2 ms·
> let me assure you that the very act of trying, will result in massive war, death, violence, and destruction. How is that different from the status quo? War,
by latexr 3y ago
> let me assure you that the very act of trying, will result in massive war, death, violence, and destruction.
How is that different from the status quo? War, death, violence, and destruction haven’t stopped for one bit since the inception of humanity.
> Worse, as if you believe it is not intelligent.
That is debatable. We’re capable of reasoning, sure, but that doesn’t mean we’re making the most intelligent decisions. See climate change and the aforementioned wars.
> I would raze everyone and everything involved to the ground. I'd probably want to have the offspring of those involved, and all family members of said persons, rendered infertile, just to ensure the flawed genes of those insane enough to try, didn't spread.
> Why? For the safety and security of the human race!
It’s easy to rally against a hypothetical. Are you doing any of that against real problems of today which are demonstrably harming the human race? I’ll mention again war, climate change, and let’s throw in attacks against democracy. All are happening right now and there are clear people we can point to that are making all of those worse.
> Humanity must either get there on its own, or it must die. There is no middle ground. "Parenting" humanity will result at best in stunted growth, will result in no change, at worse will result in stagnation, regression, and the loss of who we are.
Look, I’m not at all defending humanity being controlled by an artificial intelligence, but all of this is hyperbole. The truth is we don’t know. It could just as well happen (and again, I’m not defending we should try) that humanity could be “parented” just enough to get back on track and the left on its own to flourish. That’s what parenting is. It’s temporary guidance, it’s not meant to last forever.
> And we are Great. We are Good.
Meh. Highly debatable. All the other species we share the planet with would likely disagree.
> My response is predicated upon two core beliefs, and crafted with understanding of historical context. It is reasoned, considered over decades of thought, and not awash with emotion.
Yet it reads borderline unhinged and like the IRC kids who when mocked say they have the other person’s IP address and will send the FBI to their house.
Heck, I should be agreeing with you on principle yet I won’t because I don’t want my arguments and thoughts associated by such extremist-sounding rhetoric.
Quite honestly I think you’re doing a disservice to your cause. If this is the result of decades of thought, please take a few more weeks to rephrase it in a way that is thoughtful to the other side and has any chance of convincing them. Because as it stands, I believe you’re pushing away those who could agree with you. And you’re not going to stop any of the things you worry about alone.