4 ms·
> You're going to get fewer, more expensive products. That last much longer.
by stavros 3y ago
> You're going to get fewer, more expensive products.
That last much longer.
- financypants 3y agoProblem is sometimes you can get by with an off-off-brand product (it’s hit and miss). Many folks don’t buy the “spend more and you will get something MUCH better that will last you for years!” sales pitch. Also a lot of people wouldn’t be able to start fronting (or financing) more money for a better, more repairable product.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoYes they would, because there would be a lot of used items that fill the exact same role as a new junk item.
- financypants 3y agoGood point. The used market would likely be much more active and valuable.
- herbst 3y agoSwiss here. I would argue we have a big 'buy good, don't buy twice' community because a high percentage simply can. Can confirm that our second hand markets are filled with great, high quality, often well taken care of, products.
- sparker72678 3y agoPossibly! I just think we should be clear about what tradeoffs are being proposed. This isn't all fairy dust and magic, and the average person doesn't have the background to understand the impact of proposals like this.
- mistrial9 3y ago> the average person doesn't have the background to understand yes agree - so there must be manufacturing standards and product testing. Similarly it is established law that some products are inherently unsafe. The law must always adapt to new techniques, materials and chains of distribution.
- trey-jones 3y agoAny system of standards and testing can be gamed. It's better for the average person to better educate themselves on purchases. I don't know how realistic this is. Additional difficulty is added by the amount of (mis/dis)information available to consumers. Very few sources are trustworthy and your mileage may vary of course. Adjacent to this issue is the broader issue that rampant capitalism encourages rampant buying of stuff - often stuff that we don't need, and surprisingly often stuff we don't even want. Think Gift Giving culture nowadays. With fewer things to purchase, more effort could go into the important purchases, I would think.
- throwaway15858 3y agoI've thought about this and there's no way to condense a multivariate notion of product quality into a scale. The best I've come up with is that all products should have to prominently advertise their years of warranty support. This creates an incentive for products to last longer than the warranty and makes comparison shopping easy.
- crazygringo 3y agoBut that's not always a good thing. People's needs for products change, and products themselves improve to gain features, become more energy efficient, etc. I do not want to be running the air conditioner I had from thirty years ago. It used tons of energy, was noisy as hell, was ugly, didn't have a thermostat or timer or any other features we take for granted today. Same thing in the way all my lamps have been replaced with LED's, televisions became HD and then large screen and then 4K, office chairs got better ergonomics, and so forth. Making a CD player that lasted 4 decades would have been a total waste of resources. I honestly think we're at a pretty good balance point today. When something breaks, more often than not it's the case that the new version is a significant upgrade that was worth getting anyways.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ehnto 3y agoOur needs don't change, our expectations change, often due to marketing. Especially true for widgets that don't serve base needs. That's fine, we do want progress. But we should have the choice. Wouldn't you want to be in control of the decision? If your air conditioning cools you and you are okay with it's current efficiency, you should be able to repair it. It's not like corporations are building short lived products out of environmental concerns about efficiency. If you leave it in their hands, then the consumer loses control, and companies do the obvious. It also reduces competition and innovation in my view. Why try hard to R&D products people want to upgrade to, when you can just wait for their unit to break and sell them a mediocre upgrade.
- sokoloff 3y agoDon’t we already have that right to repair in practice for ACs and related? In the last 3 years, I’ve repaired 1 window AC (bad bearings on the motor shaft), 1 free-standing AC (bad bearings on the motor leading to motor failure), and 2 portable dehumidifiers (low refrigerant charge). None were particularly difficult and I could source a used motor ($18.50 shipped from eBay), source the bearings by measurement (under $16 shipped for 8 bearings though I needed only 2), and R410a is a commodity ($300 for a 20# tank, used about 1.5 pounds total). Would it be easier if Fuji and Samsung and LG and others ran a parts depot that I could buy from? Maybe, but I’m probably not going to buy new parts from them anyway.