3 ms·
It's very interesting to me that Apple's willing to push spatial audio mastering this hard. Because on the one hand, listening to spatial audio on headphones i
by crazygringo 3y ago
It's very interesting to me that Apple's willing to push spatial audio mastering this hard.
Because on the one hand, listening to spatial audio on headphones is fantastic -- I will absolutely never go back to regular stereo-through-headphones playback that sounds like comes from inside your head. Spatial audio feels like it comes from outside your head, and totally eliminates the "headphones fatigue" the inside-your-head sensation creates. And you can literally hear more detail in the music because there's more separation in the instruments.
But on the other hand, it's not super clear that spatial audio recordings are all that necessary for music, because the "Spatialize Stereo" setting works pretty well on its own. You don't need Dolby mastering -- my iPhone spatializes any stereo track already, doing whatever magic processing it does based on the relative volumes and delays of the same frequencies on the L/R channels.
I've tried listening to the same tracks using Apple Music's spatial masters, and in Spotify with the spatialized stereo version. The Apple Music versions feel maybe twice as "wide" with more separation between some instruments (and sounds are usually placed a bit differently). But on the other hand, it's not clear to me that that's actually a good thing. Because when I'm watching movies with my AirPods, I do want sounds from the left to feel like they're coming all the way from the left. But when I'm listening to music on the train or on a bus, too much spatial separation feels like it might be more distracting than desired. Spatialized stereo feels good enough to me -- I don't really see a huge benefit in remastering music in surround say, the way there has been a huge benefit in remastering movie audio from previous decades in surround.
But I guess we'll see. Especially with new speakers like the Sonos Era 300 [1] that are actually built to project spatial audio into a room -- so it's not just something for headphones anymore.
[1] https://www.sonos.com/en-us/shop/era-300 https://www.sonos.com/en-us/shop/era-300
- devindotcom 3y agoI don't mean to question your experience, but the inside/outside thing can very easily be a property of the headphones, not the mix. Certainly mixing it to emphasize that is a choice, but a good stereo mix is really not so fundamentally limited in its soundstage. It may be the producer's deliberate choice to have the voice here, the guitar there, etc, and automatic "spatializers" may moot that choice. But of course so may playing it via a single-channel Bluetooth speaker. It's up to the listener to provide the experience they like best, but I question the need to have Apple pushing this particular type of mix so hard.
- crazygringo 3y ago> the inside/outside thing can very easily be a property of the headphones, not the mix Not in any of my experience or knowledge. Literally every set of headphones makes it sound like both mono and stereo audio are coming from inside your head, unless the actual mastering is meant to provide an "outside your head" experience. Originally, the "outside your head" experience only came from binaural recordings, where two microphones were placed inside dummy ears on a dummy head. That led to the famous "virtual barbershop" audio track and similar. The "outside" effect comes from a combination of relative delays* and the head-related transfer function (HRTF) [1] -- how the shape of your head and ear affects the sound waves. Regular stereo mastering never uses any of these binaural effects, so it always sounds "inside", or "between the ears". Spatializing stereo, on the other hand, is Apple's (quite successful) attempt to create relative delays and the HRTF. It has nothing to do with the quality or specifications of your headphones, and rather everything to do with the audio signal. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head-related_transfer_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head-related_transfer_function *To be precisely accurate, I believe the delays are actually included as part of the overall HRTF.
- devindotcom 3y agoI don't think this is correct. The headphones themselves certainly have an large effect on the size and quality of the soundstage. Obviously encoding binaural delay and other psychoacoustic features is important too. But Apple is far from the first to do this kind of precision stereo manipulation.
- crazygringo 3y ago> The headphones themselves certainly have an large effect on the size and quality of the soundstage. They don't, not on its size. I'm not sure what mechanism by which you think they would? > But Apple is far from the first to do this kind of precision stereo manipulation. Certainly not -- I never suggested they were.
- devindotcom 3y ago