4 ms·
I'm not sure you're right to single out corporations here. It seems like all the Real People I know who are aware of simple things they could do to pay less in
by Symmetry 15y ago
I'm not sure you're right to single out corporations here. It seems like all the Real People I know who are aware of simple things they could do to pay less in taxes end up doing them as well.
- jbooth 15y agoDifference being that Real People can't spend 10 million setting up foreign subsidiaries in order to avoid taxation on a billion in income. Different math comes into play when you can fill an office building with lawyers for your tax policy.
- olalonde 15y agoOn the other hand, they can much more easily pass under the radar.
- jbooth 15y agoBut then you're talking fraud and running a big risk.
- Symmetry 15y agoNo, but I know plenty who pay H&R block to help them find all the deductions they're eligible for. This doesn't come out to 10 million, but the income they're sheltering. Its true that large corporations benefit from economies of scale when they try to avoid paying any more taxes than they have to, but I don't see any moral difference between what they're doing and what everyone else does.
- beagle3 15y agoand, in addition to what jbooth wrote above - these corporations lobby for the laws to be changed in their favor. How many Real People do you know who have done that? And is setting up 4 related corporations in 3 different international jurisdiction a "simple" thing?
- Symmetry 15y agoIndividuals rarely do lobbying on their own, but I often see groups of farmers, homeowners, small business owners, or whatever forming groups to lobby congress for their own benefit. They're solving a harder coordination problem to do so, but it doesn't seem that different. Likewise, when a person devotes some small fraction of their resources to tax avoidance and a corporation devotes the same fraction, the corporation's results are going to be much more impressive and complex than the persons. But I'm not sure that's a reason to condemn the one and not the other.
- beagle3 15y ago> I often see groups of farmers, homeowners, small business owners, or whatever forming groups to lobby congress for their own benefit. And how successful are they, compared to corporations? The problem is that by lobbying clout making a difference, corporations are thousands of times more effective than the number of people they represent. (And it's usually an accepted deduction for them, unlike most other groups) > Likewise, when a person devotes some small fraction of their resources to tax avoidance and a corporation devotes the same fraction, the corporation's results are going to be much more impressive and complex than the persons. But I'm not sure that's a reason to condemn the one and not the other. The answer you're going to get as a person if you do that (especially if you get creative with multinational tricks) is "I'm not sure I'll be able to defend that in court. And if I can't, you're going to jail". However, if you do it as a corporation, the worst you'd do is to pay back taxes (perhaps with some small penalty). Sarbanes Oxley theoretically makes the CEO personally liable, but I haven't heard of a case where one was prosecuted that wasn't downright fraud. Do you know of any case in which a corporate executive faced personal liability for creative tax planning? I do know cases where persons creatively planning their own taxes faced such liability. And I think that makes it good enough reason to single out one and not the other.