7 ms·
Brave browser simplifies its fingerprinting protections
- alecsm 3y agoSo there's no light at the end of the tunnel. We remove the privacy settings because otherwise webs won't work.
- Erratic6576 3y agoI’ve lost hope. My amiunique.org fingerprint is always unique. I’d like my web browser to peach less on me. Websites don’t need to know my primary browsing language is en-gb, I’m rather proficient in other written dialects. They don’t need to fingerprint my audio setup. It seems like browsers were conceived at a time when surveillance capitalism didn’t exist and they still behave like thar
- Reptur 3y agoWhat I don't understand is, why can't we just have a browser that doesn't give any of those details that is used to determine unique a browser. It doesn't make sense to allow a website to have access to that info.
- asimpletune 3y agoI think we can? I mean, technically it's possible. Maybe it even already exists.
- Cu3PO42 3y agoThere are such projects. The problem is that so few people use such browsers that just having that browser is often enough to fingerprint you.
- santoshalper 3y agoThe most popular browsers are all funded by advertising, which has entirely consumed the web.
- shiandow 3y agoYou mean like the tor-browser? It's not that they don't exist it's more that they're pointless if they're not used by lots of people. Personally I'm more in favour of randomizing some of the properties. That way you don't need to rely on being unique. In the end it's all about how much information you're transmitting about your identity, and while picking a common value is one way of increasing entropy picking a random value is much more effective.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYou don't actually want that. Not giving up those details is information unto itself. You want a browser that gives up the same bits as everyone else's browsers so they can't tell it apart from the others.
- tiltowait 3y agoI've never understood why websites need to be able to get a list of installed fonts.
- wnevets 3y ago> I've never understood why websites need to be able to get a list of installed fonts. I assumed it was a left over from the early days of the web before fonts were a thing.
- jorvi 3y agoBrave actually has font protection I believe :)
- IX-103 3y agoTry implementing Photoshop as a web app without it.
- vdaea 3y agoI've never understood why someone would want to implement Photoshop as a web app.
- curtisblaine 3y agoGiven that the original Photoshop is a nightmare subscription service, I hope developers implement a version of it on all existing platforms.
- jopsen 3y agoTo some the browser is the platform, more than the operating system. You may dislike the move. For me it has made the linux desktop more feasible. I can order photos through a print shop online, without having to install a windows-only program (just as an example).
- jeroenhd 3y agoPhotopea.com is actually pretty great. It works on any device under the sun and it's free (ad supported, with a subscription if you don't want ads). It's good enough that I stopped pirating a copy of Photoshop ages ago. Not perfect, but pretty close to it.
- lolinder 3y ago> My amiunique.org fingerprint is always unique. A bit of an aside, but I love that their data set consists of 26% Linux users and 41% Firefox users.
- Erratic6576 3y agoIt’s the year of Linux on the desktop!
- AlexandrB 3y ago> It seems like browsers were conceived at a time when surveillance capitalism didn’t exist and they still behave like thar It's worse than that - the world's most popular browser was created by a company which gets most of its competitive advantage and, arguably, revenue from surveillance capitalism. The incentive to make fingerprinting hard is not just 0, it's negative.
- IX-103 3y agoFalse. https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/9682282?hl=en https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/9682282?hl=en Google doesn't like fingerprinting. That may be because they already have all your identities and don't want competition, but they still don't like fingerprinting.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Google doesn't like fingerprinting. That may be because they already have all your identities and don't want competition Google sells ads. Of course they don't want you rolling your own fingerprinting. That's their job. I'd need to see a statement signed under oath to believe Google, itself, doesn't fingerprint.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- everdrive 3y ago>amiunique.org fingerprint is always unique. Do we really have reason to believe this matters? Just because amiunique.org identifies users based on all possible metrics available from a website doesn't necessarily mean much: - We don't know whether other websites actually use this same technique to attempt to identify unique users. In other words, there's no indication that normal commercial websites are taking every possible measure of the browser, assigning a UUID to that configuration, and then attempting to build a fingerprint based on that, rather than just using cookies, and perhaps other, more basic fingerprinting. - A browser might give different metrics in private browsing mode, due to some plugins operating differently. - A normal website (eg: google.com) observes a much, much wider list of potential browser configurations than amiunique.org. There's no reason to think that you'd be just as unique when compared to a much wider selection of possible configurations. - Corporate solutions, such as fingerprint.com _can_ be tricked.
- handedness 3y agoUnfortunately that particular test telling everyone their fingerprint is unique isn't very useful. Try something like fingerprint.com, close your browser session, go back, and compare IDs. On Tor Browser or Mullvad Browser, it should generally register each session as your first session, with unique IDs. If not, the useful life of the tracking should be short. Relevant discussion: https://old.reddit.com/r/TOR/comments/qxt7di/tor_is_still_fingerprintable/hlcdx7v/ https://old.reddit.com/r/TOR/comments/qxt7di/tor_is_still_fi...
- Erratic6576 3y agoThanks for the explanation
- beretguy 3y ago> My amiunique.org fingerprint is always unique. Disable JavaScript. That helps a little bit. Keep js off by default on all websites, and enable it by individual bases. https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/disable-javascript/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/disable-javas... https://apps.apple.com/us/app/stopthescript/id1588394487 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/stopthescript/id1588394487
- encom 3y ago>primary browsing language is en-gb Related to this, being multi-lingual on the web can be annoying. If I set my language to da-DK (my native), some non-danish websites will serve a poorly translated or machine translated version. But if I set it to en-GB a lot of danish web sites will serve an english translation, which I also don't want. I have to fiddle with this setting a lot. I wish I could set da-DK only for .dk TLDs.
- krono 3y agoIf anything we need more settings, and more warning popups to go along with them that list or link to information on some of the breakage users can expect. Inform the user and let them decide.
- everdrive 3y agoAvoid the websites. Call companies, go to the library, or just abstain altogether.
- JohnFen 3y agoThis is the approach I've been taking. Outside of a handful of websites, the situation has become so intolerable that it's not really worth trying to find a way to safely use the wider web anymore.
- plantain 3y agoAvoid legitimate websites that Brave willfully and carelessly breaks?
- everdrive 3y agoAvoid websites which require a specific browser, and specific browser settings to function. In the vast majority of cases there's no reason why a site needs to scan my computer, use webgl, use webrtc, and a million other things which are used to track me. They're built poorly in this way because they're only testing against chrome, and are apathetic about privacy.
- mastazi 3y agoI recently had to purchase some audio plug-ins for music production. I was trying to decide between two bundles by two competing companies. They were pretty even, in my mind, in terms of pros and cons. Then I discovered that one of the two companies had a website that's broken by basic privacy settings, such as preventing autoplay for videos. I gave my money to the other company.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoOr write custom clients for any website you care about. Essentially scrapers for every site which will extract and present information without the website's code running.
- quincepie 3y ago"Fewer than 0.5% of Brave users are using Strict fingerprinting protection mode, based on our privacy-preserving telemetry data." I think this is likely because people who go on their way to switch to using strict mode are more likely to disable the telemetry as well.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's so obviously hilarious that I'm surprised they don't call it out, or if they don't want to draw attention to it, moved it into multiple sentences. "0.5% of our tinfoil hat purchasers wear it, according to our wearing-telemetry."
- bbertelsen 3y agoThe good old airplane damage diagram came to mind immediately!
- gia_ferrari 3y agoYou're referring to the visualization in this article? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoCan that telemetry be disabled at all? "Privacy-preserving telemetry" could mean that they consider it OK to make it mandatory.
- quincepie 3y agoYes, brave has 2 checkboxes in its settings page. One for crash reports and the other for privacy-preserving product analytics (P3A) which is what they are talking about here. Disabling those stops Brave from sending anything to brave endpoints, aside from auto update checks of course.
- karaterobot 3y agoI mean, this is a press release way of saying they're removing Strict fingerprinting protection, not that it's being simplified. That said, I get it. I have all the fingerprint protection stuff turned on in Firefox, and it breaks a lot of sites. In fact, it hurts the UX of most of the sites I use a lot, and completely breaks a lot of them. There are some critical websites where I just have to load up Chrome if I'm going to use them at all. And their point about it being self-defeating if so few people use fingerprinting protection that you can more easily identify them uniquely by the fact that they use it. I've wondered about that myself. So I think it's cool to get rid of it in their browser, and I like their explanation of the reasoning, I just don't like the weasel-word "simplify" to describe it.
- schmorptron 3y agoIs there a way to randomize a few inconsequential ones of these on each page load? i.e. subtle canvas rendering changes, report adding or removing a few installed fonts.
- FirstLvR 3y agoHey brave, get ride of crypto stuff and you’ll get users back You guy are actually building a good browser
- sjwhevvvvvsj 3y ago[flagged]
- mamidon 3y agoEveryone has to earn a living, not just people who have the same values as you.
- fwip 3y agoWhat does this comment mean? Just because he "has to" earn a living, doesn't mean people have to want to give him money.
- Phiwise_ 3y agoA CEO that sweetened the deal would set about turning brave into chrome and google search. You cannot both castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.
- smoldesu 3y ago> You cannot both castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful. You cannot mean to imply that Brave is worthless without Eich.
- slig 3y agoHopefully they too can find a lawyer to be a CEO of a tech company.
- louthy 3y agoIt’s pretty simple to turn all that off. It’s bloat, for sure, but can be made invisible. If they could just fix the back-button on Brave iOS so it doesn’t occasionally pick a completely different tab, I’ll be happy.
- wolverine876 3y agoI've seen Brave's fingerprinting strict mode on a users' computer, and they say they've had very few problems with it in 1-2 years of use.
- crimsontech 3y agoIt caused problems with dark mode for me. All sites displayed in light mode so I had to disable it.
- mastazi 3y agoThis is also my experience, I don't know why the linked post makes it look like a big problem, I very much disagree with them retiring strict mode.
- refactorguy 3y agoYeah, the only times I've had problems with it, it was because of WebGL. So I use Standard mode in like 2-3 sites, and Strict everywhere else. This is a bad move IMO
- jchook 3y agoLibreWolf[1] is a Firefox-based alternative to Brave, and appears to pass more privacy tests[2]. 1. https://librewolf.net/ https://librewolf.net/ 2. https://privacytests.org/ https://privacytests.org/
- Rehanzo 3y agoWhy is it an "alternative to brave" rather than just another browser?
- colordrops 3y agoBecause Brave is the topic of this thread.
- DavideNL 3y agoNo, https://privacytests.org/ https://privacytests.org/ is misleading, it shows only the results of the default browser settings - which absolutely nobody uses. Worst part is, they don’t even mention this…
- bimguy 3y agoYou are wrong. The very top of the chart reads: "Desktop Browsers (default settings)"
- DavideNL 3y agoAh, they have added it now, good! (I suggested them to add it as info, some time ago...)
- autoexec 3y agoi think that's important because most users will only use the default settings. Firefox would be the clear winner if they didn't use default settings because they give you so much more control and customization than other browsers. Even without add-ons, about:config lets you really lock firefox down.
- 3y ago
- klabb3 3y agoCould fingerprinting without consent be considered illegal data collection under gdpr? Why not? I thought device identifiers were included.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoIf it's not then it sure as hell should be. I'll go even further and say it should be considered an illegal search and a violation of personal integrity, both of which justify violence in self-defense.
- okokisay 3y ago[flagged]
- neilv 3y agoTor Browser does letterboxing for anti-fingerprinting of usable window size, which can be kinda painful, with sometimes large margins of lost display space. Any current thoughts on this, and on Brave's approach? I see a request for letterboxing in Brave, and a PR that does randomizing of some values instead: * https://community.brave.com/t/feature-request-letterboxing-in-brave-browser/502392 https://community.brave.com/t/feature-request-letterboxing-i... * Bug 23170: anti-fingerprinting: hide screen size and window position #13737 https://github.com/brave/brave-core/pull/13737 https://github.com/brave/brave-core/pull/13737 (Incidentally, that PR number is not quite elite. :)
- mancerayder 3y agoCan you explain letterboxing to a non front-end dev?
- neilv 3y agoNormally, a browser window has a rectangular area of the display that is "visible" and used for the Web page, with browser controls and scrollbars and window decorations around it. To a company that wants to identify who the person is (such as to build a profile of the person and sell that information) one way is to "fingerprint" the browser and how it's used. The dimensions of that visible display rectangle help with this, since individuals will often tend to end up with a window size that's more particular to them than of all possible users. One browser anti-fingerprinting privacy feature targets that telltale rectangle size, with "letterboxing" (different from movie letterboxing). Which means that range of different visible rectangle dimensions of what could be many users get reduced to the same smaller rectangle dimensions. Which (like movie letterboxing) results in large unused margins for all users. So, say that you have a 1920x1080 native window size, including all the decorations and controls. That's a pretty common size, and doesn't fingerprint you very well at all. But your particular preferences for things like window decorations and font sizes and such narrow that down quite a bit. And if you don't have a common display size, nor a maximized window, but you tend to have the window the same size, that can fingerprint you even more. With letterboxing, your 1920x1080 native window might give you, say, a 1600x800 display rectangle for the browser page. And a bunch of other people's native windows, of various sizes in the vicinity, and of various desktop settings, will also get the same 1600x800 display rectangle. With letterboxing, everyone is wasting precious screen space, but they're supposedly harder for adversaries to identify. I'm not thrilled with the tradeoff here. Though it's easier to stomach when so many Web sites make poor use of the display anyway, I've been desensitized. (Sorry, I'd make this explanation shorter, if I had more time.)
- plantain 3y agoGood. Brave's fiddling with WebGL causes >50% of my bug reports from 1% of users. [1] https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/issues/10518 https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/issues/10518 [2] https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/issues/8377 https://github.com/mapbox/mapbox-gl-js/issues/8377