scientific theory cannot really be "confirmed." The word choice is suspect. The Big Bang Theory is consistent with many properties of the known universe, but cannot adequately explain others. Claiming it is the ground truth takes a leap of faith, which however small compared to religion, requires a measure of faith as implied.
- Jensson 3y agoWhat does that have to do with atheism? You don't think that people who believe in God sometimes makes mistakes when picking words?
- ken47 3y agoIt begs the question as to whether the author of the title actually believes the Big Bang is confirmed from a scientific point of view. That would suggest an atheistic belief.
- pvg 3y agoYou're conflating confirmation with some type of irrefutable proof which is both pedantic and plain wrong.
- ken47 3y agoThe job of people who write titles like this is to be very pedantic about word choice. I’ll have to disagree with you on this being a “plain wrong” interpretation of the given wording.