4 ms·
I wonder how the market will shake out… Generally I see AAA studios churning out Boring Shooter: 2024 Q1 edition. Pay $70 for the same engine, some balance twe
by bee_rider 3y ago
I wonder how the market will shake out…
Generally I see AAA studios churning out Boring Shooter: 2024 Q1 edition. Pay $70 for the same engine, some balance tweaks, and a new map. But their games are pretty because they are the only ones who can afford to buy millions to make assets.
Indie games are, of course, where all the interesting mechanics are invented.
If AI makes it easy to generate assets, why won’t the AAA studios feel the pain first? Of course, everyone would love a stable job, and it is really sad when they lose them. But the management just contributes coordination. Maybe we’re heading toward a world small teams can leverage AI to fill their skill gaps, they can make some actually interesting games, and the AAA studios can go extinct. The game shattering Steam records was made by like 10 people apparently, and I think they didn’t even use AI (as far as I know).
None of this puts food on the table now of course, but the future could be better.
- lmm 3y ago> If AI makes it easy to generate assets, why won’t the AAA studios feel the pain first? Because, as you said in your first paragraph, the AAA studios' USP is that their games look better. They have skilled artists, and for the moment generative assets aren't going to be able to match that - and they don't have to, for most purposes. Indie games using procedural generation is already a tradition, it's just going to kick up a notch, and then the low end of AA will start using it, and so on; I'm not saying this stuff won't eventually make it into the AAA games, but it's going to get there from the bottom up, and the low/middle-end - those studios that just barely kept a few artists on the payroll at the moment - will be the first jobs hit. > None of this puts food on the table now of course, but the future could be better. It'll be better for creative and original people. But those who were just getting by churning out good enough are in for a rough time.
- nottorp 3y ago> churning out Boring Shooter: 2024 Q1 edition Lovely description of current AAA drivel. Permission to reuse? :) I used to call those "Battlefield of Honor of Duty", but I think that name combination isn't current any more.
- bee_rider 3y agoI actually had Call of Fortnight instead but I figured didn’t want to argue about a particular brand, hahaha.
- ajmurmann 3y ago> Generally I see AAA studios churning out Boring Shooter: 2024 Q1 edition This seems very selective. Shooters seem to take up a fairly small portion of released AAA games these days and it's easy to find AAA games that don't fit this at all. We all know about Zelda ToTK, Baldur's Gate III, Alan Wake II, Mario Bros. Wonder, Hi-fi Rush. All games that came out last year, are AAA games and take risks and don't fit what you criticize at all. We even had debates about Dave the Diver which is a game from a major studio, but kept getting falsely celebrated as a indy hit. If anything the "boring shooters" like Cod and Medal of Honor are taking up less space these days. Fortnite might have started out as a shooter and is massive, but at this point it's hard to tell what it even is.
- JKCalhoun 3y ago> Generally I see AAA studios churning out Boring Shooter: 2024 Q1 edition. And I would not be surprised if this formula comes crashing down hard and people simply stop paying $70 for the same crap. It's happened before to too-comfortable corporate gaming companies and I won't be sad this time either.